TLDR
Michael Popach and Lisa Graves discuss the Trump administration's aggressive posture toward congressional oversight, highlighted by White House Counsel Will Sharf's threatening letters to incoming Democratic committee chairs. They analyze Sharf's far-right Missouri network connections, the Supreme Court's defensive PR campaign — Alito at the Federalist Society and three justices on Fox News — and preview December oral arguments on guns, transgender care, and voting rights.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Leonard Leo's Federalist Society received a $1.6 billion trust from Barre Seid only after Leo successfully placed three justices on the Supreme Court, after which Leo purchased a Maine mansion and church and paid off his mortgage.
Alito claimed Congress cannot diminish justices' salaries but ignored that Congress controls every other aspect of Court funding — including the number of law clerks, the Court's building, and even whether the lights stay on.
The Federalist Society's biggest funder is anonymous, while law firms with cases before the Court contribute to the organization that handpicked the justices hearing those cases.
Will Sharf ran for Congress in Missouri and lost — Missouri voters rejected him before he became White House Counsel with authority to threaten elected officials nationwide.
Key takeaways
Will Sharf, the new White House Counsel, sent preemptive letters threatening incoming Democratic committee chairs like Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia, claiming their planned investigations are frivolous and warning of vigorous resistance from the administration.
Sharf emerges from a Missouri far-right network cultivated by Leonard Leo and the Federalist Society, including Josh Hawley, Eric Schmitt, and Ed Martin — a pipeline that has placed loyalists in key positions to shield Trump from accountability.
The administration's letter cites the 1957 Watkins case to argue Congress cannot investigate for 'improper purposes,' but Graves notes this ignores Congress's constitutional duty to oversee executive branch corruption and spending abuses.
Justice Alito used his Federalist Society speech to claim Congress has no power over Supreme Court ethics or size, ignoring Article III's grant of congressional authority over jurisdiction, the Judiciary Act of 1789, and Congress's power of the purse.
Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, and Barrett appeared in a Federalist Society-produced video on Fox News defending the Court's legitimacy — an unprecedented PR campaign that Graves calls 'infomercials' rather than legal decisions, funded by dark money including Leonard Leo's $1.6 billion Barre Seid trust.
The 2024 election exit polls showed democracy as a top-three voting issue, contradicting years of conventional wisdom that democracy 'doesn't poll well' — voters punished efforts to restrict ballot access and manipulate electoral rules.
Congress retains multiple leverage points over the Court: setting its size, controlling its budget (including clerk allocations), defining its appellate jurisdiction, and imposing ethics rules via the Government Ethics Act of 1978 — all of which Alito's speech attempts to deny.
December oral arguments include Vermont v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins (AR-15 bans), International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson (parental rights in gender transition care), and RNC v. MAI Vote (Arizona documentary proof-of-citizenship requirements).
Notable quotes
“It's it's it's offensive and ridiculous. And I think it just, you know, it reminds me a little bit like when I was way way way back when when I was a law clerk at some private law firms, sometimes there'd be some client who would come in and be like, I want a letter. Send them a letter.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:20“Congress has the power to determine the jurisdiction of the court beyond the jurisdiction set by the Constitution.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:02“They literally invented immunity from criminal prosecution for Donald Trump even though the Constitution A does not give any president such immunity and B structurally requires checks and balances.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:54“I don't need a speech about them defending the rule of law. I need decisions, right? The American people deserve decisions of law, not infomercials.”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:55“The one thing the Constitution bars Congress from doing, and it's one thing, is to de dim diminish their salary while in office. They can't diminish. But everything else, they could say, 'Look, we're not going to give you four clerks. We're going to pay for only two clerks for you justices since you're only doing 60 decisions.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:27“This is a guy who's a longtime you know affiliate of the sort of Leo gang in Missouri that includes Ed Martin, the guy who, you know, was basically put in at the Justice Department as the pardon attorney while Trump was running rampant on pardons.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:23Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Will Sharf's threat letters: Hosts introduce the episode focusing on White House Counsel Will Sharf's letters threatening incoming Democratic committee chairs, framing it as unprecedented executive branch intimidation of congressional oversight.
5:26 — Will Sharf's background and Missouri network: Graves details Sharf's origins in Leonard Leo's Missouri pipeline — including Josh Hawley, Eric Schmitt, and Ed Martin — and how this far-right network places loyalists in power to protect Trump.
7:18 — Analysis of Sharf's Fox News clips: Hosts play and dissect Sharf's interview citing Watkins v. United States to claim Congress investigates for improper purposes, while Graves and Popach rebut that Congress has a duty to investigate corruption.
15:23 — Election results and democracy messaging: Discussion of 2024 election results showing democracy as a top-three voter concern, the failure of voter suppression tactics, and the need for Democrats to reclaim the 'democracy' brand from Republican framing.
23:18 — Alito's Federalist Society speech: Alito claims Congress lacks authority over Court ethics, size, and jurisdiction; Graves systematically refutes each point citing Article III, the Judiciary Act of 1789, and Congress's power of the purse.
33:21 — Justices' Fox News PR campaign: Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, and Barrett appear in a Federalist Society-produced Fox News video defending the Court; hosts criticize it as unprecedented political campaigning funded by dark money to cover controversial decisions.
36:22 — Upcoming December Supreme Court cases: Preview of December oral arguments: AR-15 ban cases (Vermont v. Cook County, Grant v. Higgins), parental rights in gender transition care (International Partners v. Ferguson), and Arizona proof-of-citizenship voting requirements (RNC v. MAI Vote).
Speakers
Michael Popach — Host
Lisa Graves — Co-host / Expert