Live From Boston (Night 1) | Reading Reddit Stories

Original Media · 1h 30m · English · YouTube · Smosh Pit

TLDR

Smosh's live 'Reddit Stories' show in Boston features host Shayne with guests Tommy, Olivia, Anthony, and Amanda reading and reacting to six Reddit posts. Stories include a woman walking out on a date after learning the man was 'shreking' (dating less attractive people on purpose), a father mocking his daughter's boyfriends as 'Baskin Robbins flavors,' a boyfriend demanding his girlfriend build a bigger butt via squats, a man realizing he's mispronounced 'Parmesan' his whole life due to his Boston accent, a man listing his future sister-in-law's staggering ignorance, and a Magic: The Gathering card dispute that may lead to divorce.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The term 'shreking' is an actual documented dating trend, not something the date made up in the moment.

•

The father in the Baskin Robbins story posted an update during the live show announcing he would stop the joke and learn the boyfriends' names.

•

The boyfriend in the 'ass audit' story had previously convinced his girlfriend to attempt squats for a year, making her complicit before she realized the toxicity.

•

The Magic: The Gathering collection was transported in five briefcases, suggesting either extreme bulk or high-value cards.

•

The husband in the Magic story told the recipient to keep the money from sold cards ($500) and intended to make his wife repay him, signaling serious marital fracture.

Key takeaways

•

The 'shreking' dating trend involves deliberately dating people you find less attractive to avoid drama, but the man in the first story weaponized it to insult his date while simultaneously bragging about his own looks.

•

The father calling his 17-year-old daughter's boyfriends 'Baskin Robbins' seemed like a harmless joke until Reddit comments revealed it was belittling her normal teenage dating experience and could damage their relationship.

•

The 'ass audit' story highlights how some partners impose impossible body standards — the boyfriend expected his size-2 Asian girlfriend to build glutes through squats despite genetics, while openly staring at curvier women.

•

The Boston accent story reveals how regional accents can create blind spots — the OP mocked women for over-pronouncing 'Parmesan' with an R, only to discover he'd been saying 'pamasean' his entire life.

•

The future sister-in-law story sparked debate: while her factual ignorance was extreme (believing Santa until 16, pink lemons exist, Obama gave the 'I Have a Dream' speech), the brother-in-law's contempt and focus on embarrassment over kindness made him the asshole to most listeners.

•

The Magic: The Gathering dispute centered on a coworker gifting her husband's valuable card collection without his knowledge; the recipient sold some cards but returned the rest, and the husband's calm reaction contrasted with his wife's deception, potentially ending their marriage.

Notable quotes

“To be honest, nothing much but prettier girls are too much drama, so I was trying this thing I saw called shreking.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:24

“I bet you're glad for this trend. How does it feel to be on a date with someone so handsome?”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:10

“You're (beep) ugly inside and out.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:00

“Why don't you go build me a (beep) house?”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:01

“I have lived my life honestly believing that Parmesan was pronounced pamasean.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:24

“She thought Obama did the 'I have a dream' speech.”

▸ Notable quotes · 64:09

Chapters

•

6:02 — Shreking Date Story: A woman walks out on a first date after the man admits he's 'shreking' (dating less attractive women to avoid drama) then brags about his handsomeness. Guests are horrified and validate her reaction.

•

15:02 — Baskin Robbins Father: A father calls his daughter's revolving boyfriends 'Baskin Robbins flavors.' Reddit verdict: he's the asshole for belittling her normal teenage dating. He later updates he'll stop the joke.

•

28:08 — Ass Audit Breakup: A woman dumps her boyfriend after he texts that he hasn't had 'access to an ass' in 1.5 years and blames her for not building glutes via squats despite being size 2 and Asian.

•

45:14 — Boston Accent Parmesan: A man with a Boston accent mocks girls for fake accents, then realizes he's pronounced 'Parmesan' as 'pamasean' his whole life after his girlfriend makes him Google it.

•

55:14 — Stupid Sister-in-Law: OP lists future sister-in-law's ignorance: believed Santa until 16, thought pink lemonade comes from pink lemons, didn't know Trump actor/president were same, stared at eclipse, thought blood diamonds are made of blood, didn't know platypuses real, thought 100 million not a real number, moon produces light, Obama gave 'I Have a Dream' speech.

•

75:54 — Magic Cards Dispute: Coworker gifts husband's Magic: The Gathering collection (five briefcases) without asking. Recipient sells some valuable cards. Husband wants collection back, is chill about sold cards but plans to make wife repay the $500, possibly divorcing her.

Speakers

•

Shayne — Host

•

Tommy — Guest

•

Olivia — Guest

•

Anthony — Guest

•

Amanda — Guest

•

Emily — Director

⋮