FINAL Midterm Polls Point to a NIGHTMARE for Trump and Republicans

Original Media · 1h 25m · English · YouTube · Pod Save America

TLDR

Pod Save America hosts Jon Favreau, Jon Lovett, and Tommy Vietor analyze the final Time/Siena polls before the 2026 midterms, showing Democrats leading in key Senate races across Michigan, Kansas, Alaska, Texas, Iowa, Ohio, and Maine. They dissect Trump's bizarre final rally focused on White House renovations and algae, Tucker Carlson's claims about a potential nuclear strike on Iran, and Haley Stevens' chaotic endorsement flip-flop in Michigan. The hosts debate whether Democrats' apparent strength reflects a genuine shift or polling errors, and what the results would mean for 2028.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Trump's final pre-midterm rally focused almost entirely on White House renovations, algae, and sod rather than any policy or political message.

•

Roger Marshall's own campaign staff refused to air his self-made defensive ad about medical debt collections, so he emailed it to random people to post online.

•

Haley Stevens went to church with Mike Rogers and held a press conference endorsing him hours after telling Debbie Dingell she would not endorse him.

•

The Time/Siena poll shows Abdul El-Sayed winning 96% of Kamala Harris voters in Michigan, up from 91% in September, despite the Haley Stevens controversy.

•

Vivek Ramaswamy's gubernatorial campaign in Ohio has become so toxic that even Republican voters are turned off, potentially helping down-ballot Democrats.

•

Alaska voters in a focus group were dismissive of the 'two Dan Sullivans' ballot stacking scandal, saying 'we knew this was happening the whole time, you have to think we're idiots.'

Key takeaways

•

The final Time/Siena polls show Democrats leading in seven competitive Senate races, including deep-red states like Kansas (Adam Hamilton +5), Texas (James Talarico +3.5), and Alaska (Mary Peltola +2), with Abdul El-Sayed up 11 in Michigan and Sherrod Brown up 5 in Ohio.

•

Trump's closing midterm event at the Lincoln Memorial devolved into a 30-minute monologue about White House renovations, algae in the reflecting pool, and sod quality, which the hosts say reveals his staff has lost all control over him and he no longer cares about conventional politics.

•

Haley Stevens' last-minute endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers over Democrat Abdul El-Sayed — after telling colleagues she wouldn't — backfired spectacularly; her incoherent CNN interview and shifting demands exposed a double standard, as she made no similar demands of Rogers despite his racist campaign.

•

Roger Marshall's campaign in Kansas collapsed into chaos when he bypassed his own staff to film a defensive ad admitting his practice sent patients to collections, claiming 'I never had anyone arrested' while ignoring that patients were jailed for missing court summonses over medical debt.

•

Tucker Carlson published a long post citing anonymous sources claiming Trump may launch a nuclear strike on Iran's Pickaxe Mountain; Tommy Vietor assesses this as likely Gulf state disinformation, though a conventional MOAB strike is plausible for Trump's headline-seeking.

•

The hosts agree that anything short of winning both chambers will feel like a loss given Trump's unpopularity, the Iran war, and tariffs, but note that even a narrow Senate loss would be historic — the president's party rarely loses more than one Senate seat he carried by double digits.

•

Democrats' strongest Senate candidates (El-Sayed, Talarico, Hamilton, Turick) are running ahead of fundamentals in red states, but late-deciding voters are breaking Republican by +9 in polls, reflecting the natural partisan lean of states Trump won by double digits.

•

The hosts identify three factors that would explain a Democratic underperformance: persistent polarization making midterms about team loyalty, the failure of economic pain to override partisanship, and the overwhelming impact of billionaire spending (Musk, crypto) in races like Texas.

Notable quotes

“He's talking about sod.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:18

“If we don't win this one, pack it in, guys.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:13

“I think he just doesn't give a shit. I think he doesn't give a shit either. It's also like it really is a story about how his staff now has no control over him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:44

“The Iranians just floated a deal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz that included some things like lifting sanctions and billions in frozen asset relief that make it hard for me to imagine that Trump would take a deal. So, I think renewed conflict is more likely than not.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:11

“She makes ridiculous demands of Abdul, not just to disavow an ad, which I thought Abdul should denounce before Haley Stevens ever put out a statement, but also to basically relitigate the disagreements they had over the course of the primary and a completely specious attack on an ad with Tucker Carlson.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:08

“If Democrats have a bad night it would change my view about people voting with their pocketbooks. Like, I can't remember an election where people have been this angry about the economy and if that does not do it, then that's going to be a quite a signal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 77:34

Chapters

•

2:00 — Trump's bizarre Lincoln Memorial rally: Trump's final pre-midterm event focused on White House renovations, algae in the reflecting pool, and sod quality for 30 minutes before a low-energy political close, revealing staff has lost control over him.

•

8:20 — Tucker Carlson's Iran nuclear strike claims: Tucker Carlson posted a long piece citing anonymous sources that Trump may nuke Iran's Pickaxe Mountain; Tommy Vietor assesses this as likely Gulf state disinformation, though a conventional MOAB strike is plausible for headlines.

•

16:20 — Haley Stevens' endorsement chaos in Michigan: Stevens flipped from endorsing Abdul El-Sayed to endorsing Republican Mike Rogers, then gave an incoherent CNN interview; her shifting demands and double standard (no demands of Rogers) unified Democrats around El-Sayed.

•

24:40 — Time/Siena poll deep dive: Michigan and Kansas: El-Sayed leads Rogers by 11 (53-42), winning 96% of Harris voters; Hamilton leads Marshall by 5 in Kansas despite a Republican-leaning sample, as Marshall's self-made ad about medical debt collections backfired.

•

46:00 — Alaska, Texas, and Iowa Senate races: Peltola leads by 2 in Alaska amid ballot-stacking scandal; Talarico leads Paxton by 3.5 in Texas as Paxton cancels Alamo event; Turick and Hinson tied in Iowa where Trump attacked Hinson's weight.

•

63:20 — Ohio and Maine: Brown vs. Husted, Jackson vs. Collins: Brown leads Husted by 5 in Ohio, aided by Vivek Ramaswamy's toxic gubernatorial campaign; Jackson leads Collins by 6 in Maine as independents shift toward him and the state's partisan lean reasserts.

•

72:00 — What constitutes a win or loss for Democrats: Hosts agree winning both chambers is the only acceptable outcome; a Senate loss would be historic given Trump's double-digit wins in these states, but winning Texas or North Carolina would signal a 2028 realignment.

•

83:00 — Election night expectations and final thoughts: Hosts discuss how polarization, money in politics, and economic voting would be reinterpreted based on results; they preview live election coverage and a bonus episode tomorrow.

Speakers

•

Jon Favreau — Host

•

Jon Lovett — Host

•

Tommy Vietor — Host

⋮