Alaska Senate race places spotlight on ranked choice voting

Original Media · 9m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

The episode explains how ranked choice voting works through a four-candidate example, then shifts to live coverage of Alaska's 2024 Senate race where Mary Peltola leads at 49.8% with 96% of votes counted. Guest Nathaniel, reporting from a Denver airport bathroom, explains Alaska's slow count is due to a 10-18 day ballot arrival window and remote communities requiring ballots to be flown in. The ranked choice tabulation is automated once all ballots are logged. Notably, the second Dan Sullivan's voters ranked Peltola second more often than the incumbent Sullivan, likely putting her over 50%. Repeal attempts for ranked choice voting have failed twice, with political professionals still opposing it but broader acceptance growing.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The spoiler candidate's voters preferred the Democrat (Peltola) as their second choice over the Republican incumbent (Sullivan), contradicting the assumption that a same-party spoiler only hurts the opposing party.

•

Alaska's ranked choice tabulation requires no manual counting — it's a single button press once ballots are logged, making the weeks-long wait purely about ballot collection, not computation.

•

Despite fierce opposition from political insiders and two repeal attempts, the system appears to be gaining acceptance among regular Alaskan voters, not losing it.

Key takeaways

•

Ranked choice voting lets voters rank candidates by preference; if no one reaches 50% in round one, the last-place candidate is eliminated and their voters' second choices are redistributed, repeating until a majority winner emerges.

•

In Alaska's Senate race, Mary Peltola leads Dan Sullivan by 10,358 votes at 49.8% with 96% counted; the remaining 4% plus ranked choice reallocation will likely push her over 50% without a runoff.

•

Alaska's vote counting takes weeks because ballots can arrive up to 10 days post-election (14-18 for overseas) and must be flown from hundreds of roadless communities, a timeline Alaskans expect and officials remind voters about every cycle.

•

The state's ranked choice tabulation is fully automated: once all ballots are scanned and logged, officials press a button and software instantly reallocates votes — no manual recount needed.

•

The 'spoiler' candidate — a second Dan Sullivan — actually helps Peltola because more of his voters ranked her second than ranked the incumbent Sullivan second, flipping the typical spoiler dynamic.

•

A 2022 repeal effort failed by just 700 votes; the 2024 attempt is failing by a wider margin. Political professionals and parties still oppose the system, but Nathaniel sees growing acceptance among the broader electorate.

•

An initiative may appear on the next ballot to address ways candidates have gamed the system to get fringe candidates on the ballot, which the original framers didn't foresee.

Notable quotes

“IF NONE OF THE CANDIDATES RECEIVED MORE THAN 50 % THAT'S A 50 % LINE IN THE FIRST ROUND THE NEXT THING THAT HAPPENS IS AT THE BOTTOM FINISHING CANDIDATE CANDIDATE D DROPS OUT OF THE NEXT ROUND BUT WHOMEVER CANDIDATE D'S VOTERS RANKED SECOND GETS AWARDED THOSE VOTES IN THE NEXT ROUND”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:37

“RANKED CHOICE VOTING MOVES AWAY FROM THE TWO-PARTY DYNAMIC BY OPENING GENERAL ELECTIONS TO MULTIPLE CANDIDATES”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:21

“IN THEORY, IT REDUCES TOXIC CAMPAIGNING BECAUSE EACH PERSON'S VOTE IS NO LONGER A ZERO-SUM GAME”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:28

“I AM IN A BATHROOM IN DENVER, WHICH IS WHERE I HAVE BEEN STUCK FOR THE NIGHT, THANKS TO THE FAA AND THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:28

“WE HAVE A SORT OF PERMISSIVE TIMELINE FOR WHEN BALLOTS CAN ARRIVE WITH ELECTIONS ADMINISTRATORS AND STILL BE COUNTED. I BELIEVE FOR MOST BALLOTS, THAT'S A 10-DAY AFTER THE ELECTION ARRIVAL WINDOW”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:02

“MORE OF HIS VOTERS ACTUALLY RANKED MARY PELTOLA AS THEIR SECOND CHOICE THAN THE DAN S. SULLIVAN THE INCUMBENT AND SO VERY LIKELY AT THIS POINT BASED ON WHAT THE RESULTS LOOK LIKE THE VOTES FROM THIS SECONDARY DAN SULLIVAN WILL PUT MARY OVER THE TOP AND INTO THE U.S. SENATE”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:12

Chapters

•

0:01 — How Ranked Choice Voting Works: A step-by-step explanation using four candidates (A, B, C, D) showing how voters rank choices, how first-round totals are counted, and how successive rounds eliminate the last-place candidate and redistribute their voters' next preferences until someone crosses 50%.

•

2:20 — Benefits of Ranked Choice Voting: Three arguments for the system: it breaks the two-party dynamic by allowing multiple candidates in general elections, reduces toxic campaigning since votes aren't zero-sum and candidates court second-choice support, and avoids costly low-turnout runoff elections.

•

3:18 — Alaska Election Context & Guest Introduction: Host introduces Nathaniel, an Alaska election reporter stuck in a Denver airport bathroom due to an FAA outage. He explains Alaska's slow count stems from a permissive ballot-arrival window (10-18 days) and the logistics of flying ballots from hundreds of roadless communities.

•

4:51 — Breaking News: Peltola Leads at 96% Count: A new vote drop puts Mary Peltola ahead by 10,358 votes at 49.8% with 96% reporting. The host and Nathaniel discuss why ranked choice tabulation can't run until nearly all ballots are in, since uncounted ballots can't be reallocated.

•

6:30 — Ranked Choice Tabulation Process & Spoiler Effect: Nathaniel describes Alaska's automated tabulation — a button press once all ballots are logged. He reveals the second Dan Sullivan's voters ranked Peltola second more often than the incumbent Sullivan, meaning the 'spoiler' likely pushes Peltola over 50%.

•

8:01 — Alaskan Views on Ranked Choice Voting: Two repeal attempts have failed (2022 by 700 votes, 2024 by more). Political professionals and parties still oppose it, but Nathaniel sees broader electorate acceptance growing. An initiative may address candidates gaming the system to place fringe candidates on the ballot.

Speakers

•

Host — News anchor / host

•

Nathaniel — Alaska election reporter

⋮