TLDR
Emily D. Baker covers two major legal cases: the YSL/Young Thug RICO trial in Georgia, where a second secret ex parte hearing between prosecutors, the former judge, and a key witness has sparked Brady violation allegations and motions to dismiss; and the upcoming federal trial of Tom Girardi in Los Angeles, where prosecutors will argue he stole millions from clients to fund his wife Erika's entertainment career while blaming his CFO. Both cases reveal systemic procedural breakdowns.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
An attorney in the YSL proceedings referred to a homicide as an "unaliving," using internet slang in formal court testimony.
Prosecutors in the YSL case asked the judge for legal guidance on how to handle a represented witness they were already communicating with, effectively seeking judicial help for an ethical violation.
Judge Glanville was recused not for the ex parte meeting itself, but for how he handled the subsequent recusal motions.
Girardi's defense essentially argues "my accountant was stealing from me while I was stealing from my clients," a circular admission of commingled theft.
Key takeaways
The YSL/Young Thug trial, already the longest in Georgia history, has been further derailed by allegations of two ex parte meetings between prosecutors, former Judge Glanville, and witness Kenneth Copeland without defense counsel present.
A newly revealed June 7 transcript shows prosecutors and the judge discussing whether Copeland's attorney Melnick had a conflict, while simultaneously communicating with Copeland directly despite signs he was represented.
Defense attorneys argue the ex parte conversations included references to "outside agitators" influencing the case and discussions about case strategy, violating due process and Brady obligations.
Judge Whitaker has struck all rulings made after June 12, including testimony from the contested witness, but the defense seeks full dismissal with prejudice.
Tom Girardi's federal wire fraud trial begins in Los Angeles, with prosecutors focusing on $25 million funneled from client trust accounts to his wife Erika Girardi's entertainment company EJ Global.
Girardi plans a "side fraud" defense claiming his CFO stole the money, but prosecutors argue Girardi commingled personal and client funds and his own emails show awareness of the scheme.
The court has limited Girardi's cognitive impairment defense to pre-scheme mental state, ruling post-scheme condition irrelevant and post-theft mitigation not a defense to wire fraud.
Both cases illustrate how procedural misconduct and commingled funds can undermine prosecutions: YSL through judicial/prosecutorial overreach, Girardi through decades of documented client theft.
Notable quotes
“I have never felt more old than watching these proceedings today and seeing one of the attorneys that was in the in chamers exp par day hearings referring to a homicide as a unal living”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:53“this case is like an old house that the present honorable judge is tasked with renovating every time a piece of pasted up wallpaper is removed more rot is found hidden underneath”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:54“this is weaving the appeal in like a spider web gordian knot it is just you've woven the issues directly into the fabric from Whole cloth”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:10“you can't have it both ways when you've been talking to the witness”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:21“what a mess what an absolute mess and we've seen that in other arguments too that gerardi had intermingled all of these funds”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:28“the amount of mess the transcript goes on to say that Mr copelan had been reaching out to Da Hilton and that communication's being blocked by someone Mr Copeland didn't reach out to”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:29Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Case Preview: Emily Baker introduces the episode, noting a busy court week with hearings in YSL, Cory Richens, and Karen Read cases, and previews updates on the YSL Young Thug trial and Tom Girardi's upcoming federal trial.
3:13 — YSL Young Thug Trial Background: Overview of the 88-page RICO indictment charging 26 defendants, with 6 currently on trial; jury selection began January 2023, evidence phase November 2023, now the longest trial in Georgia history.
4:00 — Judge Recusal and New Judge: Judge Glanville recused in mid-June over handling of recusal motions; Judge Whitaker now presiding and has struck all rulings and proceedings from June 12 onward, including some witness testimony.
12:00 — Second Ex Parte Meeting Revealed: Defense supplement reveals a June 7 ex parte meeting between Judge Glanville and prosecutors discussing witness Kenneth Copeland and his attorney Melnick, before the known June 10 meeting.
20:00 — Prosecutor-Witness Communication Issues: Transcript shows prosecutors communicating with Copeland directly while his attorney Melnick was present, raising questions about whether Copeland was represented and whether prosecutors violated ethics rules.
31:00 — Defense Motions and Brady Allegations: Kendrick's motion supplement alleges due process violations, Brady violations, and seeks mistrial with prejudice; defense argues the case is irreparably tainted by judicial and prosecutorial misconduct.
47:34 — Tom Girardi Federal Trial Preview: Girardi's federal wire fraud trial begins in LA; prosecution focuses on four client victims and $25 million diverted to wife Erika Girardi's entertainment company EJ Global.
51:00 — Girardi Defenses and Prosecution Rebuttal: Girardi plans 'side fraud' defense blaming CFO, cognitive impairment defense, and victim negligence; prosecution argues commingled funds, awareness of scheme, and that post-theft mitigation is not a defense.
Speakers
Emily D. Baker — Host