TLDR
This episode examines the 2016 death of Barbara Kendhammer, allegedly killed when a pipe flew through her husband Todd's windshield. Despite Todd's claim of a freak accident, forensic evidence — including Barbara's injuries inconsistent with a single pipe strike, blood patterns suggesting an altercation outside the car, a grass blade in the trunk seal, and no corroborating truck on surveillance — led to his conviction for first-degree murder. Todd's children and Barbara's mother maintain his innocence, and conflicting expert testimony keeps the case debated.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The pipe was 53 inches long and weighed 10 pounds — a heavy projectile that, at combined speeds of 45–55 mph, would have passed completely through a human head rather than causing the scattered injuries Barbara had.
Barbara's cricoid cartilage fracture — a ring at the top of the trachea — is classically associated with manual strangulation, yet the defense argued her large metal water bottle could have caused it during the crash.
Todd testified he sat down to urinate at home for 25 years to respect Barbara's pet peeve, a detail the defense used to portray him as a devoted, non-violent husband.
The prosecutor told Todd's adult children at sentencing to 'get their heads out of their ass,' a remark the host called unprofessional and cruel.
The police reenactment video was never seen by the jury; the defense called it inconclusive, the prosecution said they didn't need it, and the judge only learned of it years later during an evidentiary hearing.
Key takeaways
Forensic evidence contradicted Todd's pipe story: Barbara had injuries on both front and back of her head, a fractured cricoid cartilage suggestive of strangulation, and no blood on the headrest despite deep scalp lacerations.
The passenger seat held glass shards but the door cubby had none, indicating the door was open and the seat empty when the windshield broke — inconsistent with Barbara sitting there during a pipe strike.
A construction worker passed the Camry in the ditch at 8:00 a.m. and saw no cracked windshield; Todd called 911 at 8:05 a.m., leaving only five minutes to stage the scene.
Todd gave three different names for the windshield job he claimed to be driving to (Justin Heim, Ben Path, Jerry Logging); all three men testified no arrangement existed.
The car's gear-shifter glass pattern showed the transmission was in park when the windshield was pierced, not in drive as Todd described.
A single blade of grass trapped halfway in the trunk seal indicated the trunk had been opened and closed, supporting the theory Todd retrieved the pipe from there.
No truck matching Todd's description appeared on the horse-farm camera or other area cameras in the minutes before the 911 call.
Multiple forensic pathologists reached opposite conclusions: the state's expert ruled strangulation and assault; defense and independent experts said injuries fit a pipe strike or post-crash organ donation.
Todd's children and Barbara's own mother supported him at trial, yet the jury convicted in nine hours, citing his shifting stories and nervous demeanor as signs of deception.
A police reenactment testing whether a pipe could bounce off the road and through a windshield was conducted 12 times but never shown at trial — both sides agreed not to admit it.
Notable quotes
“could the jury have gotten it wrong here?”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:50“A pipe right through.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:38“those injuries... didn't happen by a pipe coming through the windshield”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:07“that pipe would be a projectile that would go right through anything it came in contact with”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:43“I would actually take her down, you know, take her to work. But if I wasn't if I had to work, I'd take her car halfway down and leave it there and she had remote start so she wouldn't have to go down the driveway by herself.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:53“Could Todd, who had no apparent motive, have snapped after 25 years and killed his wife and staged it as a freak accident? Or was this truly a freak accident and he's innocent?”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:41Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Sponsor: Host Kendall Ray introduces the Barbara Kendhammer case, found via a member request, and reads a Chime sponsorship.
3:20 — Background on Barbara and Todd: Barbara, born 1970, married Todd at 16; they had two children, worked middle-class jobs, and were described as a devoted, argument-free couple for 25 years.
6:10 — The Incident: September 16, 2016: Todd and Barbara left for a camping trip; instead of heading to her school, Todd drove north on County Road M where he claims a pipe fell from a truck and struck Barbara through the windshield.
7:28 — 911 Call and First Responder Scene: Todd's frantic 911 call at 8:05 a.m. describes a pipe through the windshield; dash-cam footage shows the Camry stuck in a ditch, Todd covered in blood, and officers immediately suspicious of his injuries and the scene.
14:25 — Forensic Inconsistencies Emerge: Investigators note: no blood on headrest, glass on passenger seat but not door cubby, gear-shifter glass indicates car was in park, grass blade in trunk seal, no blood on pipe, blood on rear tire, and no truck on surveillance cameras.
23:40 — Interrogation and Changing Stories: Todd is questioned the day before the funeral; he gives shifting accounts of the windshield job (Justin Heim, then Ben Path), cannot explain his knuckle and neck scratches, and appears extremely nervous.
38:50 — Trial and Competing Experts: State's pathologist Dr. McCubbin rules strangulation and assault; defense experts argue injuries fit pipe strike or organ donation. Windshield fracture patterns, construction worker testimony, and Todd's own testimony (including a third windshield name, Jerry Logging) are central.
60:30 — Verdict, Sentencing, and Appeals: Jury convicts in nine hours; Todd gets life with parole in 30 years. Children sell homes to fund appeals; a police reenactment video surfaces but is excluded. Multiple experts still disagree; case remains polarizing.
Speakers
Kendall Ray — Host