The Last Ride | 53 Years Later, DNA Reveals Who Murdered Two Teenage Sisters

Original Media · 39m · English · YouTube · Crime Weekly

TLDR

Crime Weekly News hosts Derrick Levasseur and Stephanie Harlow cover the 1973 murders of sisters Maggie (18) and Mary (16) Jenkins, who were hitchhiking in the Florida Keys and found dead in Key Largo. In September 2026, 53 years later, forensic investigative genetic genealogy identified their killer as David Allen Snyder, a Key West resident who died in 2008. The breakthrough came from a blood stain on one victim's underwear that yielded a partial male DNA profile, which was later sequenced by Authurm and matched through genealogy databases to a living relative of Snyder.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Studies from 1981, 2014, and more recently consistently show around 30-35% of men surveyed would commit sexual assault if they knew they would not get caught.

•

Serial killers were far more prevalent in the 1960s-1980s largely because limited forensic technology and surveillance made it easier to avoid detection; modern technology has drastically reduced their ability to accumulate victims.

•

The killer, David Allen Snyder, lived 35 years after the murders and died of natural causes in Idaho — never arrested, never suspected, and never connected to the crime until genetic genealogy identified him decades after his death.

Key takeaways

•

The Jenkins sisters were last seen hitchhiking on Stock Island near Key West on May 2, 1973, and found the next day nearly 100 miles north in Key Largo, both severely beaten and shot, with clothing removed or displaced indicating sexual assault.

•

Monroe County Sheriff's Office preserved the evidence including the victims' clothing for decades, which allowed a partial male DNA profile to be extracted from a blood stain on one sister's underwear when technology advanced.

•

In 2018 the profile was entered into CODIS with no match; in 2023 the Florida Department of Law Enforcement partnered with Authurm for forensic-grade genome sequencing, enabling comparison against public genealogy databases to build a family tree and narrow to David Allen Snyder.

•

A reference DNA sample from one of Snyder's living relatives in early 2026 confirmed he was the source of the crime scene DNA; Snyder lived in Key West from 1972-1974 and died of natural causes in Idaho in 2008 at age 57.

•

The hosts emphasize that hitchhiking was common and not considered reckless in 1973, and that the sisters were not to blame; they discuss how women remain disproportionately targeted by male violence, citing studies where ~30% of men admitted they would commit sexual assault if guaranteed no consequences.

•

Derrick and Stephanie highlight that evidence preservation by 1970s detectives was crucial — many departments failed to store evidence properly, leaving countless cases unsolvable even with modern technology.

•

The hosts' Criminal Coffee brand funded this case's investigation ($7,500) and has contributed to 26-27 cold cases; they also donate to victim advocacy organizations between major case fundings.

•

Authorities have not yet disclosed whether Snyder had a criminal record or is being investigated for other crimes; the hosts urge law enforcement to examine his movements after 1974 for potential links to other unsolved cases.

Notable quotes

“Their interest were boys, making money, and they wanted to travel.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:38

“If I had known what I know now, I would have never never ever.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:09

“They were covered with sticks and leaves and dirt, basically dumped like garbage in the wood.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:19

“We did our own investigation, but obviously we were in their way and they kept telling us to go home.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:04

“The clock is ticking on these people out there because now that the science and technology is here, the more recent cases that are occurring, uh you're not going to spend your whole life out there.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:04

“Putting shit in a plastic bag is not hard.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:58

Chapters

•

0:10 — Mission and Case Introduction: Hosts explain Crime Weekly's mission to educate and fund cold case investigations through Criminal Coffee, then introduce the 1973 Jenkins sisters case — two New Jersey teens hitchhiking in the Florida Keys who were found murdered in Key Largo.

•

3:00 — Victim Background and Hitchhiking Culture: Details about Maggie (18) and Mary (16) Jenkins, their sister Sarah and brother-in-law Dwayne Barlow, and discussion of how hitchhiking was normal for young people in the 1970s, not considered reckless by contemporary standards.

•

4:00 — Gendered Violence and Safety Discussion: Hosts discuss the disproportionate danger women face when traveling alone, citing studies where ~30% of men admitted they would commit sexual assault if guaranteed impunity, and the limitations of the buddy system against armed attackers.

•

15:00 — Timeline and Geography of the Crime: The sisters were last seen on Stock Island (mile marker 5) on May 2; bodies found May 3 near mile marker 99.5 in Key Largo — a 95-mile drive up the Overseas Highway, suggesting the killer transported them the full length of the Keys.

•

17:10 — Early Investigation and Cold Case Efforts: Family conducted their own investigation but were told to go home; case went cold until 2007 when Detective Mark Coleman resubmitted preserved evidence for DNA testing, with Dwayne Barlow calling detectives weekly for decades.

•

24:40 — DNA Breakthrough and Genetic Genealogy: A blood stain on a victim's underwear yielded a partial male DNA profile; 2018 CODIS entry had no match; 2023 Authurm forensic genome sequencing enabled genealogy database searches; family tree work narrowed to David Allen Snyder; 2026 relative reference sample confirmed the match.

•

28:00 — Funding, Evidence Preservation, and Authurm's Role: Discussion of Criminal Coffee funding ($7,500 for this case), the Magnolia Project, and the critical importance of 1970s detectives preserving evidence properly — without which modern DNA technology would have nothing to analyze.

•

30:20 — Identification, Closure, and Remaining Questions: Sheriff Ramsey announced Snyder as the killer on September 2, 2026; Snyder died in 2008 in Idaho. Hosts raise unanswered questions: Snyder's movements after 1974, potential other victims, whether he had a criminal record, and the details of the missing hours between Stock Island and Key Largo.

Speakers

•

Derrick Levasseur — Co-host

•

Stephanie Harlow — Co-host

⋮