Secret Killer Leads Cops Into Her $3,000,000 Murder Mansion

Original Media · 48m · English · YouTube · Dr Insanity

TLDR

Craig Thetford, a 60-year-old roofing business owner in Cloudcroft, New Mexico, disappears for months while his wife Dina gives conflicting accounts of his whereabouts. A multi-agency investigation uncovers Dina's history of violence against former husbands, financial motive involving $1.5 million in cash, and a daughter's revelation that Dina confessed to shooting Craig, hiding his body for days, then moving it with a tractor. Craig's body is found buried under cardboard and plastic in a carport on the property; Dina is arrested for first-degree murder and tampering with evidence after a suicide attempt in Texas. As of March 2026, she awaits trial.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The first responding officers smelled decomposition odor at the carport but dismissed it as a wildlife smell and left without investigating further, unknowingly standing feet from Craig's buried body.

•

Dina voluntarily showed Deputy Roger the safe and mentioned the $1.5 million unprompted, then later dug a large hole in the yard while claiming it was for gardening, effectively drawing attention to the very area where the body had been.

•

Craig's own firefighter friend Thomas revealed that Craig had set up a 'dead man's switch' communication method — leaving notes and cash in an envelope — because he anticipated something might happen to him.

•

Dina's daughter Leslie stated that her siblings had known about the killing 'for a long time' but cut off contact with her after she learned the truth, implying a family-wide cover-up before she came forward.

•

Deputy Roger had worked a nearly identical case years earlier where a wife stayed in the house for weeks after murdering her husband, dragged him into the woods, covered him with a tarp, and claimed he was on a fishing trip — the same story Dina used.

Key takeaways

•

Multiple welfare checks from Craig's friend and grandson over two to four months initially yielded no action because police found the home vacant but with lights on and no obvious signs of foul play, allowing the investigation to stall.

•

Dina Thetford's three ex-husbands and her daughter Leslie independently described her as violently unstable, with allegations including attempted stabbing, chasing a husband with a gun, trying to run a husband over with a car, and Leslie's claim that Dina tried to kill her and hog-tied her sister.

•

Deputy Roger Schoolcraft, a retired homicide detective, deliberately revealed his background mid-interview after Dina casually admitted she was the 'common denominator' in her four failed marriages, signaling he was investigating a possible homicide.

•

Dina claimed she could not access the safe holding $1.5 million because she lacked the combination, but Craig's firefighter friend Thomas stated Craig told him Dina had the combination and left an envelope of cash as their only communication method.

•

A former co-worker of Dina's from her correctional officer days called Detective Curtis and reported that Dina had confessed to shooting Craig, providing the first direct admission that prompted a search warrant.

•

During the search, officers found bleach bottles throughout the house, a disabled surveillance system, a table saw with possible blood traces, and only $84,200 in the safe — far less than the $1.5 million Dina claimed — supporting the theory she had been spending Craig's money for months.

•

Leslie, Dina's daughter, provided the breakthrough location: Craig's body was wrapped in rugs and plastic, moved with a tractor to the detached carport, and hidden under cardboard boxes and soil bags 'in plain sight' next to the tractor.

•

Autopsy confirmed Craig died from multiple gunshot wounds, including one through the heart, weeks to months prior (consistent with a January killing), and the death was ruled a homicide; Dina was arrested at a Texas hospital after a suicide attempt and invoked her right to counsel.

Notable quotes

“If I could kill Craig and get away with it, I'd do it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:58

“My mom is crazy. Like, she's tried to kill me before.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:50

“She said Craig pushed her down the stairs and she shot him and he fell into the pool room.”

▸ Notable quotes · 43:11

“This is the only way I've been able to have any communication with you. And I don't even know if it's even him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:35

“If that happened, you know, I'd be okay with it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:27

“I recently got in touch with an old friend of mine. She was married to that dude and apparently she said she said she shot him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:30

Chapters

•

0:01 — Initial welfare checks: Friend Larry Scott and grandson Cody Gibson request welfare checks on Craig Thetford after months of no contact; officers find the home vacant with lights on but dismiss a faint odor at the carport as wildlife.

•

5:17 — Grandson's call reveals longer timeline: Cody Gibson reports Craig hasn't been seen for over four months and that Dina claims Craig went to Mexico after filing for divorce, contradicting the two-month timeline from the first call.

•

7:21 — Neighbor canvassing and Dina's first interview: Deputies canvas neighbors who haven't seen Craig since January; Dina calls Deputy Pinter, claims Craig is in Mexico with another woman, and says she last saw him packing on the first of the month.

•

11:45 — Ex-husbands and daughter expose Dina's violent past: Detective Curtis interviews Dina's ex-husbands Scott and Scotty, who allege assault, attempted stabbing, and gun threats; daughter Leslie describes Dina as 'demonic,' alcoholic, and claims she tried to kill Leslie and poison Craig.

•

16:56 — Deputy Roger interviews Dina, reveals homicide background: Deputy Roger Schoolcraft interviews Dina at the home; she shows him the safe, claims she can't open it, and mentions $1.5 million; Roger reveals he is a retired homicide detective after she calls herself the 'common denominator' in her marriages.

•

26:05 — Roger canvasses neighbors, gets crucial contradictions: Roger speaks with neighbor Thomas, who says Craig told him Dina has the safe combination and left notes with cash as communication; Thomas also recalls Dina saying she'd be 'okay with it' if something happened to Craig.

•

29:19 — Second visit, Dina's incriminating statements: Roger returns five days later; Dina has dug a large hole in the yard, says 'if I had just left when he told me to, none of this would have happened,' and appears increasingly unstable.

•

32:18 — Co-worker's confession tip and Dina's suicide attempt: Dina's former prison co-worker Andrew calls Detective Curtis saying Dina confessed to shooting Craig; police learn Dina attempted suicide at her mother's house in Texas, prompting an urgent search warrant.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Narrator

•

Deputy Roger Schoolcraft — Investigator

•

Deputy Pinter — Investigator

•

Detective Bobby Curtis — Lead Investigator

•

Dina Thetford — Suspect

•

Larry Scott — Witness

•

Cody Gibson — Witness

•

Heidi — Witness

•

Thomas — Witness

•

Leslie — Witness

•

Andrew — Witness

•

Mary — Witness

•

Scott — Witness

•

Scotty — Witness

⋮