I Thought Elizabeth Holmes Was Guilty AF. Then I Watched THIS. | 'You Can See Everything' Explained

Original Media · 51m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

Ashley Banfield and her husband Chris Hanner debate the new A24 documentary on Elizabeth Holmes, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. Ashley argues Holmes is less culpable than believed — neuroatypical and manipulated by the men in her life (Sunny Balwani, Billy Evans) — while Chris contends she is more intentional and manipulative, using her 'babe in the woods' persona strategically. They dissect Billy Evans's controlling behavior, his profit deal with the filmmakers, his takeover of Holmes's social media, and the documentary's possible role as a PR vehicle for a 'Theranos 2.0' launch.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Ashley — a veteran true-crime journalist who entered the film convinced Holmes was 'guilty AF' — came out believing Holmes is less guilty due to diminished mens rea, and that she may not even know Billy Evans profits from the documentary.

•

The documentary gives its subject (Billy Evans) a profit share, which is highly unusual for a documentary and undermines its legitimacy, turning it into 'reality TV.'

•

Holmes's father's first answer about her is 'she was raped,' delivered without pause — a moment that felt coached to elicit sympathy rather than illuminate.

•

Nathan Fielder was never intended to be on camera; his presence emerged organically because the filmmakers realized the dynamic between him and the subjects was the story.

•

The filmmakers had only 34 days of access and went in with A24's blessing to possibly scrap the whole project — a rare luxury that Ashley says changed her trust in the final product.

Key takeaways

•

Ashley believes Elizabeth Holmes is neuroatypical/on the spectrum and lacks the social intelligence to orchestrate the Theranos fraud, viewing her as a 'useful idiot' manipulated by Sunny Balwani and Billy Evans.

•

Chris argues Holmes is more calculating, using her persona deliberately to manipulate investors and the public, and was likely aware of Billy Evans's financial deal with the documentary filmmakers.

•

Billy Evans is portrayed as controlling and narcissistic: he shuts down interviews, takes over Holmes's Twitter (posting abusive messages), negotiated a backend profit cut from the documentary, and staged a gratuitous full-frontal shower scene.

•

The 'Who's on First' scene — where Holmes fails to understand the Abbott & Costello routine — is a key metaphor for Ashley: Holmes grasps literal facts but misses social nuance, supporting the neuroatypical reading.

•

Holmes's father gives a suspiciously instant, coached-sounding answer ('she was raped') when asked why she's partnering with Billy again, which Ashley sees as performative sympathy-seeking; Billy then shuts down the interview.

•

The documentary filmmakers (Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim) are viewed as honest brokers by Ashley; they had no guaranteed distribution, built the plane while flying it, and included Fielder on camera only after realizing his interactions added crucial context.

•

Both hosts agree Billy Evans is a red flag for any future venture ('Theranos 2.0'); Ashley would invest in Holmes only with legitimate, truth-keeping partners, while Chris says the money is likely gone and the track record is disqualifying.

Notable quotes

“I went into that movie thinking that she's guilty AF, right? And I came out of that movie with a different opinion.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:31

“I don't think she's the scheming, conniving, you know, um, oz that everybody thinks she is. I don't think she's capable. Honestly, I don't think she's socially smart enough.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:20

“He knows best. It came out again in that very ugly moment. She her default was right away he knows best.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:05

“She didn't get that the guy on first had a last name that was who. She actually didn't get it. And once again, for me, that was a super duper uh clear metaphor for who she is in life.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:42

“They went into this project thinking maybe we're going to scrap it. We'll go in, we'll shoot for a while and maybe we'll throw it away. And A24 gave them the latitude to do that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:08

“If Elizabeth partnered with allied with legitimate brokers out there... then I could see this because I do think she's brilliant. I do think she is just that personality, just that neuroatypical personality that is so focused on the product and on invention.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:28

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Ashley's Shift on Holmes's Guilt: Ashley Banfield introduces the episode, her husband Chris Hanner as guest, and reveals she entered the Elizabeth Holmes documentary convinced of Holmes's guilt but left questioning it, citing mens rea and Holmes's possible neuroatypical nature.

•

3:50 — Billy Evans: The Shower Scene and Controlling Behavior: Ashley critiques Billy Evans's gratuitous full-frontal shower scene as ego-driven, then details his controlling actions: whisking eggs from Holmes's hands, shutting down interviews, and negotiating a profit cut from the documentary.

•

17:00 — The 'Who's on First' Scene and Neuroatypical Reading: Ashley analyzes the moment Holmes fails to understand the Abbott & Costello routine, interpreting it as evidence she misses social nuance — a metaphor for how she may have been manipulated by Sunny Balwani and Billy Evans.

•

19:50 — Billy's Takeover of Holmes's Social Media: Billy Evans runs Holmes's Twitter while she's in prison, posting abusive messages; when confronted, Holmes defers to him ('I trust him'), which Ashley finds cult-like and Chris sees as calculated acceptance.

•

27:00 — Chris Hanner Joins: Debate on Holmes's Intentionality: Chris argues Holmes is more manipulative and intentional than Ashley believes, citing her curated Steve Jobs persona and likely awareness of Billy's documentary profit deal; Ashley maintains Holmes is checking boxes, not masterminding.

•

39:00 — The Filmmakers' Process and Credibility: Ashley shares insights from an interview with co-director Lance Oppenheim: the crew had 34 days, no guaranteed distribution, added cameras mid-shoot, and only put Fielder on camera after realizing his interactions were the story — factors that increase Ashley's trust.

•

48:00 — Theranos 2.0 and Final Verdicts: Both hosts agree Billy Evans's involvement makes any future venture a 'no'; Ashley would back Holmes only with legitimate, truth-keeping partners, while Chris believes the money is gone and the track record disqualifies them.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

•

Chris Hanner — Guest / Husband

⋮