International Smuggler Reveals His Secrets!

Original Media · 2h 11m · English · YouTube · Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime

TLDR

Comedian and writer Brian McCarthy recounts his chaotic youth in Baltimore, expulsion from Catholic school, teenage drug use and sex work, moving to 1990s New York with $250, becoming a pot and cocaine dealer, smuggling 50 pounds of Jamaican "lamb's bread" marijuana inside boomboxes, getting caught at Miami customs, spending weeks in Miami-Dade County jail, and eventually turning his life around through comedy writing — including penning jokes for the Dos Equis "Most Interesting Man" campaign — while reflecting on white privilege that kept him out of serious prison time.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

McCarthy was expelled from Catholic school for eating unconsecrated communion wafers on a Roy Rogers burger — the nuns called it devil worship, but he successfully argued at 13 that without transubstantiation they were just crackers.

•

He won a fraternity "Hogan Award" (a spear) for having sex with the "fattest girl" at a party, and the hazing ritual involved doing sit-ups while a naked brother sat on his face.

•

At 14 he danced shirtless in gay bars for free drinks, and the men thought he was at least 18 — he didn't realize "long neck" referred to the bottle, not a beer brand.

•

The Jamaican farm dinner involved a guy breaking a chicken's neck, gutting it with a rusty machete while smoking an 18-inch wet joint, and frying it in a pot of oil over a fire — which McCarthy calls the best fried chicken he ever ate.

•

At Miami customs, McCarthy played a tape of himself freestyling Jamaican dancehall to distract officers, then humped his friend Brandon while they laughed — the agents laughed too and initially waved him through.

•

The customs dog (a beagle) humped the speaker cabinet containing the weed, which is what triggered the search — McCarthy later owned a beagle for 15 years.

•

McCarthy's white privilege was so extreme that the white customs agent believed his fabricated "Jamaican gang forced me" story instantly, saying "I knew it was something like that," and they were charged only with a misdemeanor despite 40–50 lbs of marijuana.

•

In county jail, an inmate barber gave McCarthy a haircut and eyebrow slits but refused to cut his half-Ecuadorian friend Brandon's hair, saying "I've already cut Spanish hair."

•

McCarthy wrote 300 Dos Equis "Most Interesting Man" jokes in one night on red wine, got paid $5,000, and didn't realize they'd used all of them until he saw a billboard on Sunset Boulevard months later.

Key takeaways

•

McCarthy's childhood was marked by family dysfunction: an alcoholic father who hid vodka bottles in the oven, a stepmother whose sunburned skin he ate to feel close to her, and expulsion from Catholic school at 13 for eating unconsecrated communion wafers on a burger — a stunt the nuns called devil worship.

•

At 14 he began sneaking into Baltimore gay bars, dancing shirtless so men would buy him drinks, not realizing he was underage; he thought "long neck" was a beer brand, not a bottle style.

•

After dropping out of ninth grade and a failed stint at Kent State (where he won a fraternity "Hogan Award" for sex with the "fattest girl" and endured a hazing ritual involving a naked brother's ass crack), he moved to NYC in 1991 with $250 and a footlocker.

•

His first NYC roommate, Eric Jay Friedman, masturbated on him while he slept; McCarthy fled to a waitress's apartment, beginning a pattern of chaotic housing and survival sex work.

•

He became a pot dealer using a pager, business cards reading "I sell pot / clown available for kids," and a stolen Trek bike for deliveries, making $800/week — enough to quit his restaurant job.

•

A Jamaican connect invited him to Montego Bay to buy lamb's bread at $100/pound (vs. $800/qtr-lb in NYC); McCarthy and friend Brandon flew down, were met by an AK-47-toting "godfather" in a Christmas-light-covered BMW, spent days at a mountain farm eating fresh-killed fried chicken and sleeping with local women, then packed 40–50 lbs of compressed weed into two radios wrapped in carbon paper.

•

At Miami customs, a beagle alerted on the radio; McCarthy improvised a cover story about being forced to carry it by a Jamaican gang threatening his family — the white customs agent believed him, saying "I knew it was something like that," and they were processed for a misdemeanor (under 99 lbs in Florida).

•

They spent roughly two weeks in Miami-Dade County jail (nicknamed "Smuggler One" and "Smuggler Two"), where McCarthy kept morale up by freestyling Dr. Dre lyrics, getting a haircut and eyebrow slits from an inmate barber, and joking through the misery while Brandon spiraled.

•

McCarthy's aunt, connected to Carly Simon and James Taylor, enlisted a NORML lawyer who got the charges dropped if he stayed clean six months — but he immediately resumed dealing cocaine, even selling to Liza Minnelli, before pivoting to comedy writing.

•

He wrote 300 "Most Interesting Man in the World" jokes in one wine-fueled night for $5,000, later worked in women's extreme wrestling, hosted his own interview show, and feuded with Shane Gillis at Joe Rogan's Comedy Mothership in Austin.

Notable quotes

“I used to sit behind her when she had a sunburn and I would pick off pieces of her back skin when she had a sunburn and I would eat her skin to get close to her so she would become my mommy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:22

“These were not consecrated. These were not this not even a desecration of anything. These are just wafers. If we're all here believing in the miracle of the Christ, then can we all agree that until this happens, until these are put through the m... what are we even here to do? What are we episcipalians? Hello.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:45

“I thought that whatever my story would be ultimately like I'd be sitting on the couch in some talk show and it'd be a much better story to be like, 'Oh yeah, I dropped out at a sixth screen. How, you know, how interesting.' So instead of going to my last day as a 16-year-old ninth grader, I went to go see the Three Amigos.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:07

“You bring the radio, you go down, you make a fortune, and you come back.”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:52

“Juno, you ruined your life. You ruined your life.”

▸ Notable quotes · 74:49

“I knew it was something like that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 75:48

Chapters

•

0:00 — Baltimore Childhood & Catholic School Expulsion: McCarthy describes his chaotic family — alcoholic father hiding vodka in the oven, eating stepmother's sunburned skin to bond, and getting expelled at 13 for eating unconsecrated communion wafers on a burger, which he successfully argued was not devil worship.

•

5:18 — Teen Years: Gay Bars, Drugs & Dropping Out: At 14 he danced shirtless in Baltimore gay bars for free drinks, used poppers and acid, failed seventh grade, dropped out of ninth grade at 16, and chose to see The Three Amigos instead of attending his last day of school.

•

7:58 — Kent State & Move to NYC: He got into Kent State on an opera scholarship, never attended classes, joined a frat, got chickenpox, and from the infirmary mailed applications to NYU/Tisch — getting into Tisch but not NYU, then moving to NYC in 1991 with $250.

•

17:58 — Eric Jay Incident & Start of Drug Dealing: His roommate Eric Jay masturbated on him; he fled to a waitress's apartment, got a restaurant job, and began selling pot using a pager, business cards, and a stolen bike — making $800/week.

•

45:04 — Jamaica Smuggling Trip: A Jamaican connect invited him to Montego Bay to buy lamb's bread cheap; he and Brandon were met by an armed 'godfather,' spent days at a mountain farm eating fresh-killed chicken and partying, then packed 40–50 lbs of weed into two radios.

•

65:04 — Miami Customs Bust & Jail: A beagle alerted on the radio at Miami customs; McCarthy improvised a 'Jamaican gang forced me' story that the white agent believed. They were charged with a misdemeanor and spent ~2 weeks in Miami-Dade County jail as 'Smuggler One' and 'Smuggler Two.'

•

98:04 — Release, Legal Fix & Return to Dealing: His aunt got a NORML lawyer to secure a six-month clean record deal; charges were dropped. McCarthy immediately resumed dealing cocaine, sold to Liza Minnelli, then pivoted to comedy writing.

•

106:04 — Comedy Career: Dos Equis, Wrestling & Shane Gillis Feud: He wrote 300 'Most Interesting Man' jokes in one night for $5,000, worked in women's extreme wrestling, hosted his own interview show, and had a confrontation with Shane Gillis at Joe Rogan's Comedy Mothership in Austin.

Speakers

•

Brian McCarthy — Guest

•

Colby — Host

•

Tom — Co-host / Producer

⋮