Stephen A.'s COWBOYS QUESTIONS 🤨 Should coaching changes be made?! | First Take

Original Media · 15m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

The panel debates whether the Dallas Cowboys should fire defensive coordinator Christian Parker mid-season, with Jeff Saturday arguing against it while Stephen A. Smith criticizes head coach Brian Schottenheimer's accountability and the team's culture of comfort. They also discuss the NFC North's playoff prospects and whether the road to the Super Bowl still runs through Kansas City given Patrick Mahomes' injuries and rising AFC competition.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A former player who won a Super Bowl with the Giants says he was treated better every day in Dallas without winning than he was in New York after winning, highlighting how the Cowboys' brand comfort may undermine competitive drive.

•

Christian Parker is a 34-year-old first-year defensive coordinator who was considered a 'boy wonder' under Vic Fangio, but was handed a roster with massive turnover, suggesting his struggles are situational rather than purely incompetence.

•

The Packers currently have more wins than two NFC division leaders despite a 6-4 record, illustrating the NFC North's unusual depth where all four teams are above .500 at Week 10.

Key takeaways

•

Jeff Saturday opposes a mid-season firing of defensive coordinator Christian Parker, arguing it would distract the coaching staff and that Jerry Jones historically avoids in-season changes, so the Cowboys should wait until the offseason to evaluate.

•

Stephen A. Smith condemns Brian Schottenheimer for calling himself a 'great coach' while holding a sub-.500 record, saying he focuses on aesthetics rather than the bottom-line results that define great coaches like Bill Parcells and Bill Belichick.

•

The Cowboys' defensive collapse — 68 plays of 20+ yards allowed and three 65+ yard plays in one game — reflects a locker room lacking leadership and urgency, which a former player attributes to the 'posh life' at The Star facility breeding comfort over competitiveness.

•

Jeff Saturday proposes hiring Rex Ryan as defensive coordinator to instill accountability, noting Ryan would not tolerate players getting run over and returning to the sideline without consequence.

•

The panel agrees the NFC North is the NFL's strongest division, but Stephen A. Smith predicts only three of its four teams will make the playoffs because they beat each other up, while the other analyst believes all four will qualify.

•

Despite Patrick Mahomes' ankle injury and offensive line struggles, Stephen A. Smith maintains the Super Bowl runs through Kansas City because Mahomes remains the 'boogeyman' of the AFC playoffs with only two career AFC playoff losses.

•

The Cowboys' offense has failed in critical moments, such as producing nothing in the fourth quarter against Arizona while holding a two-possession lead, undermining confidence in Schottenheimer's play-calling and the team's overall direction.

Notable quotes

“It's pretty difficult to get in the ring and get in there in that fight when you you sleeping in silk pajamas.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:46

“The Dallas Cowboys are closer to being reality TV stars than a competent NFL football team.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:26

“You are what your record says you are.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:17

“It's hard to eat when you're full.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:12

“Patrick Mahomes is still the boogeyman in the AFC playoffs.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:30

“This defense, Stephen A, they gave up over almost 600 yards of offense. On the season, they've given up 68 plays of 20 yards or more. Stephen A, you don't have to practice to do that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:28

Chapters

•

0:34 — Cowboys coaching crisis: The panel debates whether the Cowboys should fire defensive coordinator Christian Parker mid-season, with Jeff Saturday arguing against in-season changes and Stephen A. Smith criticizing head coach Brian Schottenheimer's accountability and the team's culture of comfort.

•

10:18 — NFC North playoff predictions: The panel discusses whether all four NFC North teams will make the playoffs; most agree the division is strong but Stephen A. Smith predicts only three will qualify due to head-to-head matchups.

•

12:38 — Chiefs' Super Bowl path: The panel debates if the road to the Super Bowl runs through Kansas City, with opinions split on whether Mahomes' injuries and emerging AFC contenders make it too far to say.

Speakers

•

Stephen A. Smith — Host

•

Jeff Saturday — Analyst

⋮