Trump may REGRET suing the BBC for $10 billion

Original Media · 7m · English · YouTube · David Pakman

TLDR

Donald Trump is suing the BBC for $10 billion over a documentary edit about January 6th. The BBC subpoenaed former special counsel Jack Smith to testify about his investigation findings, but the Justice Department blocked his deposition, citing grand jury and classified material protections. This reveals how Trump's own lawsuit created discovery risks he now tries to avoid, while the DOJ appears to protect his interests.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Justice Department blocked Jack Smith's deposition after previously authorizing his congressional testimony on the same subject matter.

•

Trump's own lawsuit created the very discovery mechanism that could force examination of his January 6th conduct, which he now seeks to prevent.

•

A federal magistrate judge already determined Jack Smith has relevant information, yet the DOJ still moved to block his testimony entirely.

Key takeaways

•

Trump voluntarily filed the $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC, which opened the door for the BBC to seek discovery about his conduct on January 6th.

•

The BBC subpoenaed Jack Smith because his investigation concluded Trump was responsible for causing the January 6th violence and that the violence was foreseeable.

•

The Justice Department intervened to block Smith's deposition, arguing it could expose grand jury material and classified information, despite a federal magistrate judge ruling Smith has relevant information.

•

The DOJ previously allowed Smith to testify before Congress, creating an inconsistency the BBC highlights in arguing he should also be available for a deposition.

•

Trump's aversion to discovery mirrors a common litigation strategy where plaintiffs sue for defamation but then resist being questioned under oath about the underlying facts.

•

The BBC has refused to settle and is actively pursuing discovery, which is unusual for media organizations facing costly litigation from powerful figures.

•

The episode illustrates how the Justice Department under the Trump administration is positioned to protect Trump's personal legal interests in civil litigation.

Notable quotes

“You may have heard that Donald Trump is suing the BBC for $10 billion.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:00

“This is a remarkable but not super surprising development, because Trump is the one who decided to bring this lawsuit in the first place.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:31

“BBC has acknowledged the edit was misleading.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:51

“A federal magistrate judge already determined Smith has information relevant to Trump's speech and to the Capitol attack.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:10

“Lawsuits open the door to discovery.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:54

“But at least so far, good for the BBC for not simply laying down and giving Trump 10 million or something to go away.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:48

Chapters

•

0:00 — Trump's BBC lawsuit overview: Trump is suing the BBC for $10 billion over a documentary edit about January 6th; the BBC is fighting back rather than settling.

•

1:03 — BBC subpoenas Jack Smith: The BBC sent a subpoena to former special counsel Jack Smith to question him about his investigation into Trump's role in January 6th.

•

1:24 — Documentary background and lawsuit details: The BBC documentary misleadingly edited Trump's January 6th speech; the BBC apologized, but Trump filed a massive defamation suit, prompting the BBC to seek evidence about Trump's actual conduct.

•

3:08 — DOJ blocks Smith's deposition: The Justice Department informed Smith's lawyers he cannot be deposed, citing grand jury and classified material protections, despite a judge ruling Smith has relevant information.

•

4:27 — Congressional testimony inconsistency: The DOJ previously allowed Smith to testify before Congress; the BBC argues this undermines the claim that he cannot testify in a deposition.

•

4:54 — Discovery risk and Trump's aversion: Lawsuits enable discovery; Trump's lawsuit exposes him to questioning about January 6th, which he wants to avoid, mirroring a common plaintiff strategy.

•

5:28 — Host's personal discovery anecdote: The host recounts being threatened with a lawsuit and learning that plaintiffs often drop cases to avoid discovery and legal fee exposure.

•

6:57 — Conclusion and new January 6th fears: The BBC's resistance is notable; the host transitions to discussing growing fears about a new January 6th-type event.

Speakers

•

Host — Legal/political commentator

⋮