She Went to Meet Her Divorce Lawyer… Then Was Stabbed 11 Times | Aliza Sherman

Original Media · 51m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

Aliza Sherman was stabbed 11 times outside her divorce attorney's office in Cleveland on March 24, 2013, three days before her contentious divorce trial. The case went cold for over a decade until her attorney, Gregory Moore, was arrested in 2025 and charged with aggravated murder, conspiracy, and kidnapping, with prosecutors alleging he orchestrated the attack to delay the trial. The defense has since shifted focus to Aliza's ex-husband Sanford Sherman, who died in 2024, citing testimony that he asked a friend years earlier how to commit the "perfect murder."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The attorney who was supposed to protect Aliza in her divorce trial is the one charged with orchestrating her murder to avoid going to court.

•

Gregory Moore called in multiple bomb threats to courthouses simply because he was unprepared for hearings, a pattern that prosecutors say escalated to planning a kidnapping and murder for the same reason.

•

The killer's methods — no gun, fully covered clothing, no vehicle — allegedly match advice Sanford Sherman received from a friend years earlier about how to commit the "perfect murder."

•

Moore continued texting and calling Aliza after she was dead to manufacture evidence that he didn't know what happened.

•

The law firm allegedly gave Moore new phones and never turned over older devices to detectives, potentially helping him avoid detection.

Key takeaways

•

Aliza Sherman was lured to a locked office building on a Sunday evening by her divorce attorney Gregory Moore, who texted her he was waiting at the door but key card records show he had left the building an hour earlier and didn't return until two hours after the attack.

•

Gregory Moore had a documented pattern of calling in bomb threats to courthouses to delay proceedings when he was unprepared, including one in July 2012 and three more in 2016, for which he pleaded guilty and lost his law license.

•

Prosecutors allege Moore used a law firm mobile hotspot to text Aliza while his work phone was off-network to make his communications less traceable, and continued texting and calling her at least nine times after she was already dead to create a false alibi.

•

New DNA testing in 2021 on Aliza's watch and wristband revealed an unknown male's DNA alongside hers, prompting the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation to re-examine the case and pursue Moore.

•

The defense argues investigators focused on Moore too early and overlooked Sanford Sherman, Aliza's ex-husband, who allegedly asked a longtime friend multiple times how to commit the "perfect murder" and received advice matching the killer's methods: no gun, cover face and hands, wear bulky clothing, don't use a vehicle.

•

Sanford Sherman denied any involvement and the nurse he allegedly confessed to in Florida denied he ever made such a statement; BCI closed that tip as unfounded.

•

Moore was released on $2 million bond in July 2025 with strict GPS monitoring, and the trial has faced repeated delays due to defense motions challenging evidence, search warrants, and requesting dismissal based on speedy trial violations.

•

A civil lawsuit filed by Aliza's family in May 2026 alleges the law firm knew of Moore's deceptive behavior including bomb threats but kept him on staff, and that a voicemail Aliza left on the day of her murder was deleted and surveillance footage may have been destroyed.

Notable quotes

“She was always, even as a little girl, always always looked out for other people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:37

“I think she was one of the few people I've come across on this earth that genuinely did things out of the goodness of her heart with zero expectation of anything in return.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:41

“If you don't think he's a suspect, I don't know what you're doing on your job.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:56

“He essentially lied to them and claimed that he was at work in his office that day. When Aliza notified him that he was there, he said that he went down to the lobby and looked outside and did not see her. And we know that that is absolutely false because he was not in the building that day.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:52

“How can a perfect murder be committed? He kept asking that question, 'How do you do it?' He kept saying, 'Aliza Sherman will never get a penny from this case.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 44:47

“If he could do this to our mother, then none of us are safe.”

▸ Notable quotes · 39:17

Chapters

•

2:29 — Aliza's Life and Marriage: Aliza Sherman's background as a nurse, mother of four, and her troubled 30-year marriage to Sanford Sherman marked by domestic violence and a contentious divorce.

•

10:35 — The Murder: On March 24, 2013, Aliza was lured to her attorney's locked office building, left waiting in the cold, and stabbed 11 times on the sidewalk; Kenny Shepherd found her and called 911.

•

19:00 — Investigation Stalls: Police found surveillance footage of a hooded figure but couldn't identify the attacker; the case went cold despite a reward and public rallies.

•

24:44 — Attorney Gregory Moore's Crimes: Moore was indicted for bomb threats to courthouses and later for falsification related to lying about his whereabouts on the day of Aliza's murder; he pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor and lost his law license.

•

30:41 — Cold Case Reopened: In 2021, BCI took over the case, new DNA testing found unknown male DNA on Aliza's watch, and a tip about Sanford Sherman's alleged confession was investigated but deemed unfounded.

•

32:59 — Moore Arrested for Murder: In May 2025, Moore was arrested in Texas and charged with 10 felonies including aggravated murder; prosecutors allege he orchestrated the kidnapping and murder to delay the divorce trial.

•

43:00 — Defense Shifts to Sanford Sherman: Moore's defense argues investigators overlooked Sanford, citing testimony that he asked a friend how to commit the perfect murder and received advice matching the killer's methods.

•

46:49 — Ongoing Legal Battles: Civil lawsuit filed against Moore and his law firm; defense motions to dismiss based on speedy trial violations; new phone evidence submitted; attorney conflict of interest; trial delayed.

Speakers

•

Anne-Marie Lease — Host/Narrator

•

Kenny Shepherd — Witness

•

Jennifer Sherman — Aliza's Daughter

•

Larry Shankman — Sanford Sherman's Friend

•

News Anchors/Reporters — Media Coverage

⋮