THE MENU Movie Reaction – Anya Taylor-Joy Devoured This Role! - First Time Watching

Original Media · 1h 30m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

The hosts of the Reject Nation podcast watch and react to the 2022 horror-comedy film 'The Menu,' starring Ralph Fiennes as a celebrity chef who orchestrates a deadly tasting menu for wealthy guests. They provide real-time commentary on the film's twists, performances, and themes of class, art, and service industry dynamics, followed by a post-screening discussion answering Patreon subscriber questions about the ending, character morality, and favorite horror films.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts reveal that John Leguizamo's character (a washed-up actor) was complicit in his assistant's embezzlement and likely had secret apartments for affairs, making him more culpable than he initially appears.

•

Ralph Fiennes practiced his 'Ralph Fiennes' pronunciation all night before recording because he'd said it wrong '10,000 times' in a previous episode.

•

The film's director Mark Mylod directed episodes of Succession and Game of Thrones, and is set to direct the first episode of the upcoming Harry Potter HBO series.

•

Judith Light (the older woman at the rich couple's table) was a Broadway star in 'A Doll's House' and appeared on 'One Life to Live,' which Tara watched as a child.

•

Arturo Castro (one of the tech bros) is a comedic actor from Broad City and The Vince Staples Show, not a dramatic actor as his role might suggest.

•

The hosts initially thought the film was a happy cooking movie like 'Chef' (2014) and were blindsided by the horror elements.

Key takeaways

•

The hosts highlight how Ralph Fiennes' Chef Slowik embodies an artist who has lost his purpose, with his calm menace and occasional glimpses of humanity making him a compelling antagonist rather than a one-dimensional villain.

•

Anya Taylor-Joy's character Margot (revealed as Erin) survives by recognizing Slowik's nostalgia for simple cooking and ordering a cheeseburger, which the hosts interpret as her meeting him on his level rather than outsmarting him.

•

Nicholas Hoult's Tyler represents toxic fandom — a self-absorbed 'foodie' who worships chefs but lacks actual skill, culminating in a humiliating cooking demonstration that exposes his incompetence.

•

The film's class commentary resonates with the hosts, particularly Tara's service industry experience, as they discuss how the kitchen staff's military precision mirrors abusive workplace dynamics where the chef's mood dictates everyone's wellbeing.

•

The hosts debate which guests 'deserved' to die, concluding that while Tyler and the embezzlers were worst, the critic Lillian Bloom and actor John Leguizamo's character were more ambiguous — Bloom damaged livelihoods with words, while Leguizamo enabled theft and infidelity.

•

The s'mores finale — where guests are coated in marshmallow and chocolate then set ablaze — is framed as Slowik's 'masterpiece,' turning the diners into ingredients in his final conceptual dish, which the hosts find both horrifying and darkly comedic.

•

The hosts appreciate the film's genre blend, noting it functions more as a dark comedy and class satire than pure horror, with the isolated island setting and single-location structure amplifying tension.

•

Margot's escape on a Coast Guard boat leaves her fate ambiguous; the hosts lean toward her surviving because Slowik genuinely rediscovered joy cooking the burger, but acknowledge the aged meat theory as a plausible dark reading.

Notable quotes

“You've spat in the name of art. And what about her? What school did you go to? Brown. Student loans? No. I'm sorry. You're dying.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:28

“When I eat your food, it tastes like it was made with no love. We always cook with love. Everyone knows love is the most important ingredient. Say you want a burger. Come on, chef. If I thought tonight was a night of hard home truths, this is one of them. You cook with obsession, not love.”

▸ Notable quotes · 58:23

“I think she definitely made it out alive. I think the picture he wouldn't have foreseen that she had gone into his house to see that picture to get the information to ask for the cheeseburger from when he was a kid.”

▸ Notable quotes · 75:31

“She let the plan go accordingly. She just said, 'I'm going to take this to go, please and thank you.' So, yeah, I don't feel like it was that ambiguous.”

▸ Notable quotes · 77:14

“The reason I would go with Train to Busan is because it hits emotionally as a horror film and that's what that's what sticks with me.”

▸ Notable quotes · 87:40

“Ray Fines was absolutely incredible. And that little tick his character has freaking scared me several times throughout the film. And also the calmness that you feel when he but you know he's boiling underneath and so scary at the same time.”

▸ Notable quotes · 88:07

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro and Movie Setup: Hosts Andrew, Tara, and Roxy introduce themselves and the film 'The Menu,' noting it's been requested for over a year. They establish their dynamic as horror reaction hosts with Andrew sometimes 'bullied' into participating.

•

2:00 — First Act: Arrival at Hawthorne: The hosts react to the boat ride to the private island, the $1250 price point, the staff's cult-like devotion, and the introduction of Chef Slowik (Ralph Fiennes). They note the Harry Potter references and the immediate tension between guests and staff.

•

10:00 — The Courses Begin: Scallops and Breadless Bread: Reactions to the first courses: raw scallops with sea water emulsion, and the controversial 'breadless bread plate' where only dips are served. The critic Lillian Bloom's presence and the guests' varying responses to the conceptual dining are discussed.

•

21:00 — Taco Night and Tortilla Revelations: The 'Memory' course reveals Slowik's traumatic childhood via laser-engraved tortillas showing guests' secrets — tax fraud, bad movies, bank records. The hosts react to the escalating danger and the critic's split emulsion complaint.

•

28:00 — Violence Escalates: Suicide and Finger Cutting: Sous-chef Jeremy shoots himself after Slowik's brutal critique. Tyler's finger is cut off when he tries to leave. The hosts are genuinely shocked, noting the tonal shift from dark comedy to visceral horror.

•

40:00 — Margot's Identity and the Chef's House: Margot's real name (Erin) and background (Brockton, Massachusetts) are revealed. She discovers Slowik's past happiness in his private house — photos of him cooking simple food with family — which becomes key to the ending.

•

45:00 — The Man's Folly and the Hunt: Sous-chef Katherine stabs a male guest, then men are given a 45-second head start to run. Nicholas Hoult's Tyler refuses to run. The hosts discuss the militarized staff and the impossibility of escape on an island.

•

58:00 — The Cheeseburger and Escape: Margot orders a simple cheeseburger ($9.95 with fries), rekindling Slowik's joy in cooking. He lets her leave with the burger to-go. The hosts debate whether she truly escapes or if the meat was tainted.

Speakers

•

Andrew — Co-host

•

Tara — Co-host

•

Roxy — Co-host

⋮