TLDR
This episode covers the live oral argument before the New York Appellate Division First Department in Donald Trump's appeal of his 34-count felony conviction for falsifying business records to conceal hush money payments to Stormy Daniels. Trump's attorneys from Sullivan & Cromwell argue the conviction should be reversed on three main grounds: (1) the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) preempts the state prosecution because the case relied on FECA violations as the "unlawful means" supporting the election law conspiracy; (2) the jury should have been required to unanimously agree on which specific unlawful means (FECA, tax fraud, or bank fraud) constituted the conspiracy; and (3) presidential immunity bars admission of Trump's tweets, Hope Hicks testimony, and Michael Cohen's testimony about Trump's statements. The Manhattan DA's office counters that FECA preemption is narrow and doesn't bar state fraud and election integrity laws, that unanimity on the specific unlawful means is not required because "unlawful means" is a single element, and that any immunity error would be harmless given overwhelming evidence of guilt. The panel of five justices actively questioned both sides on preemption scope, unanimity requirements, preservation of arguments, and the application of the Supreme Court's Trump v. United States immunity ruling to a state prosecution.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The host reveals he was sworn in as a lawyer in 1992 in the very ceremonial courtroom where the appeal is being heard, and has argued appeals there himself.
Trump's counsel concedes that Judge Hellerstein's first 2023 ruling on removal was "correct" in recognizing FECA preemption would apply if FECA governed contributions and expenditures, but argues the second ruling was "superficial" because the DA shifted theories at the charge conference.
The prosecution acknowledges that FECA violations were "only partially" the basis for the falsifying business records charge, and that the jury was given a "menu of options" for unlawful means including tax fraud and bank fraud — not just FECA.
Trump's counsel argues that even a president's tweets about private affairs (like "don't hire this lawyer, he didn't flip") are official acts because responding to allegations of personal wrongdoing is part of the president's job and "fitness for office."
Four U.S. Supreme Court justices reportedly thought the presidential immunity issue in this case warranted review during Trump's sentencing proceedings, suggesting the issue has traction at the highest court.
The prosecution argues that speech or debate clause immunity — a constitutional legislative immunity — is subject to harmless error review, and therefore presidential immunity should be too, citing the U.S. amicus brief in Trump v. US.
Key takeaways
Trump's appeal centers on three arguments: FECA preemption, jury unanimity on "unlawful means," and presidential immunity barring key evidence — but the prosecution argues all three fail because the state's fraud and election integrity laws operate independently of FECA, "unlawful means" is a single element not requiring unanimity on specific predicate crimes, and any immunity error would be harmless.
The FECA preemption debate turns on whether New York's use of FECA violations as evidence of "unlawful means" constitutes direct regulation of federal campaigns (which FECA preempts) or merely uses FECA facts to support a state law conspiracy targeting election integrity and business record fraud (which the prosecution argues is permissible).
On unanimity, Trump's counsel argues the jury had to agree on at least one specific unlawful means (FECA, tax fraud, or bank fraud) because each is a distinct element of the conspiracy offense, while the prosecution contends "unlawful means" is a single element and the jury only needed to agree that some unlawful means were used, not which one.
The presidential immunity argument focuses on four tweets, Hope Hicks's testimony about a private conversation with Trump regarding the Stormy Daniels story, and Michael Cohen's testimony about Trump telling David Pecker "I'll take care of it." The prosecution argues tweets are public records admissible under Trump v. US, the Hicks conversation was not about official duties, and the Cohen-Pecker conversation involved private actors.
Multiple justices pressed on whether FECA's express preemption clause (52 U.S.C. § 30106(b)) bars any state prosecution that relies on FECA violations, with Trump's counsel citing Farmer v. United Steelworkers and Richardson v. Byrd for the proposition that a state claim based on a preempted federal statute is itself preempted.
The prosecution emphasized that AMI (National Enquirer) and Michael Cohen both admitted FECA violations in federal proceedings — AMI via an FEC conciliation agreement and Cohen via a guilty plea — but argued this doesn't trigger preemption because the state charges target broader harms: falsifying New York business records and corrupting the electoral process.
On preservation, the prosecution argued Trump waived the unanimity argument by conceding at the charge conference that unanimity was not legally required but merely a discretionary request, while Trump's counsel pointed to specific transcript pages where counsel stated unanimity was "an accurate statement of the law."
The panel questioned whether Trump v. United States constitutes a new constitutional rule that excuses preservation requirements, with Trump's counsel arguing it does in the context of a state criminal prosecution of a president, while the justices noted preservation still applies in other constitutional immunity contexts.
Notable quotes
“This court should reverse the president's conviction because it was infected by multiple fatal errors under New York and federal law.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:48“The district attorney turned a time-barred business records misdemeanor into a felony by stacking on top of that time-barred business records misdemeanor an obscure New York election misdemeanor.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:55“FECA says that it supersedes and preempts any provision of state law with respect to the election of Fed to federal office. And this is express preemption.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:58“The only thing that makes an agreement, which is what we're talking about here, a conspiracy either having an intention, is you've got to do it through unlawful means. And the only unlawful means that the other side focused on a trial was FICA.”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:23“If you have an element of an offense, and clearly the element of the offense here was was there among others a violation of FICA? Yes, I agree there was the others were tax fraud and then the bank fraud issue, but when a jury could have picked any one of them, you could have had a jury divided 4-4-4, you needed to have that be a unanimous jury.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:40“The Supreme Court made clear in its opinion that even as to official acts, even as to acts that are indisputably official, um, prosecutors can introduce the public record of the official act being made. And the tweets here are a perfect example of a public record.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:32Chapters
0:01 — Host Introduction and Case Background: The host, a New York appellate lawyer, provides context: Trump was convicted of 34 felony counts for falsifying business records to conceal hush money payments to Stormy Daniels before the 2016 election. He explains the New York court hierarchy (Supreme Court is the trial court, Court of Appeals is the highest court), notes Trump didn't raise presidential immunity at trial (waived it), and describes the appellate courtroom and procedures.
13:34 — Oral Argument Begins: Trump's FECA Preemption Argument: Trump's counsel Robert Affr (Sullivan & Cromwell) argues FECA expressly preempts the state prosecution because the DA relied on FECA violations as the "unlawful means" for the election law conspiracy, citing detailed jury instructions on FECA contribution limits and the prosecution's summation calling FECA the "most obvious ground for conviction."
16:14 — Justices Question FECA Preemption Scope and Carve-Outs: The justices probe whether FECA's preemption applies given carve-outs for similar offenses (WinRed, Stern), whether the jury had to find a FECA violation, and whether the state is directly regulating contributions/expenditures or merely using FECA facts to support a broader conspiracy charge. Trump's counsel argues the case is in FECA's "heartland."
32:25 — Unanimity Requirement Debate: Trump's counsel argues the jury should have been required to unanimously agree on at least one specific "unlawful means" (FECA, tax fraud, or bank fraud) because each is a distinct element of the conspiracy offense. Justices compare to burglary and larceny statutes, and debate whether the defense preserved this objection at the charge conference.
38:58 — Prosecution's Response: FECA Preemption Inapplicable: Stephen Wu for the People argues FECA preemption is narrow and doesn't bar state enforcement of anti-fraud statutes or election integrity laws. He contends the prosecution focused on falsifying New York business records and corrupting the electoral process, with FECA violations merely as one factual basis among many for the "unlawful means" element.
42:54 — Justices Press Prosecution on Preemption and Unanimity: Justices challenge the prosecution on whether a jury verdict based solely on a preempted FECA violation would be valid, whether "unlawful means" is an element requiring unanimity, and whether the defense preserved the unanimity objection. The prosecution distinguishes between elements and evidentiary facts, citing Matteo and burglary analogies.
54:04 — Presidential Immunity Argument: The prosecution addresses presidential immunity for Trump's tweets, Hope Hicks testimony, and Cohen's testimony about Trump's statements. They argue tweets are public records admissible under Trump v. US, the Hicks conversation was private and not about official duties, and the Cohen-Pecker conversation involved private actors. They also argue any error would be harmless given overwhelming evidence.
69:45 — Trump's Rebuttal on FECA, Unanimity, and Immunity: Trump's counsel rebuts that the case was fundamentally about FECA (citing the summation, jury instructions, and exclusion of Trump's FECA expert), reiterates the unanimity argument citing black letter conspiracy law and the Matteo case, and argues presidential immunity bars the Hicks testimony because she was a White House official discussing responses to press inquiries about the president's fitness for office.
Speakers
Host/Narrator — Legal commentator and host
Robert J. Affr — Appellate counsel for Donald Trump
Stephen Wu — Appellate counsel for the People (Manhattan DA's Office)
Appellate Justices — Panel of five justices