Death Row’s ‘Mean Girl’ Kept Piece of Teen's Skull, Wakes Up ANGRY After Botched Execution

Original Media · 1h 17m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

This episode examines the botched execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee, where two doses of pentobarbital failed to kill her, leaving her hospitalized and raising legal questions about retrying execution. Host Ashley Banfield details Pike's 1995 torture-murder of Colleen Slemmer, the gruesome failed execution procedure, and the ensuing legal limbo, while also exploring global execution methods and interviewing legal expert Paul Callan on the death penalty's future.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The medical examiner had to stop alphabetically labeling Colleen Slemmer's wounds because there were too many — she documented only major injuries after running out of letters.

•

Christa Pike ate breakfast with a piece of her victim's skull in her pocket, showing it to multiple classmates while singing and dancing.

•

The execution team opened and closed the viewing curtains three times during the procedure, hiding Pike's prolonged consciousness from witnesses.

•

Paul Callan argues that firing squads and the electric chair may now be more humane than lethal injection due to drug shortages caused by abolitionist pressure.

•

Nearly half of all recorded global executions in 2025 (1,257) were for drug offenses, not murder.

•

The French used the guillotine until the early 1990s, and there is debate whether consciousness persists for 25-30 seconds after decapitation.

Key takeaways

•

Christa Pike survived a double dose of pentobarbital during her September 30, 2026 execution attempt in Tennessee, was hospitalized, and later woke up, creating unprecedented legal territory.

•

Pike tortured and murdered 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in 1995 over a romantic rivalry, keeping a piece of Slemmer's skull as a trophy and showing it to classmates while smiling.

•

The execution protocol failed apparently because the drug was injected into tissue rather than a vein; witnesses heard Pike snoring and complaining of arm pain for over an hour behind closed curtains.

•

Tennessee Governor Bill Lee halted all 2026 executions and ordered an independent review; lawmakers are now discussing reverting to the electric chair or firing squad.

•

Anti-death penalty pressure on pharmaceutical companies has led to unreliable single-drug protocols from compounding pharmacies, which legal expert Paul Callan argues ironically causes more suffering.

•

Only 17 countries carried out executions in 2025; the U.S. (47 executions) shares the practice with nations like Iran, Saudi Arabia, China, and North Korea.

•

The 1947 Supreme Court precedent (Louisiana ex rel. Francis v. Resweber) allows a second execution attempt after a botched one, ruling the first was 'incomplete.'

•

Death penalty cases cost millions and take decades; Paul Callan predicts Pike's case will push more Americans toward abolition and life without parole.

Notable quotes

“She survived. I was just crazy. And then the curtains are open and close, I mean it was crazy. This execution was crazy. It didn't happen. She didn't die.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:36

“This woman has nothing to lose. She's already tortured a teenager to death, and then while she was in prison, tried to kill another inmate and got another 25 years added to her sentence.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:00

“Why the fuck are they closing the curtains? If this is a public process and we're proud of it, uh don't close the curtains in the middle of it. Because that just screams hooded justice, secret justice.”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:54

“The court held in that case, however, that he had not been executed the first time because it was an incomplete execution. And they ordered that the execution go forward and he was placed back in the electric chair and he was executed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 52:14

“Ironically those advocates are really leading to the torture sometimes of people who are being put to death.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:26

“We don't mandate equal torture for someone who did the horrible things that Christa Pike did. That's our rules. Those are our laws. And we fucked up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:30

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction: Christa Pike's Botched Execution: Ashley Banfield introduces the case of Christa Pike, whose execution by lethal injection failed after two doses of pentobarbital, leaving her on life support and creating legal chaos.

•

11:24 — The 1995 Murder of Colleen Slemmer: Detailed recounting of Pike's torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer at a Job Corps center, including Pike's own confession, witness testimony, and the gruesome autopsy findings.

•

30:00 — The Failed Execution Procedure: Eyewitness reporter Tori Gastner describes the execution chamber timeline: Pike conscious for over an hour, curtains opened and closed repeatedly, snoring and labored breathing heard, and eventual hospitalization.

•

44:18 — Global Death Penalty Landscape: Statistics from Amnesty International's 2025 report: 2,707 executions in 17 countries, methods used worldwide (hanging, firing squad, beheading, lethal injection, nitrogen gas), and the U.S. ranking among top executors.

•

49:19 — Interview with Legal Expert Paul Callan: Former prosecutor Paul Callan discusses legal precedents for botched executions, the 1947 Francis v. Resweber case, drug shortage causes, firing squad vs. electric chair, innocence concerns, and the death penalty's likely abolition.

•

76:48 — Conclusion and Ongoing Questions: Banfield summarizes the unresolved legal status: Pike's potential third execution attempt, gubernatorial review, legislative debates on execution methods, and the victim's mother's decades-long wait for justice.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

•

Paul Callan — Legal Expert

•

Tori Gastner — Reporter

•

Stephen Ferrell — Attorney

•

Judge (1996) — Sentencing Judge

⋮