TLDR
In 1995, The Jenny Jones Show taped a "secret crush" episode where Scott Amedure revealed his romantic interest in acquaintance Jonathan Schmitz on national television. Three days later, after finding a suggestive note from Scott, Schmitz bought a gun, went to Scott's home, and shot him twice in the chest, then called 911 to confess. At trial, Schmitz's attorneys successfully used the "gay panic defense" — arguing he lost control due to the victim's sexual orientation — to reduce his charges. The defense remains legal in most U.S. states. Scott's family blamed the show for ambushing Schmitz and exploiting the situation for ratings.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The gay panic defense is a recognized legal strategy that has successfully reduced murder charges in multiple U.S. cases.
As of 2018, only three states had banned the gay panic defense, meaning it remained legally viable in 47 states.
Jonathan Schmitz called the Jenny Jones producer the day after taping and said he and Scott had a "love connection" and "seemed really into one another," contradicting his later claim of panic.
The show's producers testified they explicitly told Schmitz his admirer could be a man or a woman, yet he still claimed he was blindsided.
Key takeaways
Daytime talk shows in the 1990s increasingly relied on shock value and sensational confrontations to boost ratings, treating guests' personal lives as entertainment.
The Jenny Jones Show producers told Jonathan Schmitz his secret admirer could be a man or woman, but Schmitz claimed he assumed it was his ex-fiancée and felt ambushed when it turned out to be a man.
After the taping, Scott Amedure left a sexually suggestive note for Schmitz, which Schmitz said triggered feelings of humiliation, anger, and fear about his own sexuality.
Schmitz purchased a gun the same day he read the note, drove to Scott's house, and shot him twice, then immediately called 911 and confessed while crying.
The "gay panic defense" — a legal strategy arguing a defendant lost self-control due to the victim's sexual orientation — was used to reduce Schmitz's conviction from first-degree to second-degree murder.
As of 2018, the gay panic defense was still permitted in every U.S. state except California, Illinois, and Rhode Island.
Scott's family sued The Jenny Jones Show, arguing producers manipulated guests and created a dangerous situation for ratings; a jury initially awarded $25 million, later overturned on appeal.
Schmitz's defense also cited his alcoholism, depression, thyroid condition, and substance use the night before the killing to argue diminished capacity.
Notable quotes
“It's called the gay panic defense. It's a thing. Let me tell you. Gay panic defense. Okay. What? Now, this sounds like an absolute joke, but surprise, it's a real thing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:59“In a gay panic defense, the defendant argues they lost control because of their victim's sexual orientation.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:24“Gay panic defense is permitted in every US state except California, Illinois, and Rhode Island as of 2018.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:43“If you really want to get off, I'm the only one who has the right tool.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:27“Jon called the studio the day after filming the show and told her that Jon and Scott had what producers referred to as a love connection. It was a match.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:42Chapters
0:00 — 1990s Daytime Talk Show Culture: The hosts describe the sensationalist nature of 1990s daytime talk shows like Jenny Jones, which used shock value and outrageous topics to attract viewers.
1:18 — The Secret Crush Episode Taping: Scott Amedure appears on The Jenny Jones Show to reveal his crush on Jonathan Schmitz, who is brought on stage unaware the admirer is a man.
3:43 — The Murder: After the taping, Schmitz finds a suggestive note from Scott, buys a gun, drives to Scott's house, and shoots him twice before calling 911 to confess.
7:06 — Trial and Gay Panic Defense: Schmitz's attorneys use the gay panic defense — arguing he lost control due to the victim's sexual orientation — along with claims of mental illness and intoxication to reduce the charges.
8:49 — Legal Status of Gay Panic Defense: The hosts explain that as of 2018, the gay panic defense remained legal in 47 states, with only California, Illinois, and Rhode Island having banned it.
Speakers
Speaker 1 — Co-host
Speaker 2 — Co-host