Electoral College On Life Support

Original Media · 22m · English · YouTube · LegalEagle

TLDR

The 2022 midterms created Democratic trifectas in five key swing states — Nevada, Arizona, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania — whose combined 61 electoral votes could push the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact past the 270 threshold needed to effectively nullify the Electoral College. The compact, joined by 18 states and DC since 2006, commits states to award their electors to the national popular vote winner once enough states join to control a majority of electoral votes. This workaround avoids a constitutional amendment, which is politically impossible today, by using states' constitutional authority to determine how their electors are appointed.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Electoral College's original design had electors cast two undifferentiated votes for president, causing the 1800 tie between Jefferson and his own running mate Burr that threw the election to the House for 36 ballots.

•

In 1969, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the League of Women Voters, organized labor, and the American Bar Association all supported abolishing the Electoral College — a consensus that has since vanished due to partisan polarization.

•

Donald Trump called the Electoral College 'a disaster for democracy' in 2012, then called it 'actually genius' a week after winning it in 2016 while losing the popular vote by nearly 3 million votes.

•

The 1969 amendment failed not because of small-state opposition but because segregationist senators convinced Northern Black and Jewish groups that their large states would lose influence under a national popular vote — a 'strange bedfellows' coalition that preserved the Electoral College for another half-century.

Key takeaways

•

The Electoral College was a rushed, half-baked compromise at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, not a carefully designed safeguard; delegates adopted it to finish the convention, and it immediately caused a constitutional crisis in the 1800 election that led to the 12th Amendment and contributed to Alexander Hamilton's death in a duel with Aaron Burr.

•

A constitutional amendment to abolish the Electoral College passed the House 339-70 in 1969 with bipartisan support including future presidents Ford and Bush, but was filibustered by segregationist senators led by Strom Thurmond who feared losing the Electoral College's amplification of white Southern power.

•

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact does not abolish the Electoral College; it harnesses it by having states pledge their electors to the national popular vote winner, but only once compact members collectively control 270 electoral votes — a threshold now within reach after the 2022 midterms.

•

The Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed states' 'broadest power of determination' over how they appoint electors (McPherson v. Blacker, 1892; Chiafalo v. Washington, 2020), providing a strong textual basis for the compact's constitutionality under the Electors Clause.

•

Critics argue the Compact Clause (Article I, Section 10) requires congressional consent, but the Court has long held it only bars state combinations that encroach on federal supremacy — which the compact does not, since it merely coordinates states' exercise of their existing elector-appointment power.

•

An equal protection challenge argues the compact unconstitutionally combines voters subject to different state voting rules into a single national pool, echoing the reasoning the Court used in Bush v. Gore — raising the prospect that the current conservative majority could strike down the compact on partisan lines.

•

Pennsylvania's 19 electoral votes are the linchpin; Governor Josh Shapiro has endorsed the compact, arguing Pennsylvania can remain influential under a national popular vote because candidates would have to campaign everywhere votes exist, not just in swing states.

•

If the compact reaches 270 electoral votes and survives legal challenges, the 2028 presidential election would be decided by the national popular vote, ending a system that has delivered the presidency to the popular-vote loser in two of the last six elections and rendered most voters invisible to campaigns.

Notable quotes

“The electoral college was a half-baked compromise that the exhausted framers of our country's foundational law just waved through in the final days of the constitutional convention during the hot Philadelphia summer of 1787.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:18

“The Constitution does not provide that the appointment of electors shall be by popular vote, nor that the electors shall be voted for upon a general ticket, nor that the majority of those who exercise the elective franchise can alone choose the electors.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:55

“The compact clause only is directed to the formation of any combination tending to the increase of political power in the states which may encroach upon or interfere with the just supremacy of the United States.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:02

“Break the law, get punished, win the most votes, take office. And yet the parties have polarized over both prospects in the age of Trump.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:13

Chapters

•

0:00 — Midterms and the Compact's Momentum: The 2022 midterms created Democratic trifectas in five swing states whose 61 electoral votes could push the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact past the 270 threshold, effectively ending the Electoral College without a constitutional amendment.

•

5:18 — The Electoral College's Flawed Origins: The Electoral College was a last-minute compromise at the 1787 Convention, adopted to break a deadlock between large and small states and slave and free states; it immediately caused the 1800 constitutional crisis that killed Alexander Hamilton.

•

10:48 — The 1969 Near-Miss Amendment: A constitutional amendment to establish direct popular election passed the House 339-70 with bipartisan support but was filibustered by segregationist senators who relied on the Electoral College to preserve white Southern political power.

•

13:08 — How the National Popular Vote Compact Works: Launched in 2006, the compact commits states to award electors to the national popular vote winner once members control 270 electoral votes; 18 states and DC have joined, totaling 222 votes.

•

15:46 — Legal Basis: States' Power Over Electors: Supreme Court precedent (McPherson v. Blacker, Chiafalo v. Washington) confirms states have plenary authority to determine how electors are appointed and to condition their appointment on voting for the national popular vote winner.

•

16:42 — Constitutional Challenges: Compact Clause and Equal Protection: Critics argue the Compact Clause requires congressional consent and that combining voters under different state rules violates equal protection; the Court's relaxed Compact Clause reading and its Bush v. Gore equal protection reasoning create uncertainty.

•

18:20 — Pennsylvania as the Deciding State: Pennsylvania's 19 electoral votes are essential to reach 270; Governor Josh Shapiro supports the compact, arguing Pennsylvania would remain influential because candidates would need to campaign everywhere under a national popular vote.

Speakers

•

Speaker 1 — Host

⋮