Confessions Of A Deep Sea Diver | Creep Cast

Original Media · 2h 15m · English · YouTube · CreepCast

TLDR

Creepcast hosts Hunter and Isaiah read and discuss two oceanic horror stories. First, 'Confessions of a Deep Sea Diver' (2014) follows a commercial diver recounting escalating supernatural encounters: hieroglyphic shells, a missing pilot from an intact plane, ghost divers, living WWII sailors who scream of burning eternity, a megalodon-sized shark, vanishing missiles, and a military prototype submarine where the crew is taken by entities and the divers are forced to destroy it. Second, 'A Silent Girl from a Whaling Sea' tells of a coastal town plagued by 'blue boys' (drowned bodies returned by the sea), a mob attacking a lighthouse keeper who imprisoned a siren, the narrator receiving the siren's memories of being a human woman captured and forced to sing for a drowned god, and the narrator ultimately rejecting then decades later accepting the siren's offer to join her beneath the waves.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The 'living' WWII sailor screams of an 'eternity spent burning' underwater, contradicting the assumption that drowning is cold and silent.

•

The mermaids/sirens do not kill for food or malice but sing to pacify a drowned god, making their predation a cosmic necessity rather than a choice.

•

The lighthouse keeper's 'magic' was actually science — he used potions and hallucinogens to suppress the siren's memories, not spells.

•

The narrator's human memories (London clerk, typewriters, waxed floors) were chemically induced hallucinations, meaning her 'real' life was the siren's existence all along.

•

The military forces civilian divers at gunpoint to plant charges on a prototype sub to destroy the entities inside, then threatens them with 'real consequences' for leaks — treating the supernatural as a security breach.

Key takeaways

•

The deep sea diver story uses a vignette structure where each incident stands alone but collectively builds a mythology of 'Keepers of the Deep' — dead divers cursed to roam the ocean and drag the living down out of envy.

•

In the WWII body recovery, the 'living' sailor's body rapidly decays once on deck, and he draws hieroglyphs of waves, flames, and bodies in blood before the supervisor scrubs the walls clean, implying institutional suppression of the truth.

•

The military prototype submarine is covered in scaled reflective metal with hieroglyphs carved from the bottom up, suggesting something massive has been climbing the hull; the crew inside is still alive but taken by entities when hatches open.

•

The siren's backstory reveals mermaids are not predators but a choir singing to soothe a 'drowned god' — an incomprehensibly vast entity at the bottom of the abyss — and they collect drowned souls as 'tribute' to swell their ranks.

•

The lighthouse keeper was not a villain but a captor studying the siren's voice to unravel the song, drugging her to suppress her memories; his deterioration suggests the drowned god's influence reached him through dreams.

•

The narrator refuses the siren's first offer of escape, choosing a human life of art and fame in London, but the longing never fades; decades later, insomnia and madness drive her back to the sea where she finally accepts.

•

Both stories frame the ocean as a space where normal rules invert: depth equals time (deeper carvings are older), the dead return altered, and human institutions (military, companies) are complicit in covering up or exploiting the supernatural.

•

The hosts note a shift in online horror writing from the 2014 'confessional vignette' style to the 2024 'lyrical folk-horror' style, with the latter using dense poetic prose and perspective shifts to deliver lore through emotional immersion rather than exposition.

Notable quotes

“We are not meant to roam the depths of the ocean. And when a diver loses his life in the deep, it doesn't stay that way. They're cursed to forever roam the oceans. When they find the living in an envious rage, they will bring you back to the depths from which they came.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:54

“There is neither peace nor pain, only an internal slumber, rocked by drowned lullabies.”

▸ Notable quotes · 96:51

“She is a cursed son from a far harbor. From far shores. I have tried to fix her, but the deep longs to reclaim their song.”

▸ Notable quotes · 98:08

“We weave our melodies not for ourselves or the lost souls at sea, but to lull him, to shield the waking world from his gaze, and to soothe his endless nightmarish hunger between his dreams.”

▸ Notable quotes · 104:52

“Under stars when you dream your last.”

▸ Notable quotes · 116:33

“The ocean just freaks me out. Being underwater freaks me out. I don't like the idea of being somewhere that I have to have equipment to live, you know?”

▸ Notable quotes · 60:04

Chapters

•

0:08 — Intro & Story 1 Setup: Hosts introduce 'Confessions of a Deep Sea Diver' by Pisendee (2014), a three-part nosleep classic about a commercial diver's supernatural encounters, and 'A Silent Girl from a Whaling Sea' by Sufficient_Leave_144 from their Tales From The Creep subreddit.

•

7:05 — Confessions Part 1: Vignettes: Diver recounts early incidents: hieroglyphic shells in tool bag, intact plane with missing pilot, extra bubble streams and shadow figures during demolition, ghost diver inside sunken ship, lost time on ocean floor amid human bones, and WWII sailors where one revives screaming of burning eternity.

•

40:58 — Confessions Part 2: Escalation: ROV finds fresh hieroglyphs carved up oil rig legs; megalodon-sized shark circles divers on decompression stage; wall of sand engulfs divers and makes missiles vanish; bridge recovery reveals ghost diver stealing a child from a minivan.

•

60:36 — Confessions Part 3: Prototype Sub: Former supervisor warns 'things are getting worse.' Military hires team to recover massive scaled prototype submarine. Divers hear banging inside, see figure dragging body, hatches open, umbilicals cut, standby diver attacked. Military forces team to destroy sub at gunpoint.

•

74:38 — Story 2: Whaling Sea Opening: Coastal town loses men to 'blue boys' — drowned bodies returned with indigo veins. Narrator's sister walks into sea. Mob forms, blames lighthouse keeper, attacks tower.

•

85:50 — Lighthouse Laboratory & Siren: Mob breaks in, finds lab with specimens and tentacled idol. Boy prays to idol, everyone vanishes except narrator, Rafe, boy. Downstairs: siren in glass cylinder. Keeper emerges bloated, oozing saltwater. Siren's eyes flash pink, enthralls Rafe and Caleb to attack keeper.

•

96:10 — Siren's Memories & Narrator's Choice: Narrator breaks glass, siren forces water down throat — narrator lives siren's life: human Sophie, shipwreck, lifeboat death, mermaids take her to sing for drowned god. Hunter captures her, drugs her, she regains human memories. Keeper deteriorates. Narrator wakes, helps Sophie to sea, refuses her offer to join.

•

121:40 — Epilogue & Discussion: Narrator lives human life, becomes artist in London, fame painting monsters, but longing persists. Insomnia, madness, returns to pier, Sophie calls again, narrator accepts and enters sea. Hosts praise story's lyrical prose, perspective shift, and folk-horror depth.

Speakers

•

Hunter — Co-host

•

Isaiah — Co-host

⋮