FDD EXECUTIVE CALLS FOR THE U.S. TO REVISE NUCLEAR DOCTRINE FOR IRAN WAR – w/ Jonathan Schanzer

Original Media · 52m · English · YouTube · Mario Nawfal

TLDR

Brandon Wert and Jonathan Shanzer debate whether escalating military action against Iran can achieve regime change, given three US carriers in the region. Shanzer argues the rules-based international order constrains US warfighting while adversaries fight asymmetrically, and that sanctions were poorly enforced for decades. Both question Israel's ability to join a new campaign with Netanyahu as caretaker PM, and Trump's political calculus after midterm losses. They clash on whether US decline stems from Middle East wars of choice or systemic failures including deindustrialization and China's rise.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Shanzer, a hawkish FDD scholar, explicitly questions whether the US-led rules-based international order serves American interests, arguing it prevents victory while adversaries ignore it.

•

Shanzer suggests the US might need to consider changing its own warfighting rules — including potentially using tactical nuclear weapons — not because he wants to, but because the current framework yields no victories.

•

Netanyahu's caretaker status and lack of IDF buy-in may prevent Israel from joining a US-Iran war, despite Israeli media reporting Netanyahu pressuring Trump to escalate.

•

The US redeployed a Patriot or THAAD battery from Saudi Arabia to Israel in recent weeks, causing a 'stir' in Riyadh, revealing how thin missile defense resources are stretched.

•

Shanzer argues the Nixon opening to China was 'one of the worst moves ever made by an American diplomat' and would arrest that moment if he could, blaming it for decades of strategic disaster.

Key takeaways

•

The US has not won a decisive war in decades — Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Iran — because the rules-based order it created ties its hands with precise, expensive munitions while adversaries like Iran fight asymmetrically, targeting energy infrastructure and civilian airports without restraint.

•

Sanctions on Iran were enforced 'limply' for 40 years with gaping holes via Turkey, Iraq, and UAE; Shanzer argues a proper economic siege before military action would have weakened the regime, but the current sequence gives Iran time to adapt and find US vulnerabilities.

•

Israel may not join a new US-Iran war because Netanyahu leads a caretaker government on an interim budget, and his IDF chief of staff Zamir has reportedly resisted; deploying Israeli forces would effectively legitimize Netanyahu's authority during a contested political transition.

•

Trump faces a legacy dilemma: after a resounding midterm defeat, he can either leave the Iran war unresolved and be seen as defeated twice, or escalate with a credible plan — but Shanzer warns against a 'drunk guy at the casino' approach without a strategy that actually topples the regime.

•

US missile defense stocks (Patriots, THAAD) are severely depleted defending allies across the region, including a recent redeployment from Saudi Arabia to Israel that caused diplomatic friction; standoff munitions are also drawn down, though JDAMs remain plentiful.

•

Shanzer raised the possibility of using tactical nuclear weapons on deeply buried sites like Pickax Mountain not as endorsement but to illustrate that the current rules-based framework may be fundamentally incompatible with winning; he argues the system needs changing so adversaries fear US power again.

•

The hosts fundamentally disagree on whether US global retreat stems from Middle East wars (Wert) or from a broader systemic failure including deindustrialization, technology theft by China, and an order that lets rivals 'leapfrog' the US while America follows gentlemanly rules (Shanzer).

•

Yemen's Houthi control of Bab al-Mandeb is a strategic blind spot in Washington; Shanzer calls it a 'black hole' where the US is sleepwalking, while Wert argues it's Europe's problem and notes the US withdrawal in 2024 didn't cause collapse.

Notable quotes

“We created this system, this rules-based international order, right? We created it after 1945. We created after World War II. And it was like, hey, we're never going to have a terrible war like the kinds of wars that we had in World War I, World War II, right? The idea was we're going to put guard rails on everybody. And because it's our system, we're going to lead by example and everybody's going to see they can buy into this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:58

“What bothers me right now is we can't win with the rules that we've created. I mean, look at wars that we have fought now over the last several decades. When's the last time we saw a real victory, right? ... Like, when we look at every other war that we fought, specifically in the Middle East, we're getting our butts handed to us and we are playing by these rules, we're dropping insanely expensive, precise munitions, and by all measure, we should be winning. We should be getting surrender. But we're not consistently.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:44

“It seems like we are fighting with a hand be tied behind our back consistently that the fact that we can't win this Iranian regime. Let's just be clear. This is a low-end military. This is a middling country with no economy to speak of.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:13

“We're not fighting to win is what I would say my big argument is. We seem to be doing this with one hand tied behind our back with the system that we created because we're like, hey, we need everybody to behave like us except we can't win. And so slowly we're seing that power and we're bleeding it out and everyone else seems to be eating our breakfast.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:36

“I would love to see a regime change ... Let me just say I what I don't want to do is I don't want to have forces on the ground imposing the rules. I don't want to see a Paul Bremer come in and issue two orders that screw everything up. Like I mean this is the stuff that I think we learned that we're not really good at at like state building.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:06

“If we seed leadership in the world, right, if we stand back, right, you think about what happened with the when the sun set on the British Empire, right, and they're like, 'Hey, we can't do this anymore. Ran out of gas. We got no money,' ... What happens when we run out of gas? ... The Chinese empire and good luck to all of us.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:08

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening: Carrier deployment and Iran war stalemate: Three US carriers are in the Middle East; hosts question whether another round of air war can change facts on the ground or achieve a political end state against Iran.

•

2:30 — Israel's political constraints on joining a war: Netanyahu is a caretaker PM on an interim budget; his IDF chief Zamir has reportedly resisted military action, and deploying forces would legitimize Netanyahu during a contested transition.

•

5:30 — Trump's legacy calculus after midterm defeat: Trump faces a choice: leave the Iran war unresolved and be seen as twice-defeated, or escalate with a credible plan — but risks a 'drunk guy at the casino' gamble without a winning strategy.

•

12:00 — Munitions and missile defense depletion: Standoff munitions and missile defense interceptors (Patriots, THAAD) are heavily drawn down defending regional allies; a battery was recently moved from Saudi Arabia to Israel, causing diplomatic tension.

•

15:00 — Tactical nuclear option and rules-based order critique: Shanzer clarifies his earlier mention of tactical nukes on Pickax Mountain as a thought experiment: the current rules-based order prevents victory while adversaries fight without restraint, suggesting the system itself may need changing.

•

19:00 — US war record and sanctions failures: The US hasn't won a decisive war in decades; sanctions on Iran were enforced 'limply' for 40 years with gaps via Turkey, UAE, and Iraq, giving the regime time to adapt.

•

29:30 — Negotiated settlement vs. regime change debate: Wert argues for a negotiated settlement per JD Vance; Shanzer counters that negotiations would legitimize the regime and likely involve concessions on Hormuz and Bab al-Mandeb without guarantees.

•

31:30 — Yemen, global leadership, and China: Houthi control of Bab al-Mandeb is a strategic blind spot; hosts clash on whether US decline stems from Middle East wars or systemic failures including deindustrialization and China's rise within the US-created order.

Speakers

•

Brandon Wert — Host

•

Jonathan Shanzer — Guest

⋮