Sonia Exelby | a Shallow Grave, a Secret Package & a Fatal Mistake (Part 2)

Original Media · 1h 59m · English · YouTube · Crime Weekly

TLDR

In Part 2 of the Sonia Elby case, hosts Stephanie Harlow and Derrick Levasseur detail how 32-year-old Sonia traveled from England to Florida to meet Dwayne Hall, a man she met on Motherless.com who used the username 'alpha sadist.' Hall purchased a shovel, paracord, rope, and gun cleaner the day she arrived, then drove her to a remote Airbnb in Reddick. Over the weekend, Hall made suspicious trips — including a 20-mile drive to Gainesville for a single iced coffee — while Sonia's whereabouts remained unknown. Hall was later interrogated, where he admitted helping Sonia die but refused to disclose her location. Police found her body in a shallow grave near his home using his cell phone data; the murder weapon, an engraved knife Hall had mailed to his friend Rick Snyder in Ohio, tested positive for Sonia's blood. Messages between Hall and Snyder suggest a pattern of prior crimes and a possible network involving 'death cult' beliefs.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The murder weapon was mailed by the killer to his friend in another state via UPS, with tracking and insurance, and the friend hid it in a sewn fabric bag in his bedroom drawer.

•

Hall and Snyder's messages reference 'for the love of shadows' and an Anubis/Egyptian death god belief system, suggesting a ritualistic or cult-like framework for their crimes.

•

Hall's wife Ginger met him at age 16 when he was 26, and hosts suspect she was groomed; she later received a package containing the murder weapon and communicated with Snyder, yet has not been charged.

•

Hall cleaned a gun in his truck the weekend of the murder, claiming it was rusty after 18 months of disuse — but experts note gun cleaning is typically done at a bench, not in a vehicle, and can remove evidence of recent firing.

•

Sonia had booked a return flight, which initially suggested she might change her mind, but hosts conclude that flying 4,000 miles for a planned death makes the return ticket a mere immigration formality.

Key takeaways

•

Dwayne Hall purchased a shovel, paracord, rope, and gun cleaner at Walmart on the day Sonia Elby arrived in Florida, then drove her to a remote Airbnb in Reddick where she was last seen alive.

•

Hall's movements were tracked via surveillance and cell data: he drove 20 miles to Gainesville for a single iced coffee (passing a closer Dunkin' in Ocala), bought food for one at Dollar General and a Petro station, and left trash with his DNA at the Airbnb — all while Sonia's location remained unaccounted for.

•

During a 4-hour interrogation, Hall initially claimed Sonia left with a man named Harold in a blacked-out Eldorado, but eventually admitted he helped her die and knew where her body was, saying he couldn't break his promise to her not to reveal the location.

•

Police found Sonia's remains in a shallow grave near Hall's home in Ocala using his cell phone coordinates; the shovel label in the grave matched the one Hall bought at Walmart, and the shovel handle bore both Hall's and Sonia's DNA.

•

The murder weapon was a 7-inch Cold Steel Recon Tanto knife engraved 'dork warf pointy end goes in the other guy' — a joke about Hall's online persona 'Dark Wolf' — which Hall mailed to his childhood friend Rick Snyder in Ohio after the killing; Sonia's blood was found on the knife.

•

Facebook messages between Hall and Snyder reveal coded language about a 'storm coming,' a 'box' containing 'precious items,' and Snyder's reply: 'Admit it. We get caught way less when I'm with you,' implying prior joint criminal activity.

•

Hall told Snyder the knife was one of his 'most prized possessions' and he felt 'strangely naked without it,' suggesting it was a signature weapon used in previous killings.

•

Sonia's sisters stated she became more isolated and desperate in the months before the trip, describing Hall's control as akin to an abusive relationship; Hall had 'mentored' her for two years, dictating her routines and sexual behavior, which investigators view as coercive control and grooming.

Notable quotes

“I know that she is not alive anymore. You know that. And I want to find her.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:12

“I was the last one to see her alive.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:48

“I tried to talk her out of it. I tried to talk her out of it many times over the last year or so that she and I had talked.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:08

“She was supposed to bring cash. She wasn't supposed to bring cards. She was supposed to bring cash. Because it's traceable. I owe the IRS almost $10,000 for the last two years.”

▸ Notable quotes · 72:31

“Admit it. We get caught way less when I'm with you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 98:45

“This is the last time I'll taste something.”

▸ Notable quotes · 65:52

Chapters

•

5:05 — Hall's Preparation and Sonia's Arrival: On October 10, Hall bought a shovel, paracord, rope, and gun cleaner at Walmart, then picked up Sonia at Gainesville airport and drove her to the Reddick Airbnb.

•

14:14 — Suspicious Weekend Movements: On October 11, Hall drove 20 miles to Gainesville for a single iced coffee, visited Dollar General and a Petro station in Reddick, and left trash with his DNA at the Airbnb — all while Sonia's location was unknown.

•

36:06 — Interrogation: First Round: On October 17, FDLE Agent McKenzie and Detective Miller interrogated Hall; he claimed Sonia left with 'Harold,' but agents pressed him using good cop/bad cop tactics, leading Hall to admit he was the last to see her alive.

•

65:00 — Interrogation: Recantation and Confession: After asking for a lawyer, Hall recanted his statement, admitting he and Sonia created a cover story, she was supposed to bring $10,000 cash for his IRS debt, and he helped her die but won't reveal her location due to a promise.

•

82:50 — Body Discovery and Arrest: Police used Hall's cell data to find Sonia's body in a shallow grave near his home; the shovel label matched his Walmart purchase, and the shovel handle had both their DNA. Hall was arrested for credit card fraud.

•

108:00 — Murder Weapon Mailed to Accomplice: From jail, Hall told his wife Ginger that friend Rick Snyder would send a package; police found an engraved knife with Sonia's blood in Snyder's possession, along with Facebook messages coordinating the handoff and referencing prior crimes.

•

136:40 — Grooming, Coercive Control, and Network: Hall 'mentored' Sonia for two years, controlling her routines and sexuality; his wife Ginger met him at 16, suggesting grooming; messages between Hall and Snyder imply a pattern of killings and a death-cult belief system.

Speakers

•

Stephanie Harlow — Host

•

Derrick Levasseur — Host

•

Dwayne Hall — Suspect

•

Agent Rebecca McKenzie — Investigator

•

Detective Joseph Miller — Investigator

•

Ginger Stein — Hall's Wife

•

Rick Snyder — Accomplice

⋮