TLDR
In 1975, 18-year-old Sarah Cindy White set a house fire that killed the Roberson family of six — Charles, Carol, and their four young children — while living with them as a babysitter. White claims she was being sexually abused and held captive by the couple, but prosecutors argued she was a jilted lover who lashed out. After 50 years in prison, Indiana's longest-serving female inmate maintains she only wanted to escape, not kill, and has earned extensive rehabilitation credentials while filing numerous clemency appeals. The interview probes her credibility given a documented history of pathological lying and the impossibility of corroborating her abuse allegations against her dead victims.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
White prayed before striking the match, asking God to prevent the fire if it was not His will, and says she genuinely believed everyone would escape.
White says she would not want the death penalty for someone who did what she did because 'that's too easy' — they should 'live with it every single day just like I do.'
White states the prison she is in 'is not here on Girl School Road. The prison I'm in is [her mind] and I want that. I want this help because this is what I deserve.'
The prosecutor notes White's abuse allegations emerged only after she had killed the only two people who could rebut them, calling the timing 'awfully convenient.'
White admits she would not forgive herself if she were a third party, yet still wants freedom 'to have something I've never had.'
Key takeaways
White endured severe childhood sexual abuse by her father from age eight, leading to conversion disorder (hysterical paralysis) and a 10-month psychiatric hospitalization at 16 where she was diagnosed with a tendency to exaggerate and distort facts.
After her release at 18, White moved in with the Robersons, a family she had babysat for; she alleges Charles and Carol Roberson then subjected her to escalating sexual abuse, including forced pornography viewing, pornographic filmmaking, bestiality, and death threats against her sister, though investigators found only evidence of a consensual affair with Charles.
On New Year's Eve 1975, White intentionally set fire to the Christmas tree, saying she prayed God would stop it if not His will, and genuinely believed the smoke would wake everyone so they could escape; six people died of smoke inhalation while she escaped through a window with a memory gap at the critical moment.
White lied for a decade, claiming the fire was accidental, until she confessed in prison because she 'couldn't keep the lies straight'; three trial psychiatrists diagnosed her as a pathological liar whose distortions were defensive and fantasy-based.
In prison, White has earned a GED, four semesters of college, and multiple certifications (cosmetology, accounting, business math, sign language, blood pressure technology), tutors deaf inmates, and participates extensively in therapy groups, framing this as atonement.
White has filed at least ten clemency appeals since 1978; Prosecutor Lance Hamner argues her abuse allegations are fabricated for sympathy and notes she killed the only two people who could refute them, while the interviewer presses her on the contradiction between remorse and seeking release.
White states she would not forgive herself, would sentence someone else to life (not death row, because 'that's too easy'), and believes the real prison is her mind; she wants to die outside prison walls but acknowledges she does not deserve freedom.
Notable quotes
“I did it. I struck that match. And I set that fire. But it wasn't to kill anybody. It wasn't those innocent babies. Michael, Dale, Gary, and Rita all choked to death by that smoke in terror.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:37“I prayed to God before I struck that match and I said, "God, if this is your will, let it happen. But if it's not your will, please, please don't let it happen."”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:54“I set the house on fire, not meaning to kill anybody. God knows I didn't mean to kill him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 34:20“If I could give my life for this, I would. 7-year-old Michael, six-year-old Dale, 5-year-old Gary, and Rita, who was just four. All choked to death by that smoke in terror.”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:19“Life. Life. Not on death row because that's too easy. Too easy. They need to live with it every single day just like I do.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:18“The prison I'm in is not here on Girl School Road. The prison I'm in is and I want that. I want this help because this is what I deserve.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:18Chapters
4:14 — Childhood abuse and institutionalization: White describes being sexually abused by her father from age eight, developing conversion disorder (hysterical paralysis) to avoid weekend visits, and spending 10 months in a psychiatric hospital at 16 where she was diagnosed with a tendency to exaggerate and distort facts.
7:54 — Relationship with the Roberson family: White found refuge with the Robersons, who employed her as a babysitter; at 15 she became infatuated with Charles, and after moving in at 18 she alleges a three-month escalation of sexual abuse, forced pornography, bestiality, and death threats, while investigators found letters suggesting a consensual affair.
20:21 — The fire and escape: On New Year's Eve 1975, White set fire to the Christmas tree intending only to smoke the family out so she could flee; she describes praying for divine intervention, attempting to rescue the children, and escaping through a window with a memory gap at the moment of exit.
27:00 — Trial, lies, and confession: White initially claimed the fire was accidental; three psychiatrists diagnosed her as a pathological liar. After ten years in prison, she confessed to intentionally setting the fire because she could no longer maintain the lies.
36:44 — Prison rehabilitation and remorse: White has earned extensive educational and vocational credentials, tutors deaf inmates, and participates in therapy groups, framing these as atonement; she expresses deep remorse, naming each child victim and stating she would trade her life for theirs.
35:44 — Clemency bids and the credibility question: White has filed at least ten clemency appeals since 1978; Prosecutor Lance Hamner argues her abuse claims are fabricated for sympathy and notes the convenience of the victims being dead, while the interviewer challenges the contradiction between her remorse and continued pursuit of freedom.
41:19 — Final reflections on guilt and freedom: White says she would not forgive herself, would sentence a similar offender to life without parole, and believes her true prison is her mind; she admits wanting freedom 'to have something I've never had' but acknowledges she does not deserve it.
Speakers
Interviewer (David) — Journalist/Interviewer
Sarah Cindy White — Inmate/Convicted arsonist
Lance Hamner — Prosecutor