TLDR
The panel debates whether the Bengals' blowout win over the Steelers makes them the AFC's top team, with Stephen A. Smith arguing their schedule lacks elite opponents and teams like the Chiefs, Bills, and Jaguars remain superior. They also analyze the Chiefs' 35-13 win over the Falcons, concluding it proves little given Atlanta's 5 losses in 6 games, though Josh Downs' addition gives Mahomes a reliable secondary weapon.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Steelers' 23 yards on 32 plays in three quarters was so low that "you cannot play and do better" — non-participants could match that output.
The Falcons have lost five of their last six games despite possessing talent (Drake London, Bijan Robinson) that would be a "welcomed upgrade" for any NFL team.
Mahomes' first game with three-plus touchdown passes traveling 15+ air yards since 2020 came against a bottom-tier Atlanta defense.
Key takeaways
Joe Burrow joined Tom Brady and Peyton Manning as the only QBs with 20 touchdowns in a five-game span, but Cincinnati's seven wins came against Tampa, Houston, Miami, Baltimore, Tennessee, Atlanta, and Pittsburgh — none of which are current AFC elite.
The Steelers' offense produced historically inept numbers: minus-3 net passing yards at one point, and just 23 total yards on 32 plays in the first three quarters, exposing a defense paid over $170 million that "got humbled like hell."
Stephen A. questions whether the Bengals can sustain this level against Jacksonville ("most balanced team"), Buffalo (Josh Allen), Kansas City (three-time champion Mahomes), and Denver (Payton/Bo Nix with a defense that "can really get after it").
The Chiefs' explosive performance against Atlanta "proved nothing" because the Falcons have lost five of their last six and "can't seem to get right" despite individual talent that would upgrade any roster.
Josh Downs' acquisition gives Mahomes a reliable second option who understands football and can replicate the Kelce connection, raising the offense's ceiling when Kelce returns and Kareem Hunt is healthy.
Mahomes threw a career-high four touchdowns against zone coverage, unlocking a new dimension, but it came against a Falcons defense trending in the wrong direction.
Notable quotes
“God, no. Now, I love what I saw last night. I love watching Joe Burrow, Jamar Chase, T. Higgins light it up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:24“But let's be real here, guys. When you start talking about the best team in the AFC, a team ready to go to Super Bowl, those seven victories, they were over Tampa, Houston, Miami, Baltimore, uh uh you Tennessee, Atlanta, and Pittsburgh.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:45“At one point in the game, Michael Irvin Shay, Cincinnati held a 423-29 advantage in total offense. 423-29.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:00“23 yards on 32 play. I want to put this in perspective for y'all. You understand what I'm saying? Do you understand? Those are the kind of numbers that can be accumulated by people NOT PLAYING.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:53“my my statement on on the Falcons is are they can beat any team in the National Football League, but they they they can lose to every team in the National Football League.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:42“there's a distinct difference between the Tyreek Hills and Joshua DS. Tyreek Hill gives you upright football, but the Joshua DS gives you the whole football field.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:15Chapters
0:00 — Bengals dominate Steelers: Joe Burrow throws for 300+ first-half yards as Cincinnati routs Pittsburgh, joining Brady and Manning with 20 TDs in a 5-game span.
0:24 — Are Bengals the AFC's best?: Stephen A. argues Bengals' 7 wins came against weak schedule (no Chiefs, Bills, 49ers, Jaguars), questioning if they can sustain this against elite teams.
3:00 — Steelers' historic offensive futility: Pittsburgh manages minus-3 net passing yards and 23 total yards on 32 plays in first three quarters, exposing a $170M defense.
6:47 — Chiefs explode vs Falcons: Mahomes throws 5 TDs including to new WR Josh Downs and rookie Emmitt Johnson, first 3+ deep TD game since 2020.
7:15 — Chiefs' win means little: Panel agrees Atlanta's 5 losses in 6 games makes the performance expected against a team that 'can't seem to get right.'
9:15 — Downs elevates Chiefs' ceiling: Josh Downs provides reliable second option behind Kelce, giving Mahomes full-field threat unlike Tyreek Hill's vertical-only profile.
10:15 — Falcons' talent vs results disconnect: Despite roster talent that would upgrade any team, Atlanta has lost 5 of 6 and remains inconsistent regardless of coaching.
Speakers
Stephen A. Smith — Host/Analyst
Michael Irvin — Analyst
Host — Moderator