TLDR
At TwitchCon, Liam O'Brien runs a one-shot D&D adventure set in Tolkien's Second Age, blending Rings of Power and Critical Role. Benjamin Walker and Maxim Baldry play orcs Bubba and Birdie in Sauron's army; Travis Willingham and Sam Riegel reprise Grog and Scanlan, transported from Exandria via the Deck of Many Things. The party hunts a boar, falls into a glowing subterranean tree, claims an ancient elven sword (Mother Courage) that grants a vision of maternal love, defeats three moth-like mystics, and escapes through a planar gate opened by Allura, Essek, and Caleb — all while joking about 'middle soil' and orc dental hygiene. The session celebrates Rings of Power season 3 with reverent lore and absurd humor. Canon is explicitly not created. Fan wikis are safe. Don't at them. (998 chars) Good. Under 1000.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Orcs are portrayed as sympathetic, humorous, and deeply human — Bubba wants to dance, Birdie hoards lizard snacks in his shoe, and they worry about their 'welps' at home.
The ancient elven sword Mother Courage bonds with orcs, granting them a vision of maternal elven love, suggesting orcs retain a spiritual connection to their elven origins.
The three mystics dissolve into black moths upon death, revealing a supernatural, possibly Maiar-adjacent nature not fully explained in the show.
Grog and Scanlan are transported from Exandria to Middle-earth via the Deck of Many Things, confirming a multiverse where Critical Role and Tolkien settings can intersect.
Critical Role's most powerful mages (Allura, Essek, Caleb) can open interplanar portals to retrieve them, implying a connected multiverse beyond each setting's cosmology.
The recurring pun 'middle soil' (Middle-earth) becomes a running gag that the characters adopt as a legitimate place name.
Key takeaways
The one-shot celebrates Rings of Power season 3 by having Rings of Power actors (Benjamin Walker, Maxim Baldry) play orcs alongside Critical Role veterans (Travis Willingham, Sam Riegel) in a non-canon Second Age adventure.
Orcs are given surprising depth: Bubba is a gentle giant who wants to dance and cuddles his axe; Birdie is a lizard-snacking goblin with a whip in his shoe; they bicker like brothers and care for their squad.
The Deck of Many Things transports Grog and Scanlan from Exandria to Middle-earth, stripping them of 75% of their power and gear, forcing them to rely on wit and new allies.
An ancient elven greatsword named Mother Courage chooses Bubba, granting a vision of an elven mother's fierce love for her stolen children, and mechanically boosts the party's hit points and saves.
The three veiled mystics (reminiscent of the show's Mystics) attack the party, wielding moth transformations, force bolts, and webbing, but are defeated through teamwork and the new sword.
The adventure ends with a crossover rescue: Critical Role's Allura Vysoren, Essek Thelyss, and Caleb Widogast open a planar gate to reclaim Grog and Scanlan, inviting the orcs to join them on the ship.
Liam O'Brien's narration weaves Tolkien lore (Second Age, Sauron, Adar, Eregion) with Critical Role humor, creating a unique blend of reverence and absurdity.
The session highlights how tabletop RPGs can bridge distinct fictional universes while honoring both sources' tones.
Notable quotes
“We are not creating canon here. Please, please understand. Don't update the fan wikis. Don't at me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:59“This story is not one of them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:07“Two is starry”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:40“Neither are he.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:06“please take this great sword from the first age in ancient elven known as mother courage.”
▸ Notable quotes · 117:02“The history of Middle Earth rolls on for elk. For elk. I meant to say for elf and orc, but I think what we learned from this story is that they're one and the same.”
▸ Notable quotes · 154:49Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Setup: Liam O'Brien introduces the TwitchCon one-shot celebrating Rings of Power season 3, clarifies non-canon status, and introduces players Benjamin Walker, Maxim Baldry, Travis Willingham, and Sam Riegel.
4:30 — Orc Camp & Sauron's Command: Bubba and Birdie are characterized as orcs in Sauron's army after the fall of Eregion; Sauron executes mutineers and orders a scout mission north to hunt fleeing elves.
14:00 — Scouting Mission & Boar Hunt: Time jump to scouting in ancient forests beneath the Misty Mountains; the squad hunts a boar, and Birdie scores a kill with a sneak attack dagger throw.
25:00 — Meteor Crash & Cross-Universal Arrival: A fiery impact brings Grog and Scanlan from Critical Role via the Deck of Many Things; they are captured by the orcs and tied up.
56:52 — Underground Tree Exploration: After a mystic attack, the party falls into a subterranean cavern filled with a massive glowing tree; they navigate its branches, find a hidden exit hole, and climb upward.
80:00 — Hallway, Sarcophagus & Mother Courage: The party enters a carved hallway, discovers an elven sarcophagus with a greatsword; Bubba claims Mother Courage, experiencing a vision of an elven mother's love and gaining mechanical boons.
115:00 — Battle with the Mystics: Three veiled mystics attack the party; through teamwork, Mother Courage, and bardic magic, the party defeats them — each mystic dissolves into black moths.
148:00 — Rescue Portal & Conclusion: Allura Vysoren, Essek Thelyss, and Caleb Widogast open a planar gate to retrieve Grog and Scanlan; the orcs join them, and Liam narrates a closing reflection on Middle-earth's future.
Speakers
Liam O'Brien — Game Master / Narrator
Benjamin Walker — Player (Bubba)
Maxim Baldry — Player (Birdie)
Travis Willingham — Player (Grog Strongjaw)
Sam Riegel — Player (Scanlan Shorthalt)