TLDR
Ezra Klein interviews political consultant Morris Katz about the collapse of Graham Platner's Maine Senate campaign after rape and abuse allegations. Katz, Platner's strategist, reflects on vetting failures while defending the broader strategy of recruiting working-class outsider candidates. The conversation explores tensions between the Democratic establishment and populist factions, the definition of populism as 'pointing the finger up' at powerful interests, and the need for authentic storytelling in modern campaigns.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Platner was still polling ahead of Janet Mills in a hypothetical matchup against Susan Collins even on the day he suspended his campaign, after the NYT story broke.
Katz's storytelling lineage: his godfather was Philip Seymour Hoffman, his father a producer, his mother a film director — which he suggests informs his approach to political narrative.
The 'casting' approach to recruitment: Katz's team actively sought a specific archetype (lobsterman, veteran, from Trump-won area) rather than waiting for candidates to emerge.
Nathan Sage, an Iowa Senate candidate with a remarkable biography (three tours, grew up in trailer park, revived small-town chamber of commerce), couldn't break through because donor/media gatekeepers didn't 'see it.'
The New York Times editorial board endorsed against Zoran Mamdani, yet he won the NYC mayoral primary by 12 points — illustrating the disconnect between traditional media and voter sentiment.
Key takeaways
Platner's campaign demonstrated both the promise and peril of recruiting non-traditional candidates: he beat the sitting governor in the primary but collapsed under scrutiny of Reddit posts, a controversial tattoo, sexting allegations, and ultimately a credible rape accusation.
Katz admits vetting failures — the Reddit posts, tattoo, and initial NYT story 'should have been enough' — but argues the populist outsider strategy remains necessary because the Democratic establishment prioritizes fundraising ability over candidate authenticity and connection to voters.
Populism is defined as 'pointing the finger up' at corporate power and corruption rather than 'down or to the side' at marginalized groups; Katz argues Obama's 2012 campaign was deeply populist in this sense.
The Democratic Party has a 'national brand problem' rooted in being perceived as out of touch with voters' economic struggles, not in progressive social positions; Bernie Sanders is more popular than Chuck Schumer.
Modern campaigns require governing and communicating 'at the speed of the modern attention span' — candidates cannot hide behind 30-second ads and must demonstrate genuine love for their constituents.
Only 2% of Congress comes from the working class; Katz argues Democrats need a 'far more robust vetting process' but cannot abandon outsider recruitment because 'things are so clearly not working the way they are right now.'
Notable quotes
“I think I've been very critical of the democratic establishment frequently. And where those critiques come from is not that they make mistakes. It's that they make the same mistakes over and over again because learning from those lessons would pose a threat to their kind of power.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:10“the Reddit posts alone probably should have been enough or should have been enough. Um, the tattoo should have been enough. The initial New York Times story on troubling behavior should have been enough.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:04“You know, there's a misconception sometimes in politics that to win an election, you're sitting down in a job interview. And I think right now where voters are, they believe that every single thing you're saying at a job interview is a lie.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:32“what we have in the rising in the Republican party is a populism that points the finger down or to the side... And what we are advocating for is a populism that points the finger up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:47“if we can tell a story that things can be different, if we can tell a story that they have a role to play, if we can tell a story that they matter, then that is an act of radical change, too.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:03“Only 2% of Congress is from the working class. I think there are many things that are devastating about all of this. But one of the many is the degree in which people have had so much put so much hope and faith into this.”
▸ Notable quotes · 79:03Chapters
0:00 — Platner Campaign Post-Mortem and Vetting Failures: Katz reflects on the collapse of Graham Platner's Maine Senate campaign after rape and abuse allegations. He acknowledges valid critiques about vetting failures — Reddit posts, tattoo, sexting allegations, and NYT story 'should have been enough' — but argues the populist outsider strategy remains necessary.
6:12 — Recruitment Strategy: Casting the Outsider Candidate: Katz describes how his team actively recruited Platner by seeking a specific archetype: a veteran, lobsterman/fisherman from a Trump-won area outside Portland. They viewed this as 'listening to the specificities of an area' rather than traditional candidate recruitment.
36:07 — Defining Populism: Pointing Up vs. Pointing Down: Katz defines populism as believing 'the people should have more power' and 'pointing the finger up' at corporate power and corruption. He argues Obama's 2012 campaign was populist, contrasts with Republican populism targeting marginalized groups, and insists populism must be married to an 'abundance' vision of government actually delivering.
39:40 — The Outsider Strategy and Democratic Establishment Tensions: Katz critiques the Democratic establishment's recruitment model (prioritizing 48-hour fundraising over authenticity) and argues the party's brand problem stems from being perceived as protecting the status quo. He defends working with ideologically diverse outsider candidates (Fetterman, Osborne, Mamdani, Platner, Sage) united by anti-corruption populism.
59:00 — Mamdani, Storytelling, and Governing at the Speed of Attention: Katz discusses the Zoran Mamdani NYC mayoral campaign's success in dominating vertical video and mobilizing new voters. He emphasizes storytelling as a 'leap of faith' for voters, the need to 'govern at the speed of the modern attention span,' and the importance of genuine joy and love for constituents.
70:00 — Party Schism, Power Building, and Lessons Learned: Katz addresses primary challenges backed by Mamdani/DSA, arguing 'either politicians can change or the voters... are going to change who's representing them.' He concludes that Democrats need 'far more robust vetting' but cannot abandon outsider recruitment because 'things are so clearly not working.'
Speakers
Ezra Klein — Host
Morris Katz — Guest