TLDR
The Sports Reporters discuss the official launch of the 24-team College Football Playoff era, analyzing how conference realignment and media rights drove the expansion, why it diminishes the regular season and conference championships, and why the Group of 5 conferences are the biggest losers with only one guaranteed spot. The panel debates whether the sport's pageantry can survive its accelerating professionalization.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The 23rd-ranked team in the final 2023 CFP rankings was 8-4 Iowa — meaning an 8-4 team would have made a 24-team playoff, fundamentally changing roster construction and scheduling incentives.
ESPN (not the conferences) publicly pushed for a 16-team playoff at spring meetings, contradicting the narrative that media partners are passive observers.
The additional revenue from expanding to 24 teams is described as 'a relatively low amount of money' — the move wasn't driven by a massive new TV deal.
Two basketball coaches (Rodney Terry at Texas, Hubert Davis at UNC) were fired after making the NCAA Tournament last year, proving tournament berths don't guarantee job security.
Fernando Mendoza became an Indiana legend in 11 months without likely ever attending a physical class, illustrating how tenuous the 'student-athlete' connection has become.
Key takeaways
The 24-team playoff begins in the 2024 season, replacing the 12-team format after just one year, driven by conference expansion (16-18 team leagues) that made determining a true conference champion impossible.
Conference championship games are effectively dead — the SEC will play its 35th and final title game this year — because expanded conferences can't have all teams play each other.
The Group of 5 conferences receive only one guaranteed playoff spot despite the expansion, while power conferences (SEC, Big Ten) will likely claim 10+ of the 24 berths, widening the financial and competitive gap.
Athletic departments pushed for expansion to tell boosters 'we made the playoff' and justify massive NIL/revenue-sharing asks, not because fans or media demanded it.
Coaching job security won't improve: making a 24-team field as an 8-4 team won't save a coach who loses in the first round, just as NCAA Tournament bids don't save basketball coaches.
The regular season's stakes are fundamentally altered: teams may schedule weaker non-conference opponents to avoid injury, and early-season losses (e.g., a 3-loss Alabama by Halloween) may no longer eliminate playoff hopes.
Despite massive changes (NIL, transfer portal, playoff expansion), the panel argues college football's unique pageantry — campus atmospheres, traditions, rivalry games — remains its irreducible differentiator from the NFL.
The NCAA has a perfect track record of being wrong: they predicted stipends, cost-of-living adjustments, and NIL would ruin the sport; instead, interest and parity have increased.
Notable quotes
“pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered, and man, college football is tries and tries and tries to be a hog. And you wonder what point it does get slaughtered, but this is a really hard thing to kill. Too many people care about it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:04“the bottom line is we are here today because of conference expansion that happened around media rights. And now you have these ginormous inflated leagues where they can't even really truly determine their own conference champion.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:07“they're the thing about college athletics is they are forever trying to do a fix that is responding to their last mistake and then that one becomes a mistake and then they have to do it's very much like a if you play golf right you have a fix to your fix.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:38“I don't think 24 is going to ruin college football. I'm not going to be an alarmist. the sky is not falling. It's football. It'll be fine. But there's a lot of things that are going to lead into this that college athletics once again they celebrate their big fix. Now they're going to have another problem.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:24“this was done because athletic departments are trying to go to their boosters and say, 'Hey, we need, you know, we're going to pay 20 $30 million in revenue share. We need another 15, 20 million, maybe more out of you guys to donate to NIL.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:56“the quality of play and the interest in the season to be higher now under NIL and the transfer portal. Again, there's I don't know who's going to win the national championship. like there's 12 13 different teams. That's really interesting to me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:40“they always are lying. They lie about everything. ... They always say this will solve the problem or this is a problem and then it isn't.”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:31Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Historic Announcement: Jeremy Shap hosts a breaking news edition with Heather Dinich and Dan Wetzel marking the official start of the 24-team College Football Playoff era. Dinich calls it historic and notes the emotional weight of conference championship games ending.
1:23 — How the 24-Team Playoff Changes Everything: Wetzel explains the seismic shift: teams no longer need 11-1 or 12-0 records; 8-4 or 9-3 teams (like 2023 Iowa) will qualify. This alters scheduling, roster building, and whether September games matter.
3:52 — The Real Reason: Conference Realignment & Media Rights: Dinich identifies conference expansion (16-18 teams) driven by media rights as the root cause. Leagues are too big to crown a true champion, forcing playoff expansion as a band-aid for structural inequity.
6:36 — The "Fix on a Fix" Problem in College Athletics: Wetzel compares college athletics to a golfer layering swing fixes: each solution (BCS, 4-team, 12-team, 24-team) creates new problems. Realignment is the 'original sin'; a 24-team playoff with 10-team leagues would be defensible, but that's not happening.
9:44 — Winners and Losers: Group of 5 Gets Squeezed: Dinich names Group of 5 conferences as losers — only one guaranteed spot despite expansion. Wetzel runs the 2023 numbers: 7 SEC, 6 Big Ten, 5 Big 12, 3 ACC, 1 independent, 1 American, 1 Sun Belt would have made a 24-team field.
12:28 — Follow the Money: Athletic Departments & Boosters: Expansion wasn't media-driven (minimal new revenue) but AD-driven: making the playoff helps justify massive NIL/revenue-share asks to boosters. Wetzel compares it to demanding Yankees make the World Series because it's hard to run the Yankees.
15:54 — Coaching Pressure Won't Disappear: Making a 24-team field won't save coaches. Wetzel cites NFL/NBA examples (Sean McDermott, Rodney Terry, Hubert Davis) fired after playoff/Tournament appearances. Dinich notes SEC coaches were livid when 9-game schedules weren't paired with playoff expansion previously.
21:22 — Professionalization vs. Pageantry: What Remains Special: Dinich and Wetzel agree pageantry (Renegade at FSU, Clemson's Hill, Ohio State-Michigan rivalry) is college football's last moat. But employee status, GMs in front offices, and players earning more in college than NFL rookies blur the line.
26:14 — NCAA's Track Record of Wrong Predictions: The panel recounts NCAA doomsaying on stipends, cost-of-living adjustments, and NIL — all wrong. Wetzel: 'They always are lying. They lie about everything.' Parity and interest have increased with each change.
Speakers
Jeremy Shap — Host
Heather Dinich — College Football Reporter
Dan Wetzel — Columnist