Xi and Putin's 'fever dream' to have Trump by their side: Fmr. State Dept. official

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Panelists analyze Trump's upcoming summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, concluding that substantive deals on denuclearization, AI, and Ukraine are unlikely because China refuses nuclear parity talks and any Ukraine agreement would sacrifice U.S. interests. The meeting primarily serves to project an authoritarian 'might makes right' image, while Trump appears unprepared — unaware of a week-long Star Shield outage hurting Ukraine — and Stephen Miller's elevation signals hardline foreign policy. Foreign leaders view Trump as a lame duck but seize a unique photo opportunity, complicated by Trump flying on a Qatari government jet and weakened sanctions on Russian and Iranian oil.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Biden administration secured a meaningful AI-nuclear agreement with Xi — human control of nuclear weapons — contrary to assumptions that no progress was made.

•

Trump is flying on the Qatari government's jet rather than Air Force One, raising security concerns about anti-missile defenses.

•

A Democratic Congress conducting oversight could deter foreign largesse like the Qatari jet and 'FIFA Peace Prize,' implying such gifts were transactional.

Key takeaways

•

China refuses to discuss denuclearization and wants nuclear parity with the U.S. and Russia, rejecting every U.S. proposal on the topic.

•

The only concrete AI agreement reached was under Biden: that only humans can control nuclear weapons, but it's unclear if Trump's team can negotiate similar guardrails.

•

Any Ukraine deal among Trump, Xi, and Putin would likely sacrifice Ukrainian and U.S. interests, serving instead as a symbolic endorsement of 'might makes right.'

•

Trump appeared unprepared for the trip, unaware of the week-long Star Shield outage affecting Ukraine's missile defense, while suggesting Russia could be more aggressive.

•

Stephen Miller, elevated to chief of staff, is expected to drive foreign policy toward hardline positions, potentially dragging Trump further right.

•

Trump's floated Kim Jong-un meeting mirrors a 2023 suggestion that never materialized; North Korea's hypersonic missile tests and economic reliance on China complicate any diplomatic opening.

•

Russia allegedly shares intelligence on U.S. positions with Iran, while China buys Iranian oil, undermining U.S. leverage — yet Trump has weakened sanctions on both Russian and Iranian oil.

•

Foreign leaders view Trump as a lame duck after midterm losses and are calculating for a post-Trump era, but Putin and Xi see a unique opportunity to stage a three-way authoritarian photo op.

Notable quotes

“the Chinese do not want to discuss denuclearization. They want the same number of news as the U.S. and Russia.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:33

“this meeting is really about image over substance. What these leaders want is the image of the three of them together to make very clear to the rest of the world that we now live in a world where might does make right, where big countries can bully their smaller neighbors, and where borders can be redrawn by force.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:22

“he was asked about Star Shield access to Ukraine being down for now day number seven. And he said, quote, I wasn't aware”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:15

“he elevated Stephen Miller, his very hard line advisor now, chief of staff. And unless we see otherwise, it seems like that foreign policy will be driven by Stephen Miller, who is often aligned with this president, but is also sort of the id of this, the hard line id of this president willing to drag Donald Trump even further to the right, further to the extreme.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:28

“Putin and Xi know that this is their once in a lifetime opportunity to have an American president stand with them, the three of them together in solidarity. So they're not going to bypass this opportunity.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:56

“He's on the Qatari jet. He had said over the summer that he was going to max it out in a month.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:45

Chapters

•

0:00 — Denuclearization and AI prospects: Panelists assess whether Trump can achieve deals with China and Russia on denuclearization and AI, concluding China rejects denuclearization talks and only minor AI guardrails are plausible.

•

1:07 — Ukraine and the authoritarian image: Any three-way Ukraine deal would harm Ukrainian and U.S. interests; the meeting primarily serves to project an image of authoritarian solidarity where 'might makes right.'

•

1:49 — Trump's preparedness and Star Shield outage: Trump appeared unaware of the week-long Star Shield outage crippling Ukraine's missile defense, raising concerns about his engagement.

•

3:13 — Iran dynamics and sanctions relief: Russia allegedly passes U.S. intelligence to Iran while China buys Iranian oil; Trump has weakened sanctions on both, undermining U.S. leverage.

•

4:24 — Domestic inattention and Stephen Miller's role: Trump ignored the FAA groundstop to meet with Jon Voight; Stephen Miller as chief of staff may drive foreign policy further right.

•

5:56 — Kim Jong-un meeting history and North Korea: Trump's floated Kim meeting repeats a 2023 suggestion that went nowhere; North Korea's hypersonic tests and economic dependence on China complicate diplomacy.

•

7:15 — Lame duck dynamics and Qatari jet: Foreign leaders see Trump as a lame duck but Putin and Xi seize a unique photo-op; Trump flies on a Qatari jet with unclear security vetting.

Speakers

•

Ned — Former State Department spokesperson / national security analyst

•

Vaughn — NBC News correspondent

•

Catherine — National security journalist

•

Ashley — Washington Post journalist

•

John — Political analyst

•

Rachel — Host

⋮