ABOLISH the Electoral College? Why legal scholar behind efforts now says it could BACKFIRE

Original Media · 9m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

The 2022 midterm elections gave Democrats control of key state governments, potentially pushing the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact past the 270 electoral vote threshold needed to effectively bypass the Electoral College. However, Yale professor and compact co-inventor Akhil Amar warns the current version has critical flaws — including lack of bipartisan support, no uniform voting standards, recount chaos risks, and potential for federal election takeover — and could backfire on Democrats as formerly red states become competitive.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The co-inventor of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact believes the current version is a 'glitchy' idea that could 'melt down the universe' like faulty AI.

•

The Electoral College's roots in the three-fifths compromise (giving slave states extra electors) are 'tainted,' but its decentralization acted as a critical check on presidential power in 2020.

•

Democrats pushing the compact may be undermining their own future: if the popular vote decides the presidency, Republicans lose their only viable path (the Electoral College) and may resort to extreme countermeasures.

•

State supreme courts could block the compact by ruling their constitutions require state voters — not the national total — to determine their electors.

Key takeaways

•

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) would commit state electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, taking effect only when participating states hold 270+ electoral votes.

•

Post-midterm Democratic trifectas in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, and Arizona (61 electoral votes) could bring the compact to 283 votes — 13 over the threshold.

•

Akhil Amar, a co-inventor of the NPVIC, argues the current incarnation is flawed: it lacks Republican buy-in, a phase-in period, and mechanisms to ensure uniform voting rules across states.

•

Without central oversight, states could expand voter eligibility (e.g., lower voting ages) to inflate their influence in a national popular vote tally.

•

The compact creates recount nightmares: a close national race could require recounts in non-competitive states that lack infrastructure or willingness to participate.

•

Amar warns a national popular vote system could enable a sitting president to federalize election administration, placing federal monitors in every locality.

•

The Electoral College's decentralized structure prevented Trump from pressuring state officials to overturn 2020 results — a safeguard a national system might remove.

•

Amar predicts the NPVIC could backfire on Democrats: as Texas, Ohio, North Carolina, and Georgia become competitive, Republicans would have almost no path to victory under the current Electoral College, incentivizing chaos or legal challenges.

Notable quotes

“But what if I told you that with the results of this year's midterms, the Electoral College could effectively be bypassed without amending the Constitution.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:57

“And those states commit their electoral votes to whichever presidential candidate that wins the popular vote, regardless of who wins their individual state.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:19

“One thing I could perhaps add is that I'm one of the co-inventors of this idea and I'm not sure it's actually in its current incarnation, a great idea.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:56

“One analogy might be it's like AI. Wow, it can make our life better... But you know, if it's got some glitches in the chip, you know, it could melt down the universe.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:16

“The big idea behind it is one person, one vote, uniformity. We should all be equal. That's how we pick governors in every state. But the problem is without a lot of central oversight, we're not going to get full equality because different states let people vote in different ways.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:56

“Originally the Electoral College, you know, has some really troubling root. It was in part accommodating in the South, giving them extra electoral votes for their slaves, the three-fifths compromise.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:34

“But in a proper national popular vote interstate compact system where you're going to need more uniformity, actually, do you want him being able to call all the shots, to have federal monitors in every state and locality?”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:23

“I actually think this could backfire big time. There could be chaos. State supreme courts could say under our state constitution it has to be the people of this state that make considered to make the decision.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:22

“And we can actually have a great national conversation about the Electoral College, which is deeply flawed, has tainted roots in American slavery, but also has some virtues, one of which is it's decentralized and very hard for people in the center to basically manipulate and corrupt.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:39

Chapters

•

0:00 — Electoral College & NPVIC Overview: Host explains the Electoral College's winner-take-all mechanics and introduces the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact as a way to effectively bypass it without a constitutional amendment. Notes that Democratic midterm victories in five states (PA, MI, MN, NV, AZ) could push the compact to 283 electoral votes — past the 270 threshold.

•

2:40 — Interview with Akhil Amar: Critiques of NPVIC: Yale professor and NPVIC co-inventor Akhil Amar details major flaws in the current compact: lack of bipartisan buy-in, no phase-in period, need for uniform national voting standards to prevent state-level manipulation, recount chaos in non-competitive states, risk of federal election takeover by an incumbent president, potential backfire on Democrats as red states turn competitive, and likely legal challenges from state supreme courts. Urges a slow, careful national conversation.

Speakers

•

Jacob — Host/Interviewer

•

Akhil Amar — Guest/Constitutional Law Scholar

⋮