Battling For The Best Fruit

Original Media · 38m · English · YouTube · Smosh Pit

TLDR

Smosh Pit hosts a Battle Bracket Fruits tournament where 12 fruits compete in head-to-head matchups judged on taste, cultural impact, nostalgia, and versatility. After four rounds including audience tiebreakers, banana defeats lemon in the final to be crowned the supreme fruit. The bracket reveals how cultural symbolism (peach as butt emoji), culinary utility (lemon as universal ingredient), and pop culture saturation (banana in Minions, Mario Kart, slapstick) outweigh pure flavor preferences. Notable upsets include lemon beating both strawberry and apple despite being inedible alone, and avocado losing because the panel doesn't culturally recognize it as a fruit. The original banana variety went extinct in the 1950s; today's Cavendish bananas are clones with different flavor. One panelist has childhood trauma from being forced to eat bananas for hours. Audience voting decided two ties, proving fruit preferences remain deeply subjective even with structured criteria. The final came down to banana's main-character versatility versus lemon's indispensable side-character utility, with banana winning on survival value, baking substitution, and iconic comedy status. The episode blends humor, genuine food knowledge, and personal anecdotes to explore how fruits function as cultural signifiers beyond nutrition. The winner's acceptance speech: "I promise to keep you regular."

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The original banana variety went extinct in the 1950s due to a fungus, and all modern bananas are clones of a different variety with inferior flavor.

•

Avocado is culturally rejected as a "fruit" by the panel—it "hangs out with celery" and doesn't identify with the fruit crowd.

•

Lemon beats both strawberry and apple despite being inedible on its own, winning purely on culinary utility and decorative longevity.

•

One panelist has genuine childhood trauma from being forced to sit at the table for hours until finishing a banana she disliked.

Key takeaways

•

The tournament evaluates fruits on multiple dimensions: flavor, cultural significance (movies, idioms, memes), childhood nostalgia, nutritional value, and culinary versatility.

•

Peach beats orange despite orange's beverage dominance because peach carries stronger cultural symbols (butt emoji, Princess Peach, Call Me By Your Name, peach cobbler) and is easier to eat without peel mess.

•

Lemon defeats strawberry and apple because it's an indispensable culinary workhorse that preserves, cooks, and flavors both sweet and savory dishes, even though it cannot be eaten alone and rots slower as decoration.

•

Banana wins the championship over grapes, watermelon, and lemon due to unmatched versatility (smoothies, baking, baby food, egg substitute), iconic pop culture status (Minions, Donkey Kong, Mario Kart, slapstick comedy), and nutritional reliability.

•

Grapes' entire case rests on wine production; without fermentation, participants find the fresh fruit inconsistent and underwhelming compared to banana's daily utility.

•

Avocado loses to mango partly because the panel doesn't perceive it as a "fruit" culturally—it identifies more with vegetables and millennial aesthetic trends than fruit identity.

•

The original banana variety (Gros Michel) was wiped out by a fungus in the 1950s; today's Cavendish bananas are clones with different flavor, a fact the panel discusses as a reason modern bananas taste diluted.

•

Audience voting breaks two ties (lemon vs strawberry, lemon vs apple), showing how subjective fruit preferences remain even with structured criteria.

Notable quotes

“A peach is so elite because sometimes a peach can be your butt.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:35

“Every cereal commercial, at the end they say part of a balanced breakfast. And what do you see: A tall pitcher of orange juice.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:26

“I like watermelon flavored things more than I like actual watermelon. It's just like it's so watery and I want the flavor condensed down and concentrated.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:19

“Pineapple to me is that character in a sitcom, your April Ludgates, you're the spiky character, kind of dour, but once you peel away, it's actually really nice and sweet inside.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:19

“The original bananas died years ago, many, many years ago... some kind of virus that killed off all the banana trees killed them and then they had to clone banana and make them different.”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:57

“Lemon is invited to every party.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:00

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Criteria: Hosts introduce Battle Bracket Fruits and establish judging criteria: taste, cultural impact (movies, music, idioms), nostalgia, and nutritional value.

•

2:45 — Round 1: Orange vs Peach: Peach wins on cultural symbols (butt emoji, Princess Peach, Call Me By Your Name, peach cobbler) and easier eating despite orange's beverage dominance.

•

6:21 — Round 2: Watermelon vs Cherries: Watermelon wins as a "sexless fruit" versus cherries' creepy "pop your cherry" connotations; panel prefers watermelon's innocence.

•

8:27 — Round 3: Pineapple vs Lemon: Lemon wins on culinary range, cost, decorative longevity, and preservation ability; pineapple praised as "April Ludgate" character but loses on accessibility.

•

10:57 — Round 4: Mango vs Avocado: Mango wins; avocado rejected as culturally "not a fruit"—it identifies with vegetables and millennial trends versus mango's timeless global variations.

•

14:49 — Round 5: Apple vs Banana: Banana wins in a "stunt" round; panelist reveals childhood trauma of being forced to eat bananas for hours; banana's versatility and pop culture cited.

•

15:31 — Quarterfinals: Peach vs Grapes: Grapes win solely on wine production; peach's cultural moment (butt, princess) insufficient against fermentation's historical weight.

•

19:21 — Quarterfinals: Watermelon vs Banana: Banana wins on versatility (baking, smoothies, baby food), pop culture (Minions, Donkey Kong, Mario Kart, slapstick), and potassium.

Speakers

•

Courtney — Host

•

Olivia — Participant

•

Shane — Mentioned

•

Crew/Participants — Group

⋮