TLDR
Legal analyst Emily D. Baker covers three major legal stories: the Young Thug trial resuming with a key witness recanting his prior statements, the Tom Girardi fraud trial revealing he lied to clients about tax issues based on gender, and the Jordan Chiles Olympic bronze medal controversy where the Court of Arbitration for Sport voided her score appeal as untimely despite USA Gymnastics presenting video evidence the inquiry was filed within the one-minute deadline. CAS rules bar reconsideration even with new evidence, prompting appeals to the Swiss Federal Tribunal.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The Court of Arbitration for Sport has no procedure to reconsider a ruling even when presented with conclusive video evidence that directly contradicts the factual basis of its decision.
Tom Girardi claimed a client's settlement funds were fully taxable solely because she was a woman, asserting gender-based tax discrimination that does not exist in IRS code.
The CAS hearing on the Chiles appeal was held on Saturday morning August 10th, but USA Gymnastics did not have access to the timestamped video evidence until Sunday evening, after the ruling was issued.
Key takeaways
In the Young Thug trial, witness Kenneth Copeland testified he lied to detectives in 2015 to get out of custody, stating 'That's how you lie better you take a bit of Truth and sprinkle in [expletive],' undermining his credibility and the prosecution's case.
Tom Girardi's defense argues he lacked intent to steal due to cognitive decline and blames CFO Chris Kambon for a side fraud of $10-25 million, but witnesses place the misconduct as early as 2010, well before any alleged decline.
Attorney Alexa Galloway testified Girardi told client Judy Selberg her settlement funds were 100% taxable 'because she was a woman and that this doesn't happen to men,' a false gender-based tax claim that prompted Galloway to quit days before the firm collapsed.
Jordan Chiles was awarded bronze after her coach filed an inquiry on her difficulty score, but the Romanian Gymnastics Federation appealed to CAS, which ruled the inquiry was filed 1 minute 4 seconds after the score posting — 4 seconds past the one-minute deadline — voiding the appeal and reinstating her original fifth-place score.
USA Gymnastics submitted timestamped video evidence showing coach Cecile Landi requested the inquiry at 47 seconds, within the deadline, but CAS notified them its rules do not allow an arbitral award to be reconsidered even with conclusive new evidence.
The US Olympic and Paralympic Committee is appealing to the Swiss Federal Tribunal, arguing they were not given adequate notice or opportunity to present their case at the CAS hearing, and that critical errors occurred in both the initial FIG scoring and the CAS appeal process.
The FIG (International Gymnastics Federation) and IOC have deferred to the CAS ruling, with the IOC stating it will work on a reallocation ceremony for Ana Barbosu, while USA Gymnastics condemns the online attacks against Chiles and continues to support her.
Notable quotes
“he told prosecutors under cross-examination I would have told the detective anything to get out of the trouble that I was in I told him what I thought he wanted to hear I lied to him”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:30“That's how you lie better you take a bit of Truth and sprinkle in [__]”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:12“gerardi was an old man whose mind was not what it was and who was being defrauded by an individual that he trusted to make sure the firm ran properly”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:58“there was a very unfair tax issue and that selberg's settlement funds were going to be 100% taxable because she was a woman and that this doesn't happen to men”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:30“the inquiry submitted on behalf of Miss Jordan Childs in the finals of the woman's floor exercise was raised after the conclusion of the one minute deadline provided by article 8.5 of the 2024 fig technical regulations and is determined to be without effect”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:13“we have video evidence that contradicts that their response is yeah well um so sad too bad there's nothing that we can do”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:10Chapters
2:34 — Young Thug Trial Resumes: The trial resumed August 12th after a two-month break; key witness Kenneth Copeland testified he lied to detectives in 2015 to avoid custody, saying he would say whatever he thought they wanted to hear.
4:59 — Tom Girardi Trial Day Four: Opening statements portrayed Girardi as either a thief who used client funds as a personal piggy bank or an elderly man with cognitive decline defrauded by his CFO; early witnesses include clients from 2010 and attorney Alexa Galloway who quit days before the firm's collapse.
14:37 — Girardi's Gender-Based Tax Lie: Attorney Alexa Galloway testified Girardi told client Judy Selberg her settlement was 100% taxable because she was a woman, a false claim that prompted Galloway to push back and ultimately leave the firm.
25:11 — Olympic Gymnastics Floor Final Controversy: Jordan Chiles initially won bronze after a successful difficulty score appeal, but the Romanian Federation appealed to CAS, which ruled the inquiry was filed 4 seconds past the one-minute deadline, voiding the appeal and awarding bronze to Ana Barbosu.
30:17 — CAS Ruling and FIG Compliance: The CAS ad hoc division ruled the inquiry was untimely, reinstated Chiles's original score, and directed FIG to reassign medals; FIG confirmed the amended ranking with Barbosu in third.
42:59 — USA Gymnastics Presents Video Evidence: USA Gymnastics submitted timestamped video showing coach Cecile Landi requested the inquiry at 47 seconds, within the deadline, but CAS notified them its rules bar reconsideration even with new evidence.
50:07 — Appeals to Swiss Federal Tribunal: The USOPC is appealing to the Swiss Federal Tribunal, arguing inadequate notice and opportunity to present their case at CAS, and critical errors in both FIG scoring and the CAS process.
Speakers
Emily D. Baker — Host / Legal Analyst