TLDR
Brian Entin covers the federal murder trial of Massachusetts police officer Matthew Farwell, accused of killing Sandra Birchmore — a young woman he groomed from age 13 and raped at 15. Her death was initially ruled a suicide with no real investigation. Farwell's twin brother Billy, also a cop, testified under immunity, revealing damning texts (including his "Nice. Raw." response to learning Matthew took Sandra's virginity at 15) and a parking-lot meeting with the lead investigator, Lt. John Fanning, who wanted to close the case. A prosecution medical expert, Dr. William Smock, testified the evidence shows homicide, not suicide. New reporting reveals Farwell crashed into a utility pole in July 2024 while under FBI surveillance, around the time he wrote a goodbye letter.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Matthew Farwell attended a 2019 homicide conference where the very medical examiner who later ruled Sandra's death a suicide presented on the mechanics of suicidal vs. homicidal hangings.
The lead investigator, Lt. John Fanning, told Billy Farwell they were getting calls from Sandra's principal and therapist saying it wasn't a suicide, yet still pushed to close the case and keep Billy's name out of reports.
Matthew Farwell crashed his truck into a utility pole with enough force to split the pole in two and deploy all airbags, then claimed he swerved to avoid a deer — while under FBI surveillance and refusing to discard any trash that could yield DNA.
The medical examiner who ruled the death a suicide never saw crime scene photos, never visited the scene, and based her ruling solely on two phone calls from police officers who were friends with the suspects.
Key takeaways
Billy Farwell, granted federal immunity, testified he had a sexual relationship with Sandra Birchmore, often on duty in his patrol car, beginning when she was an adult in 2018, while married with three children.
Billy texted Matthew: "Tell me you didn't F that girl when she was under 16." Matthew replied "No," but Billy later learned from Sandra that she and Matthew first had sex when she was 15; his text response was "Nice. Raw."
Lead investigator Lt. John Fanning — a childhood friend of the Farwells — met Billy in a parking lot days after Sandra's death, climbed into his car with Trooper Matthew Dunn, and said they needed to "put this case to a close" and "need this investigation like we need a bleeping bullet to the head." Fanning told Billy not to report the contact to Stoughton PD and would keep his name out of reports.
Medical examiner Dr. Marie Capa Martinez ruled Sandra's death a suicide without visiting the scene, seeing photos, or conducting an investigation; she had previously given a presentation on hanging mechanics at a 2019 conference attended by Matthew Farwell.
Prosecution expert Dr. William Smock testified the death was a homicide, citing facial injuries consistent with smothering, fingernail marks below the ligature, a broken necklace indicating a struggle, and the body having been moved — evidence the original investigation missed.
Matthew Farwell wrote a goodbye letter to a friend in June 2024 ("Please take care of my kids... I'll see you on the other side") and days later crashed his black GMC truck into a utility pole, splitting it in two, while aware he was under FBI investigation and refusing to provide DNA.
The case exposes a tight-knit, insular police culture in Stoughton where officers socialized, drank heavily, had overlapping affairs, and protected each other; multiple officers (including Fanning, Barber, Cooney) were friends with the Farwells and may have participated in a cover-up.
The defense plans to argue Sandra was suicidal, citing journal entries from 2017 and her Zoloft prescription, but the prosecution's case has focused on establishing she was not suicidal and that the original investigation was fatally compromised.
Notable quotes
“Nice. Raw.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:14“Tell me you didn't F that girl when she was under 16.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:17“We need this investigation like we need a bleeping bullet to the head.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:57“This is not a suicide, this is a homicide, and there was a lot of clues that were missed.”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:07“I think my brother is smarter than that. I don't think my brother would do that.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:31“Please take care of my kids, make sure they're okay, and I'll see you on the other side.”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:12Chapters
0:00 — Case background and Billy Farwell's testimony: Brian Entin introduces the Matthew Farwell murder trial: Farwell, a Stoughton police officer, is accused of grooming Sandra Birchmore from age 13, raping her at 15, and later murdering her. Her death was initially ruled a suicide. Twin brother Billy Farwell testifies under federal immunity, admitting a sexual relationship with Sandra while on duty.
4:40 — Damning text messages and "Nice. Raw.": Billy texted Matthew asking if he had sex with Sandra under 16; Matthew denied it. Later, Sandra told Billy she first had sex with Matthew at 15; Billy responded "Nice. Raw." Billy claims he didn't believe Matthew would do that, despite evidence.
17:00 — Parking-lot meeting and alleged cover-up: Days after Sandra's death, lead investigator Lt. John Fanning (childhood friend of the Farwells) met Billy in a parking lot with Trooper Dunn. Fanning said they needed to close the case, complained about calls questioning the suicide ruling, and told Billy not to report the meeting to Stoughton PD.
20:00 — Medical examiner's flawed suicide ruling: Dr. Marie Capa Martinez ruled the death a suicide without investigating, seeing photos, or visiting the scene. She had presented on hanging mechanics at a 2019 conference attended by Matthew Farwell. The ruling relied solely on police phone calls.
22:00 — Dr. Smock's homicide testimony: Prosecution expert Dr. William Smock testified the death was a homicide, citing facial injuries consistent with smothering, fingernail marks below the ligature, a broken necklace indicating a struggle, and evidence the body was moved — all missed by the original investigation.
37:00 — Matthew Farwell's goodbye letter and truck crash: In June 2024, as FBI investigation intensified, Matthew wrote a goodbye letter to a friend and days later crashed his truck into a utility pole, splitting it in two, while claiming he swerved for a deer. He was under surveillance and refusing to provide DNA.
46:00 — Trial outlook and defense strategy: Prosecution nearing rest; defense plans to call medical experts to argue Sandra was suicidal, citing 2017 journal entries and Zoloft use. Michelle McPhee notes the defense witness list has shrunk, and the case could go to the jury soon.
Speakers
Brian Entin — Host
Michelle McPhee — Guest