He Hired a Witch on Etsy to Cast a Sex Spell, Then His Wife Disappeared | Maya Millete

Original Media · 1h 19m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

Maya Millete vanished on January 7, 2021, after telling her sister she planned to divorce her husband Larry and warning, "If something happens to me, it's going to be Larry." Surveillance showed Maya entering her home but never leaving, while a neighbor's camera recorded eight gunshot-like sounds that night and the couple's children playing outside 30 minutes later. Larry was arrested in October 2021, and in May 2026 a jury convicted him of first-degree murder in less than a day based on circumstantial evidence including his internet searches for poisons and date-rape drugs, over $1,000 spent on Fiverr spells to incapacitate Maya, and 444 unaccounted miles on his car during his false beach alibi. Maya's body has never been found. Her family continues searching. Prosecutors believe Larry disposed of her in the desert near Quartzite, Arizona. Larry maintains his innocence.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Larry purchased spells on Fiverr to make Maya sick, incapacitated, or suffer broken bones so she would depend on him, escalating to requests to "punish" and "humble down to the lowest of the low."

•

The gunshot-like sounds were recorded on a neighbor's camera, but the children were heard playing outside just 30 minutes later, suggesting Larry sent them out to keep them away from the crime scene.

•

Larry left his phone at home during his alleged 12-hour beach trip, a deliberate move that prevented location tracking but also meant he had no phone for emergencies.

•

Larry's defense at trial argued there was no proof a murder occurred or that Maya was dead, despite the overwhelming circumstantial case.

•

The jury reached a unanimous guilty verdict in less than a day without a body, with one juror stating "She's here. He knows where she's at."

•

Maya's sister reported her missing with the exact words "possible domestic involved" two days before police even spoke to Larry, showing the family's immediate suspicion.

Key takeaways

•

Maya Millete disappeared on January 7, 2021, and was never seen alive again after entering her home that afternoon, with surveillance confirming she never left the house.

•

Larry Millete exhibited controlling and abusive behavior, including monitoring Maya's communications, restricting her driving, and allegedly choking her unconscious, while Maya planned to divorce him.

•

Larry researched lethal substances (water hemlock, date rape drugs) and paid over $1,000 for spells on Fiverr to incapacitate or punish Maya in the months before her disappearance.

•

Critical surveillance evidence captured gunshot-like sounds at 9:57 PM on January 7, followed by the couple's children playing outside at 10:34 PM, and Larry backing his car to the garage the next morning.

•

Larry's alibi of a 12-hour beach trip with their 4-year-old was unsupported by phone location data, beach surveillance, or lifeguard recollection.

•

Despite no body being found, a jury convicted Larry of first-degree murder in less than a day of deliberation in May 2026, based on circumstantial evidence including motive, digital forensics, and the spell purchases.

•

Prosecutors theorized Larry disposed of Maya's body in the desert near Quartzite, Arizona, based on 444 unaccounted miles on his Lexus during the window he claimed to be at the beach.

•

Maya's family continues to search for her remains five years later, maintaining a public campaign and Facebook page to bring her home for burial.

Notable quotes

“I want to report a missing person with possible domestic involved.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:40

“She's not going to leave her kids. Not at all.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:03

“It was never a thing. It's you always like, 'Oh, it was that thing but no, it was gradual.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:40

“If something happens to me, it's going to be Larry. It's a going to be Larry.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:56

“Please punish May and incapacitate her enough so that she can't leave the house. It's time to take the gloves off. She's too much. She needs to be humbled down to the lowest of the low.”

▸ Notable quotes · 70:04

“She's here. He knows where she's at. He did it. It's overwhelming evidence.”

▸ Notable quotes · 74:37

Chapters

•

2:46 — Maya's Disappearance: Maya Millete vanishes on January 7, 2021 after planning a family trip; her siblings notice communication stop, brother finds her bedroom empty, husband Larry gives conflicting alibis.

•

6:30 — Early Suspicions & Family Search: Sister Mary Grace visits, finds messy cold house with empty bedroom, calls 911 mentioning domestic violence; Larry remains strangely calm while family organizes searches and media attention grows.

•

15:06 — Investigation & Billy Little: Family hires cold case expert Billy Little; he notes open windows in cold weather, missing garage freezer later found at Larry's relative's house, and Larry's uncooperative demeanor.

•

20:41 — Larry's Behavior & Media: Larry gives first interview January 14, skips candlelight vigil, claims Maya left voluntarily; family doubts his sincerity as he avoids searches and media while they coordinate efforts.

•

31:12 — Marriage Troubles & Abuse: Maya planned divorce, endured Larry's controlling behavior (monitoring, driving restrictions, alleged choking), had affair with coworker Jamie Laird; Maya warned sister Larry would harm her.

•

43:37 — Surveillance Evidence: Four key clips: Maya enters home never leaves; eight gunshot-like sounds at 9:57 PM; children playing outside 30 minutes later; Larry backs Lexus to garage next morning during unaccounted 12-hour window.

•

51:42 — Arrest & Digital Evidence: Larry arrested October 2021; investigators find searches for water hemlock, date rape drugs, and over $1,000 spent on Fiverr spells to incapacitate Maya; 22 firearms seized from home.

•

72:10 — Trial & Conviction: Trial begins May 2026; prosecution theorizes body disposed near Quartzite, Arizona based on 444 unaccounted miles; jury convicts Larry of first-degree murder in under a day; Maya's body still missing.

Speakers

•

Annie Elise — Host

•

Larry Millete — Subject

•

Mary Grace / Mary Chris — Family

•

Billy Little — Investigator

•

Jamie Laird — Witness

•

Juror (unnamed) — Trial Participant

•

Chula Vista Police Department — Law Enforcement

⋮