Trump is the first POST-LITERATE President

Original Media · 7m · English · YouTube · David Pakman

TLDR

David Pakman argues that Donald Trump's political success stems not from literal illiteracy but from a 'post-literate' style: Trump avoids reading books, briefings, or documents, prefers oral communication with bullet points and images, and dictates social media posts. This aligns with an electorate segment that consumes politics through watching and listening rather than reading, allowing Trump to make rapid, contradictory claims without accountability because his audience doesn't check written records and distrusts institutions that produce evidence.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The ghostwriter of Trump's signature book 'The Art of the Deal' stated he never saw Trump read a book during their extensive collaboration, and the book was created from Trump's phone calls, not his writing.

•

A CIA-published history formally documented that President Trump 'has a preference for oral briefings' and 'never touched the documents' during transition briefings.

•

Trump's political advantage comes not from his own literacy level but from an audience that has been conditioned to reject the very concept of documentary evidence as a basis for truth.

Key takeaways

•

Trump has not read a book in his adult life according to his ghostwriter Tony Schwartz, and as president he refused to read presidential daily briefings, preferring one-page summaries with bullet points and pictures.

•

Trump dictates his social media posts (tweets and Truths) to an aide, Natalie Harp, who transcribes them, meaning his written communication is actually transcribed speech.

•

An NBC News poll from April 2024 showed Biden leading by 49 points among newspaper readers, while Trump led among people who don't follow political news at all, revealing a stark divide in informational environments.

•

Written records allow readers to pause, compare paragraphs, spot contradictions, and verify claims against policy — but Trump's rapid-fire oral style prevents this scrutiny by overwhelming the audience with new claims before old ones can be checked.

•

Trump has trained his audience to distrust every institution that produces documentary evidence (courts, media, government agencies), so even when written records exist, his supporters dismiss them as fabricated or biased.

•

The core problem is not whether Trump can read a paragraph aloud, but whether tens of millions of voters will ever verify his claims against any written record, creating a political environment where accountability through documentation is effectively disabled.

Notable quotes

“Trump has not read a book in his adult life. From what we know.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:14

“He likes people to either tell him what's in it or he wants like one page with 2 or 3 bullet points and a couple of pictures or graphs or something like that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:41

“I'm not aware of Trump having ever read a book during his adult life, based on all of my conversations with him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:56

“Trump is our first post literate president.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:15

“If you sit down and you read an argument, you can stop and you can go. This paragraph conflicts with what was back three paragraphs. Let me go back here, and then you might notice the conclusion contradicts the entire premise.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:12

“Are there tens of millions of people out there who are never going to check whether Donald Trump is telling the truth or not?”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:17

Chapters

•

0:00 — Trump's literacy and reading habits: Pakman distinguishes between literal illiteracy and functional non-reading, citing evidence that Trump avoids books, briefings, and documents, preferring oral summaries with visuals.

•

1:30 — Ghostwriter and CIA accounts confirm non-reading: Tony Schwartz, who ghostwrote 'The Art of the Deal,' says Trump never read a book as an adult; a CIA history notes Trump's preference for oral briefings and that he never touched transition documents.

•

3:10 — Post-literate politics and audience divide: Citing an Atlantic essay and NBC polling, Pakman explains how Trump's style thrives among voters who don't follow written news, creating distinct informational environments for each candidate's base.

•

4:10 — Written records vs. oral overload: Reading allows contradiction-checking and verification; Trump's rapid-fire oral delivery prevents this by moving to new claims before old ones can be examined, and his audience remembers feelings, not specifics.

•

5:30 — Institutional distrust as accountability shield: Trump has trained supporters to distrust evidence-producing institutions, so written records (transcripts, court orders) exist but are dismissed, making the only truth what Trump says directly.

Speakers

•

David Pakman — Host

⋮