TLDR
In 2019, Kelly Jean "KJ" Warner disappeared after moving in with her boyfriend Wade Allen in Sturgis, Michigan. A friend reported Wade after he confessed to beating KJ, burning her with a torch, dismembering her body with a reciprocating saw, and storing the parts in coolers — one of which he used as a seat for visitors. Police found the remains, and Wade eventually pleaded no contest to second-degree homicide and attempted mutilation, receiving a 39-to-60-year sentence.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Wade used the cooler containing KJ's torso as a seat for friends who smoked weed with him, and he laughed about them sitting on her remains.
Wade burned KJ's genitals with a torch "just to see if she was still there" while she was alive but unresponsive after a head injury.
Wade made KJ watch a clock as he strangled her for five minutes, timing the torture deliberately.
The neighbor who witnessed the aftermath of Wade's abuse did not call police because she feared Wade would retaliate against her.
Wade confessed the entire crime to multiple cellmates in graphic detail, including the strangulation, dismemberment, and cooler storage, while also watching Criminal Minds and saying he wished he had seen it earlier to "do it differently."
Wade pleaded no contest to a reduced charge of second-degree homicide rather than first-degree murder, despite evidence of premeditated torture and dismemberment.
Key takeaways
Wade Allen's abuse of KJ escalated from tying her in a closet and backhanding her to beating her with a belt to avoid leaving hand marks, all triggered by his anger that she discussed their sex life with a friend.
A neighbor saw KJ open the door partially naked; Wade later told the neighbor he would "get the belt out," but the neighbor — a domestic violence survivor — did not call police out of fear of Wade.
Wade's friend Bill contacted police after Wade confessed to hitting KJ, burning her genitals with a torch to check if she was alive, sawing her body apart, and asking Bill to help dispose of the coolers.
During a police visit, Wade refused to open a green cooler, claiming it was for summer parties; an officer eventually peered inside and saw skin, leading to Wade's arrest and the discovery of KJ's dismembered remains in two coolers.
In a recorded interview, Wade claimed KJ fainted in March 2019, hit her head, and he neglected to seek medical care; he left her in a bathtub with running hot water, found her dead days later, and kept her body in the tub for two to three weeks while running cold water over it.
Wade traded a DVD player for a reciprocating saw to cut KJ's legs at the knees and mid-thigh so her body would fit in the coolers; the saw later showed serrated residue consistent with bone.
Cellmates revealed Wade strangled KJ with a white ribbon for five minutes while making her watch a clock, leaving her in a vegetative state before she died — contradicting Wade's claim that she died from hot water scalding.
Wade's ex-girlfriend Katie described a pattern of violence, including a threat to break her arm in front of her children; she said Wade called her from jail every Christmas and she believed she would have been his victim had she not left.
Notable quotes
“Seeing the, you know, the smirk on his face and hear him glamorize about how he tortured this poor woman, you know, it's, you know, just it's just it blows me away.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:04“He said that he put her in the tub and eventually after, you know, that's when all the burnings and everything was um eventually he got a saw and cut her up and put her in coolers and his plan was to dispose of the body”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:17“I cracked it open, looked in there, and seen skin. I shut it and took them right out.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:51“My biggest thing is I failed her as a caretaker.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:18“He said he started to choke her and he said he choked her for 5 minutes. I said, "And I was like, 'How did you know that?' And he's like, 'Well, there's a clock right in front of me.' And I made her watch it."”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:47“It should have been me that she that died.”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:55Chapters
0:38 — KJ's Disappearance and Background: The episode introduces Kelly Jean "KJ" Warner, a 43-year-old transient woman last seen in spring 2019, and her boyfriend Wade Allen, whose dark secret emerges as the investigation unfolds.
1:17 — Relationship History and Escalating Abuse: KJ and Wade met on Facebook in 2013; by 2019 she moved into his Sturgis apartment. Abuse escalated from tying her in a closet to backhanding and belting her, triggered by Wade's rage over her discussing their sex life.
3:30 — Neighbor Incident and Friend's Report: A neighbor saw KJ open the door partially naked; Wade beat her with a belt afterward. The neighbor, a domestic violence survivor, did not call police out of fear. Wade's friend Bill later reported him after Wade confessed to killing and dismembering KJ.
7:43 — Police Confrontation and Cooler Discovery: Police visit Wade's apartment; he is evasive about a green cooler. After detention and a search warrant process, Wade relents. An officer cracks the cooler and sees skin, leading to Wade's arrest and the discovery of KJ's dismembered body in two coolers.
15:25 — Wade's Confession: Bathtub Death and Neglect: In a recorded interview, Wade claims KJ fainted in March 2019, hit her head, and he failed to seek medical help. He left her in a bathtub with hot water, found her dead days later, and kept her body in the tub for weeks while running cold water over it.
25:33 — Dismemberment and Saw Details: Wade describes trading a DVD player for a reciprocating saw to cut KJ's legs at the knees and mid-thigh so her body would fit in coolers. The saw later showed residue consistent with bone.
31:39 — Cellmate Revelations: Strangulation and Torture: Cellmates reveal Wade strangled KJ with a white ribbon for five minutes while making her watch a clock, leaving her in a vegetative state before death — contradicting Wade's hot-water-scalding claim. He also bragged about friends sitting on the cooler containing her torso.
35:36 — Ex-Girlfriend Testimony and Sentencing: Wade's ex-girlfriend Katie describes a pattern of abuse, including a threat to break her arm in front of her children. KJ's death is dated April 6, 2019. Wade pleads no contest to second-degree homicide and attempted mutilation, receiving 39 to 60 years, with parole eligibility in 2060.
Speakers
Sierra Gillespie — Host/Narrator
Wade Allen — Perpetrator
Police Officers — Investigators
Bill — Wade's Friend
Katie — Wade's Ex-Girlfriend
Neighbor — Witness