TLDR
Faith Hedgepath, a 19-year-old UNC student, was brutally murdered in her Chapel Hill apartment in 2012. Despite DNA evidence and a handwritten note at the scene, the case went cold for nine years until a 2021 DWI arrest led to a DNA match with Miguel Enrique Salguero Aliveres, a complete stranger to Faith and her circle. He was convicted in October 2024 on all counts and sentenced to life without parole, but the defense has filed a 220-page motion for a new trial citing Brady violations and evidentiary issues. The hosts, who investigated the case years earlier, still question how Miguel knew Faith's specific apartment, that she was alone, and that the door was unlocked — suggesting an unexplored connection.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The killer was a total stranger with no prior connection to Faith or her roommate, contradicting the universal assumption of investigators, family, and the hosts that the killer was someone Faith knew.
The handwritten note — 'I'm not stupid [slur] jealous' — was initially read as personal and relational, but the DA reframed it at trial as a wounded ego: 'men fear women will laugh at them while women fear being raped or killed.'
Miguel's DNA was found inside Faith's body, on the murder weapon, and on the note — yet the defense argued consensual sex and that someone else used the bottle afterward, despite Miguel telling police he'd never seen Faith before.
The apartment complex had no security cameras and no controlled access; the hosts note that a single $30 camera could have solved the case years earlier.
The SBI agent testified that Karina Rosario's account had stayed consistent since 2012, but the defense claims this was improper vouching for a witness's credibility.
The judge excluded a blood alcohol calculation the defense wanted to use to challenge the time of death, which the motion argues deprived Miguel of a complete defense.
Key takeaways
The case had abundant physical evidence — DNA, a murder weapon, a handwritten note — but no suspect match for nine years because the killer was not in any database and had no connection to Faith's known circle.
A routine DWI arrest in 2021 provided the DNA sample that finally identified Miguel Salguero Aliveres; without that arrest, he likely would never have been caught.
The prosecution's DNA statistics were staggering: the mixture from Faith's body was 170 septillion times more likely to contain the defendant than an unknown person, and his DNA was also on the murder weapon and the note.
The defense rested without calling a single witness and Miguel did not testify, relying on reasonable doubt arguments about lost bathroom evidence, other people's DNA in the apartment, and a consensual encounter theory that contradicted his own police interview denial of knowing Faith.
The jury initially had doubts — particularly on the burglary charge — but convicted on all four counts after about six hours of deliberation over two days.
Faith's family, especially her father Roland, kept the case alive for 14 years through vigils, media attention, and pressure on law enforcement, which the hosts believe was critical to the case never going completely cold.
A 220-page motion for a new trial filed in November 2024 alleges four major issues: a withheld crime lab report on unrelated drug charges, improper SBI agent testimony, misleading impressions about unavailable witnesses, and exclusion of a blood alcohol calculation that could challenge the timeline.
The hosts remain troubled by unanswered questions: how Miguel knew which apartment in a dense complex, that Faith was alone, and that the door was unlocked — suggesting a possible prior connection, stalking, or that he followed Faith and Karina from the club that night.
Notable quotes
“It's not a matter of if, it's a matter of when. We're going to catch this person.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:50“She tied it to the old saying that men fear women will laugh at them while women fear being raped or killed. So suddenly that jealous note, it reads less like a love triangle or, you know, a friendship and more like a wounded ego.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:39“Miguel left his DNA like confetti all over that room.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:55“It's not going to make anything better. It doesn't bring faith back. Um, but to get that I I like to call it not closure, but resolution to know that the person responsible is not living their life as a free person.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:51“It's not fair.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:55“There's a connection. There's a connection in my opinion. I'm not going to go throwing around names, but I don't believe it could have been brief, but I don't think this is the first time that this guy had ever encountered Faith.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:35Chapters
0:10 — Introduction and Host Background: Hosts Dererick Levasser and Stephanie Harlo introduce the Faith Hedgepath case. Dererick previously investigated it for his show Breaking Homicide, spent seven days in Chapel Hill with Dr. Chris Moi, and stayed in touch with Faith's father.
2:50 — Faith Hedgepath and the Night of the Murder: Faith, 19, was a UNC biology major from Hollister, NC. On September 6, 2012, she and roommate Karina Rosario went to The Thrill club; Faith was the designated driver. Karina left around 3:30–4:30 a.m., leaving Faith asleep alone. A neighbor heard thumps 3–4 a.m.; the friend who picked up Karina reported seeing blood on her clothing.
6:35 — Evidence at the Scene and the Cold Case Years: Faith was found dead September 7 from blunt force trauma; sexual assault evidence was collected. Key evidence: a bloody Bacardi rum bottle (weapon) and a takeout bag with a handwritten note reading 'I'm not stupid [slur] jealous.' Over 400 DNA samples were collected and 25+ SBI agents worked the case, but no matches. A 2015 Parabon phenotyping composite didn't yield an arrest. Police lost bathroom blood evidence, which became a defense issue.
14:21 — 2021 Breakthrough: DWI Arrest and DNA Match: In August 2021, Miguel Enrique Salguero Aliveres, 28, was arrested for DWI in Durham. His DNA sample matched the crime scene profile. He was arrested September 16, 2021 — nine years and nine days after the murder. He had never been a suspect; Faith's family didn't know him. In a police interview, he denied knowing Faith.
16:55 — Trial: Prosecution and Defense Cases: Trial in Durham County Superior Court before Judge Keith Gregory. Prosecution emphasized DNA on the bottle, inside Faith, and on the note — 170 septillion times more likely to be Faith + defendant. DA framed the note as a wounded ego. Defense argued consensual encounter, pointed to lost bathroom evidence and other DNA in the apartment, and claimed reasonable doubt.
25:36 — Verdict and Sentencing: Jury deliberated about six hours over two days, convicted on all four counts: first-degree murder, rape, sexual offense, burglary. Sentencing: life without parole plus consecutive terms. Faith's parents gave impact statements; Roland counted 5,000+ days. Judge Gregory hugged them, noting his son was a UNC student at the time.
28:33 — Motion for New Trial and Appeal: November 4, 2024: defense filed a 220-page motion for new trial and appeal, citing four issues: withheld crime lab report on unrelated drug charges, improper SBI agent testimony, misleading impression about unavailable cookout witnesses, and exclusion of blood alcohol calculation. DA calls it Miguel's right; law professor says overturning a murder verdict is very difficult.
30:09 — Hosts' Lingering Questions and Analysis: Dererick and Stephanie still question how Miguel knew Faith's specific apartment (back corner of a dense complex), that she was alone, and that the door was unlocked. Dererick believes there's a connection — possibly Miguel saw them at the club and followed them home. The note still suggests history. They want to understand the 'why' to better protect others.
Speakers
Dererick Levasser — Co-host
Stephanie Harlo — Co-host