TLDR
The hosts analyze Donald Trump's recent interview where he suggested his deportation policy was "too tough" and indicated openness to a deal with Democrats granting legal status to long-term illegal immigrants like landscapers and hotel workers. They argue this amounts to amnesty, betrays his base, repeats failed historical precedents, and reflects donor pressure rather than voter demand. They also criticize the campaign's denial of the term "amnesty" and note the administration's failure to implement E-Verify or target employers.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Trump used his own businesses' reliance on immigrant labor (landscapers, hotel staff) as a rationale for amnesty, creating a clear conflict of interest.
The campaign's official rapid response account lied about the transcript, claiming "amnesty" was never said when the deal described is the definition of amnesty.
Hispanic voters did not support the 2013 Gang of Eight amnesty bill, contradicting the GOP consultant class's assumption that softening on immigration would win Latino votes.
Trump's 60 Minutes interview was a deliberate, sit-down setting — not an offhand remark — signaling a calculated political shift.
Key takeaways
Trump explicitly said his deportation policy might be "too tough" and signaled willingness to negotiate legal status for illegal immigrants who have been in the U.S. for 10-15 years.
The campaign's rapid response account falsely claimed the word "amnesty" was never used, despite Trump agreeing to "work out a deal" for legal status.
Immigration hawks argue the most effective and humane approach is mandatory E-Verify and employer sanctions, which would cause self-deportation without street-level enforcement.
Historical precedent: Reagan's 1986 amnesty for 3 million led to increased illegal immigration; similar deals create incentives for more illegal entry.
Trump's shift may stem from donor pressure and a desire to appear likable, not from base demands — Hispanic voters rejected amnesty in 2013-14.
Stephen Miller's appointment as Chief of Staff may not prevent a deal if Trump personally wants one, as Trump sets his own agenda.
Current record deportations are insufficient to reverse the historic surge of ~8 million non-citizens who entered under Biden.
The GOP briefly pivoted toward immigration compromise after Romney's 2012 loss, but voter backlash led to Trump's hardline 2016 platform, which remains his strongest approval line.
Notable quotes
“I think it might be too tough. Yeah. ... Ultimately that hurt me. Well, the deal would be we would work something out. And I think it's something I think that's something that's actually doable”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:17“Do you mean the landscaper will get legal status? Yeah. Yes. That's what he said.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:33“The word amnesty was never even said in this entire exchange. Right. But that's exactly what working out a deal to allow legal status to illegals is. And everyone knows that. Even a six-year-old can understand that.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:56“Just do E-Verify. You don't have to run around hunting down Hispanics in the streets. ... It makes it impossible for them to collect a paycheck in the United States, and they self-deport. That's the most humane way of doing this.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:46“Reagan gave three million illegals amnesty and what happened? We got a whole lot more. It is an incentive to additional illegals. And President Trump is not going to be president forever.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:31“By the time we got to 2015, 16, who was the dominant Republican talking about immigration in a winning way? Donald Trump, whose whole platform was no amnesty, no crack, only cracking down, build the wall, which to this day remains his greatest approval line.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:47Chapters
0:00 — Trump's 60 Minutes Interview: Softening on Deportation: Trump tells Ross Douthat his deportation policy was "too tough" and suggests a deal with Democrats for legal status for long-term illegal immigrants like landscapers and hotel workers.
2:21 — Campaign Denial and the Definition of Amnesty: The Trump campaign's rapid response account claims "amnesty" was never said, but hosts argue the described deal — legal status for illegals — is exactly amnesty.
6:34 — The Employer Sanctions Alternative: Hosts argue mandatory E-Verify and cracking down on employers would be more effective and humane than street enforcement, causing self-deportation without optics of cruelty.
10:00 — Historical Precedent: Reagan's Amnesty Failed: Reagan's 1986 amnesty led to more illegal immigration; any new deal would create incentives for future illegal entry and could be expanded by a future Democratic president.
10:00 — GOP's 2012 Pivot and Voter Backlash: After Romney's loss, GOP elites pushed immigration compromise, but base rejection — including Hispanic voters — led to Trump's hardline 2016 platform, which won.
8:44 — Stephen Miller's Appointment May Not Stop a Deal: Even with hardliner Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff, Trump sets his own agenda; if he wants a deal, Miller will have to execute it.
7:51 — Deportation Numbers vs. Historic Surge: Record deportations under Trump are insufficient to reverse the ~8 million non-citizens who entered under Biden, a surge larger than Ellis Island's peak.
Speakers
Host (Megan Kelly) — Host
Guest Commentator — Co-host/Analyst