TLDR
Children's rights advocate Katy Faust argues that modern family structures — no-fault divorce, same-sex marriage, IVF, surrogacy, and cohabitation — prioritize adult desires over children's fundamental natural right to be known and loved by their married biological mother and father. She presents social science evidence that children suffer measurable harm when this right is violated, and calls for a cultural and legal shift that puts children's needs first.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A 2017 study found children who lost their father to death, incarceration, or divorce had shorter telomeres — indicating poorer long-term health and shorter lifespan.
Donor-conceived children fare worse psychologically than adoptees because their parents (who caused the loss) often dismiss their grief with 'you should be grateful to be alive,' whereas adoptive parents join in mourning the loss.
Surrogacy contracts often require the birth mother to relinquish rights in the second or third trimester, before the child is born.
IVF produces a 90%+ embryo attrition rate (frozen, discarded, or donated to research), making it a eugenics project that violates children's right to life.
The 'blank slate' cultural myth — that love alone makes a family and any two adults will do — contradicts hardwired child development needs for both maternal and paternal input.
Key takeaways
Children have a natural, pre-government right to be raised by their married biological mother and father, which is non-substitutable and equally distributed.
No-fault divorce removed permanence from marriage, leading to a spike in divorce rates and measurable harm to children's physical health, emotional well-being, academic performance, and future relationships.
Same-sex marriage and reproductive technologies (IVF, sperm/egg donation, surrogacy) intentionally separate children from one or both biological parents, treating children as commodities.
Surrogacy splits motherhood into three purchasable roles (genetic, birth, social), inflicting a 'primal wound' by severing the birth-mother bond at birth.
Adoption should be child-centric — finding homes for children who have lost parents — not adult-centric (fulfilling adults' desire for a child).
Adults must do the hard work of sacrifice (staying married, forgoing biological children if it severs parental ties) rather than offloading hardship onto children.
Cohabitation poses a greater threat to children than same-sex marriage, with higher rates of abuse, neglect, and instability.
Subsidizing IVF does not raise birth rates; it encourages delayed childbearing. Higher birth rates correlate with earlier marriage and cultural support for marital permanence.
Notable quotes
“Somebody's going to do the hard thing in all these situations. It will either be the adults in their struggling marriage, dealing with infertility, with their same-sex attraction, or it will be the children. And for the longest time we have said, 'Hey kids, you do the hard thing on our behalf.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:00“You don't have a right to marry somebody else if it means that a child loses their fundamental natural God-given self-evident right to be known and loved by both their mother and father.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:58“Children who lost their father to death, incarceration, or divorce had shorter telomeres. So, they were sicker in the future. They had more chronic illnesses when they grew up. They had a shorter lifespan.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:10“Surrogacy allows you to cut and paste sort of all a cart, which mother do you need, which one do you not want. ... Surrogacy forces us to inflict that wound on a child intentionally just because an adult wants something.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:00“The adoptees are being raised by the adults who are seeking to mend their loss. The donor-conceived children are being raised by the adults who created their loss. That creates a really significant psychological burden on the child.”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:00“We have said for decades love makes a family. If the adults are happy the kids will be happy. ... But it's not. And children are paying the price for it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 67:20Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Katy Faust's Background: Host Jany Cillick introduces Katy Faust, founder of Them Before Us. Katy shares her personal story: parents divorced at 10, mother entered same-sex relationship, but she entered advocacy not from personal grievance but from 20 years working with children in youth ministry and adoption, observing that no child celebrates losing a parent.
7:00 — Natural Rights Framework: The Three-Part Test: Katy explains the natural law basis for children's rights: a right must pre-exist government, not require provision by others, and be equally distributed. She applies this to argue children have a natural right to their mother and father, which same-sex marriage and reproductive tech violate.
27:00 — No-Fault Divorce: The Original Redefinition of Marriage: Katy traces the shift from at-fault to no-fault divorce (starting with Reagan in 1969), which removed permanence from marriage, incentivized exit, and caused a divorce spike. She cites studies showing divorce harms children's telomeres, increases early death risk 35-55%, lowers academic outcomes, and raises future divorce rates.
44:00 — IVF, Surrogacy, and the Commodification of Children: Katy critiques IVF on three grounds: violates right to life (90%+ embryos discarded), violates right to mother/father (donor conception), and violates right not to be bought/sold (payment for gametes/womb). She details how surrogacy splits motherhood into three roles, inflicting a primal wound by separating child from birth mother at birth.
59:00 — Adoption: Child-Centric vs Adult-Centric: Katy distinguishes ethical adoption (finding homes for children who have lost parents) from adult-centric adoption (fulfilling adults' desire for a child). She argues adopted children need a married mother and father even more due to prior loss, and that placement decisions must prioritize the child's needs, not adult preferences.
65:00 — Cohabitation, Cultural Lies, and the Global Children's Rights Movement: Katy identifies cohabitation as a greater threat to children than same-sex marriage, citing higher abuse/neglect rates. She names the cultural mantras ('love makes a family,' 'kids are resilient') that normalize adult-centric choices. She envisions a global movement that puts children's rights at the forefront of every personal and policy decision.
71:00 — Motivation: Rage at Adult Selfishness: Katy says her driving force is anger at adults celebrating family breakdown (e.g., a celebrity divorce dance video) while ignoring the lifelong harm to children. She insists adults must do the hard work of marriage and sacrifice, not offload it onto children.
Speakers
Jany Cillick — Host
Katy Faust — Guest