TLDR
Detective Susan Logothetti solves the 1984 cold case murder of Judy Weaver using an undercover gum ruse to obtain DNA from Mitchell Gaff, a Level 3 sex offender. The DNA links Gaff to multiple violent sexual assaults and murders spanning decades, including the 1980 killing of Susan Vesey, exonerating her husband Ken who lived under suspicion for 45 years. Gaff pleads guilty to two murders and receives a 50-year sentence, ensuring he dies in prison.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The detective obtained the killer's DNA by posing as a gum marketing team and having him chew and spit out samples during a 30-minute 'tasting session.'
Ken Vesey died on July 12, 2025 — exactly 45 years to the day after discovering his wife's body, never knowing she was killed by a stranger.
Gaff married a man, became a Buddhist, changed his name to Sam Wise Price, and appeared to live a peaceful life after release — while his victims suffered lifelong trauma.
Jackie Brown, Gaff's first victim, was a police officer who fought him off using her father's advice to 'fight dirty,' yet Gaff received only one year work release for attacking her.
The same electrical cord binding method connected all crime scenes, but the cases weren't linked for decades due to jurisdictional gaps and limited DNA technology.
Key takeaways
Detective Logothetti used an innovative undercover operation with fake energy gum to collect fresh DNA from Mitchell Gaff, confirming him as Judy Weaver's killer after 40 years.
Mitchell Gaff (later Sam Wise Price) was a serial predator whose crimes spanned from 1979 to 1984, including the assault of police officer Jackie Brown, the rape of teenage sisters Angela and Myra, and the murders of Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey.
Ken Vesey, Susan's husband, was wrongly suspected for 45 years despite having an airtight alibi; he died on the 45th anniversary of Susan's murder, never seeing her killer convicted.
Gaff was released in 2018 after 23 years in civil confinement when therapists believed he was cured, but he remained a psychopathic sadist who conned the system.
The DNA breakthrough also solved Susan Vesey's 1980 murder, revealing the same signature: victims bound with electrical cords, clothes cut off, sexual torture, and strangulation.
Gaff pleaded guilty to both murders five months before trial, receiving 50 years — effectively a life sentence at his age.
Notable quotes
“He was a predator of women. He stalked women. He assaulted women. He looked for that power and control. That's what fed him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:11“I saw the stuff that makes nightmares. It's an image that it's as clear now as it was 47 years ago.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:08“When you look into the eyes of a shark, they don't look like they hate you. They look like they don't care about you. And that was Mitchell Gaff.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:52“I will forget it now. I'm determined with the sentence that Judge Okoloko put on Gaff this time.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:14“It was important for me to handcuff him myself. He was a predator of women. I just felt like for his victims, a woman should be the one putting the handcuffs on him and walking him into custody where he wasn't going to be free again.”
▸ Notable quotes · 41:00Chapters
0:00 — The Judy Weaver Cold Case: Introduction to the 1984 murder of Judy Weaver, the prime suspect Bill Richards, and Detective Logothetti's decades-long pursuit of justice.
9:14 — DNA Breakthrough Identifies Mitchell Gaff: In 2023, advanced DNA testing reveals the killer is Mitchell Gaff, a Level 3 sex offender with a history of violent assaults, not Bill Richards.
10:14 — Gaff's History of Violence: Details of Gaff's prior crimes: 1979 assault of police officer Jackie Brown, 1984 rape of teenage sisters Angela and Myra, and his 23-year civil confinement.
19:04 — The Gum Ruse Operation: Detective Logothetti's undercover plan to collect Gaff's DNA using fake Zolt Energy Gum, leading to a confirmed match with the Weaver crime scene.
27:17 — The Susan Vesey Connection: A tip leads Logothetti to the 1980 murder of Susan Vesey; DNA confirms Gaff killed her too, exonerating husband Ken Vesey after 45 years of suspicion.
34:54 — Trial, Guilty Plea, and Sentencing: Gaff pleads guilty to both murders; victims' families give impact statements; Judge Okoloko sentences Gaff to 50 years; Logothetti personally handcuffs him.
Speakers
Detective Susan Logothetti — Lead cold case investigator, Everett Police Department
Mitchell Gaff (Sam Wise Price) — Serial predator, convicted murderer
Jackie Brown — Gaff's first known victim (1979)
Angela and Myra — Teenage sisters assaulted by Gaff (1984)
Ken Vesey — Susan Vesey's husband, wrongly suspected for 45 years
Paula Keeler — Susan Vesey's childhood best friend
Tom Junod — Author, profiled Gaff for GQ (1995)
Mike Perin — Detective who worked the Susan Vesey case (1980)
Craig Matheson — Lead prosecutor
Judge Edirim Okoloko — Sentencing judge