Maddow: 'Todd Blanche Should be IMPEACHED'

Original Media · 1h 11m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Rachel Maddow discusses her new book 'The Department of Fate' with Chris Hayes, tracing the Department of Justice's history from its Reconstruction-era founding to fight the KKK through the Red Scare abuses to its current role under the Trump administration. The conversation draws parallels between historical moments when the DOJ protected democracy versus when it was weaponized, and connects this to the 2025 midterm election results that saw Democrats win governing majorities nationwide.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Amos Ackerman, the first DOJ-era Attorney General, was a former Southern slaveholder who became the KKK's most effective destroyer — and wrote his 6-year-old son a letter advising: 'Ask what is right, not what is popular. When you have ascertained the right, try to make it popular. But cleave to it, popular or not.'

•

J. Edgar Hoover's first major operation (the 1920 Palmer Raids) was a humiliating failure — judges called it 'un-American' and said the DOJ 'ought to be shut down' — and this humiliation shaped his later bureaucratic ruthlessness.

•

The Red Scare propaganda included displaying theater prop guns and iron balls in water as 'bombs' — a cynical tactic with 'shockingly contemporary resonances.'

•

A North Carolina state legislative candidate dropped out in September due to health issues, didn't campaign at all, and still won by 9 points in a previously unwinnable district.

•

Nevada elected a Democrat in a district that had never had one, flipping a seat from a Republican candidate named 'Flippo' who lied about his military service and residency.

Key takeaways

•

The Department of Justice was created in 1870 specifically to enforce Reconstruction amendments and crush the KKK, with its first AG Amos Ackerman (a former slaveholder) leading a courageous, legally rigorous campaign that brought over 1,000 prosecutions.

•

Louis Post, a stenographer during the Klan trials, later single-handedly stopped thousands of unjust deportations during the 1920 Red Scare and publicly humiliated J. Edgar Hoover before Congress — demonstrating how moral courage can emerge from unexpected places.

•

The DOJ's structure has a fundamental flaw: it reports to the president it may need to investigate, making its independence dependent on norms and character rather than structural safeguards.

•

The 2025 midterms produced a historic D+13 national margin (largest since post-Watergate 1974), overwhelming GOP structural advantages (gerrymandering, DOJ interference) and reflecting a massive voter rejection of anti-democratic rhetoric.

•

Maddow argues for structural reforms: higher Senate confirmation thresholds for DOJ leadership, moving the U.S. Marshals Service to judicial branch control, and giving district judges more say in U.S. Attorney appointments.

•

She predicts impeachment of Pete Hegseth and Todd Blanche, noting senior DOJ officials are already resigning to avoid impeachment themselves.

•

The Trump-Miller dynamic is described as volatile: Trump's 'feral intelligence' may clash with Miller's ambition to effectively run the government behind the scenes.

Notable quotes

“Due process is not a favor. Due process is not something that you grant people because you like them. Due process is the way you find out whether or not somebody is guilty, and it's the way that your Constitution protects you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:02

“There's always going to be some loophole. There's always going to be some weak part in the fence. It turns out in our specific system, that's the Department of Justice. That's why it's so important.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:27

“The thing that I found so exciting this week was the huge turnout... seeing those people turn out in such huge numbers isn't just like a generically, civically exciting thing. It means that people believe that using our democracy... are the means by which they choose to make their life better.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:07

“I think the Department of Justice... ought to be treated as a different kind of cat among government agencies. And I think that there should be higher thresholds of what we expect in terms of experience and in terms of bipartisan appeal that we demand of people who have powerful jobs in the Justice Department.”

▸ Notable quotes · 57:36

“Not being cowed by people who are arguing against you in bad faith, I think is step one toward reality mattering again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:10

“Trump and Miller is a volatile combination because I think that Trump... does have a sort of feral kind of intelligence and knowing that somebody intends to run the country behind the back of the president while flattering him... I think is something that will make Trump itch.”

▸ Notable quotes · 55:51

Chapters

•

0:00 — Opening: Election Results and DOJ as Chekhov's Gun: Maddow opens with the historic 2025 midterm results (D+13 margin) that overwhelmed GOP structural advantages, framing the DOJ as a 'Chekhov's gun' — an institutional weakness Trump exploited from his first term.

•

7:00 — Founding the DOJ: Amos Ackerman vs. the KKK: The 1870 creation of the DOJ to enforce Reconstruction amendments; Ackerman's courageous, legally rigorous campaign in South Carolina bringing 1,000+ Klan prosecutions while respecting due process even for terrorists.

•

22:00 — Louis Post: From Klan Stenographer to Red Scare Hero: Post's moral education under Ackerman; 50 years later as Assistant Secretary of Labor, he single-handedly halted thousands of Palmer Raid deportations and humiliated J. Edgar Hoover before Congress.

•

33:00 — J. Edgar Hoover's Origin Story: Humiliation Shapes a Monster: Hoover's Red Scare operation was a propaganda-filled disaster (prop guns, iron balls as 'bombs'); judicial rebuke and Post's public dismantling shaped Hoover's lifelong obsession with never being embarrassed again.

•

34:00 — History's Lesson: Good Men, Not Great Men: Maddow's 'good man theory of history' — ordinary people (Ackerman, Post, Army Major Merrill) rising to meet moments they never sought; parallel to Davey Hearn standing up to Trump administration retaliation.

•

39:00 — 2025 Midterms: The Country Met the Moment: Record turnout, especially among Black, Latino, and young voters, rejected anti-election propaganda; Democrats won governing majorities coast-to-coast, flipping previously unwinnable seats.

•

46:00 — Current DOJ Corruption and Predicted Impeachments: Todd Blanche's DOJ described as openly corrupt (pardons for donations, political prosecutions, Ghislaine Maxwell interference); Maddow predicts impeachment of Hegseth and Blanche, noting senior officials are already fleeing.

•

57:00 — Structural Reforms and Audience Q&A: Proposed fixes: higher Senate thresholds, Marshals Service to judiciary, judicial input on U.S. Attorneys; questions on electoral college (Texas flip complicates partisan calculus), staff pride, and fishing stories.

Speakers

•

Rachel Maddow — Author, MSNBC Host

•

Chris Hayes — MSNBC Host, Interviewer

•

Davey Hearn — Olympian, Whistleblower

⋮