Karen Read Jury Split - A Breakdown of Count 2 & Lesser Included Charges. The Emily Show Ep 296

Original Media · 54m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

The Karen Read murder trial ended in a mistrial after jurors reported being deadlocked, but multiple jurors have since come forward stating they were unanimously not guilty on the two most serious counts (second-degree murder and hit-and-run causing death) and only hung on the OUI manslaughter count and its lesser included offenses. The confusion appears to stem from ambiguous jury instructions that told jurors not to disclose their numerical split until reaching a 'unanimous verdict' (singular), a complex verdict form with multiple lesser included options, and attorneys failing to explain the verdict form during closings. The defense has moved to dismiss the two counts where jurors reached unanimity, citing double jeopardy, but legal precedent makes this unlikely. A scheduling hearing set oral argument for August 9 and retrial for January 27, 2025, though appeals will likely delay proceedings.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The jury instruction explicitly forbade jurors from telling the judge their numerical split until reaching a 'unanimous verdict' (singular), which likely caused them to believe they could not report partial verdicts.

•

Attorneys for both sides spent almost no time in closing arguments explaining the verdict form or the lesser included offenses for count 2, leaving jurors to decipher a complex multi-option form on their own.

•

The lesser included offenses for count 2 do not all require proof that Read hit O'Keefe with her car — some only require that her conduct (e.g., leaving him intoxicated in the snow) was a 'natural and continuous sequence' causing death.

•

The judge acknowledged at the scheduling hearing that 'no matter what I do this will probably go up on appeal,' signaling the case is almost certain to face appellate review before any retrial.

Key takeaways

•

Jurors unanimously agreed to acquit Karen Read on count 1 (second-degree murder) and count 3 (hit-and-run causing death), but were hung 9-3 for guilt on the lesser included offenses of count 2 (OUI manslaughter).

•

The jury instruction — 'do not tell anyone including me how the jury stands numerically or otherwise on the questions before such time as you have reached a unanimous verdict' — used singular 'verdict' and likely prevented jurors from communicating partial verdicts to the court.

•

The verdict form for count 2 required jurors to navigate four guilt options (charged offense, two lesser included offenses, each with two sub-theories: under the influence vs. BAC .08+), but attorneys did not walk them through it in closing arguments.

•

Massachusetts model jury instructions for count 2 took the judge nearly 20 minutes to read, covering manslaughter while OUI, involuntary manslaughter, and motor vehicle homicide — each with distinct standards of conduct (recklessness vs. negligence) and causation definitions.

•

The causation instruction for count 2 allowed jurors to consider whether Read's actions (leaving an intoxicated O'Keefe in the snow, backing up at high speed) were a 'natural and continuous sequence' resulting in death, without requiring proof she hit him with the car.

•

Legally, the defense motion to dismiss counts 1 and 3 faces steep hurdles: no formal verdicts were entered, the court never polled the jury, and out-of-court juror statements are not evidence — making double jeopardy attachment unlikely under current precedent.

•

The prosecution can legally retry Read on all three counts, but could strategically dismiss counts 1 and 3 to focus on the OUI manslaughter count where they came closest to a conviction (9-3 for guilt).

•

An ongoing FBI investigation and disciplinary proceedings against lead investigator Trooper Proctor (suspended without pay) add further complexity to any retrial.

Notable quotes

“do not tell anyone including me how the jury stands numerically or otherwise on the questions um before such time as you have reached a unanimous verdict”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:29

“the jury considered being more specific in their notes to the judge but were not clear on how they were supposed to communicate their unanimous decision on charges 1 and 3”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:20

“the law is very much not on their side and that I have seen it as we've covered this more and more that the feeling and the overriding feeling is but if the jury intended to come to verdicts and in fact had verdicts then why wouldn't the court just dismiss it”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:03

“don't be weird and don't do anything weird look law is built on long-standing traditions and when it needs to be modified it is modified slowly and in increments”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:57

“the court choosing to dismiss this case would go against quite a lot of precedent and that is unlikely with this judge”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:11

Chapters

•

3:39 — Case Background and Mistrial: The Karen Read trial lasted over nine weeks. The jury sent a note saying they were deadlocked on 'charges in the indictment,' but the wording created ambiguity between the three counts and the lesser included offenses under count two.

•

9:00 — Juror Revelations and Defense Motion: Multiple jurors have since stated they were unanimous for acquittal on counts one and three, but hung 9-3 on the lesser included offenses of count two. The defense moved to dismiss counts one and three on double jeopardy grounds.

•

21:50 — Scheduling Hearing and Upcoming Dates: A brief July 22 scheduling hearing set oral argument on the motion to dismiss for August 9 and a retrial date for January 27, 2025. The judge acknowledged any ruling will likely be appealed.

•

17:09 — Jury Instruction Confusion: The instruction not to disclose the jury's numerical split until reaching a 'unanimous verdict' (singular) likely prevented jurors from communicating partial verdicts. The judge never polled the jury or asked if verdicts were reached on any counts.

•

23:20 — Count Two and Lesser Included Offenses Deep Dive: Count two (OUI manslaughter) has three tiers — charged offense, involuntary manslaughter, motor vehicle homicide — each with two sub-theories (under the influence vs. BAC .08+). The verdict form required navigating all options, but attorneys did not explain it in closings.

•

29:00 — Causation and Conduct Standards: The causation instruction for count two allowed a 'natural and continuous sequence' theory, meaning jurors could convict based on Read leaving O'Keefe in the snow or backing up recklessly, not solely on hitting him with the car. Standards drop from recklessness to negligence across the lesser includeds.

•

46:30 — Legal Outlook and Double Jeopardy Hurdles: The defense motion to dismiss faces steep legal hurdles: no formal verdicts, no jury poll, and out-of-court juror statements are not evidence. The judge is unlikely to dismiss counts one and three given precedent. Appeals will likely delay retrial.

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host

⋮