South Carolina Republicans Have a BIG Candidate Problem | Bulwark on Sunday

Original Media · 36m · English · YouTube · The Bulwark

TLDR

Bill Kristol and Lauren Egan analyze the 2026 midterm landscape with nine days until Election Day. Democrats hold polling leads in key Senate races but face structural hurdles in red states. Unexpected competitiveness in Kansas and Mississippi, late Super PAC spending, House sleeper races, and the Georgia governor's race's 2028 implications highlight a fluid environment where a Democratic Senate majority could enable a 2028 trifecta. However, Democratic operatives remain haunted by past cycles, and Southern population growth is not yielding Democratic voters. Trump's late travel underscores GOP anxiety in traditionally safe territory. The conversation blends real-time race analysis with long-term party-building strategy. Egan's on-the-ground reporting from Kansas, Mississippi, and Tennessee provides granular insight into candidate quality, local economic pain points, and demographic realities that national polling misses. The episode captures a party cautiously optimistic yet psychologically scarred, navigating resource allocation dilemmas while eyeing the next presidential cycle. The Senate map has expanded beyond traditional battlegrounds, with money following opportunity into deep-red states. The Georgia governor's race emerges as a pivotal contest for election integrity and Senate succession planning. Ultimately, the midterms are framed not just as a referendum on Trump's second term but as a foundation for 2028 governance. The dynamic reflects both a potential wave and the stubborn persistence of partisan geography.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Kansas Cattlemen's Association (traditionally Republican-aligned) refused to endorse the GOP incumbent after ICE raids devastated dairy labor.

•

Mississippi, with 38% Black population, is seeing a competitive Senate race due to weak GOP incumbent and affordability issues.

•

Democratic operatives are "afraid" to predict a wave election due to PTSD from 2016, 2018, and 2020 cycles.

•

New residents moving to booming Southern cities (Nashville, Charleston) are predominantly Republican, not Democratic.

•

Trump is campaigning in Mississippi primarily to boost a competitive House race in neighboring Tennessee via media market spillover.

•

Georgia governor race could determine whether Jon Ossoff runs for president in 2028, since a Democratic governor would appoint his Senate replacement.

Key takeaways

•

Democrats enter the final week with cautious optimism, leading in polling averages across key Senate races but facing structural disadvantages in deeply red states.

•

Candidate quality and local issues (diesel prices, ICE raids on dairy farms) are making unexpectedly competitive races in Kansas and Mississippi.

•

Late-stage spending by both parties' Super PACs in states like Mississippi and Kansas signals genuine competitiveness beyond initial expectations.

•

Democratic "learned helplessness" from the Trump era makes operatives reluctant to predict a 1994-style wave despite favorable generic ballot shifts.

•

House races in red districts (e.g., Tennessee's R+9 seats) may produce surprise flips due to wave dynamics and lower candidate name recognition.

•

The Georgia governor's race carries outsized national implications for 2028 election certification and potential Senate succession.

•

Population growth in Southern states like South Carolina and Tennessee is not translating to Democratic gains, as newcomers tend to be Republican-leaning.

•

A Senate majority of 52-53 seats in 2026 could enable Democrats to hold the chamber in 2028 and potentially achieve a governing trifecta.

Notable quotes

“it's helpful to kind of think about this as like we are in the fourth quarter of a football game. Democrats are up by a touchdown. Um but as we all know, you can go into a fourth quarter leading by a touchdown, and that does not always mean that you are going to win that game.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:59

“the Democratic apparatus as a whole is a little almost like afraid to say that it could be like '94. I think the Trump era they just feel so burned so many times that there's kind of like this almost like learned helplessness with some of this where like they're like just like a little bit too afraid to say yeah, maybe this actually could be a giant wave because we saw how '16 went and there's just a lot of PTSD in the party.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:55

“the most telling thing, and it it is kind of cliche to say, but like, follow the money. The most, uh, if you want to really see read the tea leaves right now, like, I when I'm reporting, I look at where all the big Senate, uh, all the big Super PACs are spending their money.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:06

“if you can drive up, get black turnout as high as you possibly can, um and then hope that the white turnout is somewhat depressed. Um and if you have a really good candidate like Scott Colom... if he can win around 25-ish percent of the white vote... the state flips.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:15

“I think that there probably will be some surprise House races that we're not really paying attention to or where Democrats and Republicans aren't really spending their money that we're going to wake up on November 4th and be like, 'Really? Like that flipped?'”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:24

Chapters

•

0:00 — Overall Senate Landscape and 1994 Wave Comparison: Democrats lead in polling averages but face structural barriers in red states; Nate Silver's football analogy (4th quarter, up by a touchdown); Democratic "learned helplessness" from Trump-era trauma makes operatives afraid to predict a wave.

•

4:36 — Kansas Senate Race: Candidate Quality and Local Issues: Adam Hamilton's personal popularity and name ID; diesel prices and agriculture distress; ICE raids on dairy farms causing rural backlash; Cattlemen's Association unprecedented non-endorsement; late Super PAC spending from both sides.

•

9:49 — Mississippi Senate Race: Black Turnout and Weak Incumbent: Scott Colom's candidacy; 38% Black population; Cindy Hyde-Smith's weak campaigning in Black communities; Supreme Court ruling and redistricting; both parties now spending; Trump rallying Monday night.

•

7:00 — Campaign Spending and Resource Allocation Dilemmas: Follow-the-money approach to reading the map; Democrats spending in 9 states; diminishing returns on ad saturation; tension between investing in expensive Texas vs. cheaper long-shot states; donor fatigue post-2024.

•

18:09 — Tennessee House Races and Wave Potential: Two competitive R+9 districts (Justin Pearson, Chaz Mulger); redistricting aftermath; Andy Ogles' primary loss changed dynamics; House races more susceptible to wave effects than Senate due to lower candidate name ID.

•

26:50 — Georgia Governor Race: 2028 Implications: Keisha Lance Bottoms vs. GOP; critical for 2028 election certification after 2020 interference; Jon Ossoff's potential presidential run hinges on Dem governor appointing Senate replacement; national consequences.

•

29:00 — Florida, Texas, South Carolina: Long-term Electoral College Shifts: Florida governor more winnable than Senate; Texas Senate more winnable than governor; SC population growth not yielding Dem voters (newcomers are GOP-leaning); demographic assumptions challenged; long-term party building.

•

31:25 — Senate Majority Implications for 2028 and Donor Strategy: 52-53 Senate seats could hold chamber in 2028 and enable trifecta; donors responding to pitch that 2026 builds foundation for 2028; Susan Collins model of durable incumbency; Trump/GOP polling unlikely to improve by 2028.

Speakers

•

Bill Kristol — Host

•

Lauren Egan — Guest

⋮